Recently, the biggest topic in the Catholic blogosphere is not the pro-life movement. Nor is it homosexuality. It's not the endless debates about modesty; nor whether or not the SSPX is correct about the Novus Ordo Mass. It isn't the seemingly endless angry people who decry anything Pope Francis does to help the poor. No, instead, we are focused on the recent termination of two individuals who are well known to, quite frankly, the entire Catholic internet.
The other day, popular blogger and now former National Catholic Reporter author, Mark Shea was fired from his job at the NCR. Not long after that, popular blogger, mother of ten, pro-life superstar, and now also former NCR author Simcha Fischer was also fired from her job at the NCR. What heinous crime did they do? Well, the exact details don't seem to be floating around as of this post, because it was done "quietly", but people at NCR just happened to email a lot of leading Traditionalist Catholic bloggers about it. Apparently their comments weren't in keeping with the social media policies of the NCR and there had been a growing number of people complaining about their Patheos and Facebook postings. Before I give my opinions, NCR is a private company, and legally they can do what they want to their employees if violations occurred.
The reaction has been immediate. It's difficult to go to a Traditionalist Catholic website without seeing posts that are crowing in victory over the evil modernist liberals, saying it's a blow for the True Church that they've been excised from a position where they can influence readers. Others, not so happy. And that includes myself. Let's face it, Fischer and Shea, mainly Shea, has always been a bit feisty when it comes to dealing with negative commenters, it's part of the charm. However, this never seemingly violated NCR's social media policy before, or if it did, it was never dealt with publicly, maybe there were words spoken behind the scenes, it's entirely probable. So when did their comments seem to become too much?
Why, that would be when they began to point out that other than swearing he's pro-life now, almost everything else about Donald Trump's comments are things that the Catholic Church disagrees with. This ranges from building a wall with Mexico, to his ad portraying all non-whites as illegal criminals in the U.S., to his desire to use nuclear weapons, his criticism of the Pope, his desire to torture innocent people for the 'crime' of being related to terrorists. Their main crime, at least from appearances, is as one Eye of the Tiber commenter put it, "refusing to bow to the Magesterium of the GOP, not the Magesterium of the Church". America's Catholic Church has a major problem when it comes to political identity, diehard liberals and conservatives both claim it as their faith, both say its teachings justify their beliefs, and both groups to an extent are right. However, something I've been dealing with since my own conversion is the constant issue that many American Catholics feel that a Catholic can't be anything but a Republican, due to the life issue.
Comedian George Carlin once remarked, "Pro-life conservatives are obsessed with the fetus from conception to
nine months. After that, they don't want to know about you. They don't
want to hear from you. No nothing. No neonatal care, no day care, no
head start, no school lunch, no foodstamps, no welfare, no nothing. If
you're preborn, you're fine, if you're preschool, you're fucked." I know a lot of pro-lifers who do care about all those things, but the sort of people who led the charge to drive out Fischer and Shea belong to this group.
And the comments against them make Carlin's language look downright friendly. Some commenters who once praised Fischer's ten children, now make snide remarks about how she "surely knows how to navigate the welfare system". Others call her an "ingrate". Some have denounced her as "impure" for making a single sex joke once on her personal Facebook page. The comments against Shea are far more strident and vulgar.
If I had a subscription to National Catholic Register, I would cancel it due to this, but I do not. However, I have spent hundreds of dollars in EWTN's store. EWTN, or the Eternal Word Television Network, owns the National Catholic Register, and helped in my own conversion to Catholicism. However, its placement of the Republican Party ideological purity ahead of decency and the teachings of the Catholic Church, have insured that I will not spend another cent in their store.
Tuesday, August 23, 2016
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
If you're at all interested in knowing . . . the Catholic Dogma . . . that we *must believe* to get to Heaven, and which you have *never* seen . . .
I list it on my website > > www.Gods-Catholic-Dogma.com
> > Abjuration of heresy to enter the Catholic Church > www.Gods-Catholic-Dogma.com/section_19.1.html
The Catholic God knows . . . what we think and believe . . .
Catholic writing of Romans 1:21 >
"They ... became vain in their thoughts, and their foolish heart was darkened."
Catholic Faith (pre-fulfillment) writing of Deuteronomy 31:21 >
"For I know their thoughts, and what they are about to do this day."
Catholic Faith (pre-fulfillment) writing of Job 21:27 >
"Surely I know your thoughts, and your unjust judgments against Me."
The group that calls itself "islam" ... is not a religion. Fully proven by the fact that the "koran" says the *opposite* of the Old Testament Prophets > Section 113.1 of the site.
Post a Comment