When I first saw a trailer for the movie "A Matter of Faith", I told several friends, "This movie just seems to cry out for great snarking." Having seen the film now, it does, but I find myself with a problem. It was so utterly horrible in all facets, that it makes the last cheesy Christian movie I reviewed look like Casablanca, The Great Dictator, or any other number of great works of cinema.
Basically it's the story of a young girl who goes off to college named Rachel. Her dad hides $50 in her Bible for her to find, but she starts going out and meeting guys and doesn't find it at first and when visiting home, her dad still finds it in her unopened Bible. She speaks glowingly of her Biology prof, who is the only person in this film capable of sounding like a human being who isn't in some sort of wooden speaking cult. Thus her dad visits the college and confronts the professor in his office, who then challenges the dad to a debate. Other subplots ensue with various guys wanting to date Rachel, including Super Evangelical Evan, who passes along "Biblical science" to her dad while interviewing him pre-debate and putting him in touch with Professor Porter, who was fired for teaching Creationism 12 years before. Over the course of the film, Rachel re-dedicates herself to God, she gets together with Evan at the end, the father loses the debate...but Professor Porter comes in and supposedly destroys Professor Karan from Biology (through the use of a complete lack of understanding of how evolution actually works, no less). And the professor is left wondering if the Chicken came first and Creationism is right.
There, with the story summed up, let's hit some snark worthy stuff:
1) The dad wants to make sure she finds a good church and is scared Karan is making her think for herself. Dear goodness, surely you don't mean that people shouldn't think for themselves! Actually, that's arguably one of the biggest messages of the movie.
2) The dialogue sucks. I wrote better dialogue in my Pokémon fanfiction back in sixth and seventh grade. It's awkward, it's stilted, and the only person who doesn't sound like a pod person while delivering it is the "evil liberal atheist professor" stereotype. He's far and away the only one in this film that can actually act! Which brings me to the next point...
3) The walking stereotype is the most sympathetic character in this film. As a devoted follower of Christ who believes we were given brains for a reason, I cheered the villain of the movie in just about everything he did, except singling her out in class over the debate coming up, and saying man invented God. He's funny, he's smart, and while the dad and Super Evangelical Evan try to paint him as having an agenda, he's shown to actually care about the physical and mental well being of his students. Like when the dad goes to confront him the first time, they set up the debate, the daughter comes in and is horrified her father is taking umbridge at what her prof is teaching, and the villainous professor's reaction? It's to make sure the daughter, his student, is okay. For goodness sake, the man gives you a C if you actually show up each class and he can tell you're making an effort.
However, much like Kevin Sorbo dies at the end of God's Not Dead and accepts Jesus, we see similar here. A shaken Professor Karan returns to his office the next monday, barely speaking and takes out the rubber chicken from his box where he made a chicken and egg joke, seriously considering he was wrong about God and about Creationism.
4) The humor was very targeted to its audience. At one point, as Professor Porter returns to take on Karan on the dad's behalf, he makes a joke that the stars could descend from the sky and spell out evolution being a lie in words and Karan would blame it on "clever Baptists". Everyone on film and in the theater laughed.
5) Whoever wrote all of this doesn't understand evolution, at all. Or the Big Bang. Or anything resembling science. Porter never disproves anything, he just says Creationism and Evolution are both matters of faith (ooh title drop!).
All in all, A Matter of Faith is a matter of sitting through stereotype after stereotype. There's a quote about how
Christian cinema's greatest failing is that it's like pornography.
You know the stereotypes, you know the plot, and you know exactly how
things are going to end. Nothing surprised me the entire length of the film. I predicted every single thing. Literally. Every. Single. Thing.
Final BG Review?: 1/10
Bonus Mini Rant: They used the same exterior shot all the time to transition between scenes at the university. Ivy or kudzu or something crawling across a building but kept meticulously off the windows. After the 10th or so time, I could recall exactly what that building looked like.
Saturday, April 11, 2015
Wednesday, April 01, 2015
Palm Sunday
"Crucify Him!" the interactive Gospel with the Passion has us shout. "Crucify Him!" It always strikes a bit close to home during Holy Week, because each time I sin, that's what I'm doing, shouting "Crucify Him!" You see, Christ died for our sins, so each sin, it's as if I'm again calling for Him to be put upon the cross.
It's a morbid thought, perhaps, but one of two that came with this Palm Sunday and one I have time to put into writing only now. The other is just a thought that's been bugging me a lot lately; how we've lost a sense of the sacred in modern western Christianity. As we read and hear the Gospel on Palm Sunday, we hear about Christ's entrance into Jerusalem, with people laying down their cloaks and even the leaves from trees (such as palms) so that the lowly beast of burden He rode wouldn't have to touch the dirt; how the people sang "Hosanna" at this triumphal appearance of a man so many considered to be a prophet. It would have to be quite a sight to behold, and it's not a sight we would probably see anywhere today.
Partially, it's cultural, or so I would suspect. But also, we're losing a sense of the sacred and becoming more corporate, more secular, in worship. "Sanctuary" is now "Auditorium". "Campus" has replaced "church", the building, not the body of believers. The "altar" becomes "the stage". "Gatherings" replace "worship service", "Mass", etc. Becoming "relevant" to people has placed Jesus in the backseat, or so it often seems. I don't know, maybe it's just me.
And maybe I'm just tired of hearing Evangelical non-denominational folks tell me things like "Prayer isn't important" or "If we talk about Hell, we'll drive people away" or my personal favorite for vomit inducing, "God wants you to be rich! If ya ain't prospering, ya ain't right with God. Give us money now!" Or Catholics saying, "We need to modernize the Mass" or "Maybe if we just add some rock music" or "The liturgy is the source and summit of our faith!".
Do you know the source and summit of my faith? Jesus, the Christ. Do you know what I consider "relevant"? Jesus, and His death and resurrection. And so I find myself pondering, if Jesus were to walk into an American church tomorrow, would he be welcomed in such a way that His feet would not touch the ground? Or would we all think ourselves so far above Him?
It's a morbid thought, perhaps, but one of two that came with this Palm Sunday and one I have time to put into writing only now. The other is just a thought that's been bugging me a lot lately; how we've lost a sense of the sacred in modern western Christianity. As we read and hear the Gospel on Palm Sunday, we hear about Christ's entrance into Jerusalem, with people laying down their cloaks and even the leaves from trees (such as palms) so that the lowly beast of burden He rode wouldn't have to touch the dirt; how the people sang "Hosanna" at this triumphal appearance of a man so many considered to be a prophet. It would have to be quite a sight to behold, and it's not a sight we would probably see anywhere today.
Partially, it's cultural, or so I would suspect. But also, we're losing a sense of the sacred and becoming more corporate, more secular, in worship. "Sanctuary" is now "Auditorium". "Campus" has replaced "church", the building, not the body of believers. The "altar" becomes "the stage". "Gatherings" replace "worship service", "Mass", etc. Becoming "relevant" to people has placed Jesus in the backseat, or so it often seems. I don't know, maybe it's just me.
And maybe I'm just tired of hearing Evangelical non-denominational folks tell me things like "Prayer isn't important" or "If we talk about Hell, we'll drive people away" or my personal favorite for vomit inducing, "God wants you to be rich! If ya ain't prospering, ya ain't right with God. Give us money now!" Or Catholics saying, "We need to modernize the Mass" or "Maybe if we just add some rock music" or "The liturgy is the source and summit of our faith!".
Do you know the source and summit of my faith? Jesus, the Christ. Do you know what I consider "relevant"? Jesus, and His death and resurrection. And so I find myself pondering, if Jesus were to walk into an American church tomorrow, would he be welcomed in such a way that His feet would not touch the ground? Or would we all think ourselves so far above Him?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)