Friday, January 04, 2008

Reply to a Phatmass Question

[quote name='CatholicAndFanatical' date='Jan 3 2008, 12:12 PM' post='1441573']
BG, not to hijack the thread but you seem pretty knowledgeable about the Church, may I ask why you are not Catholic?
[/quote]

Well after thinking about this, I've come up with a simple reply:
Fear. Fear of being wrong for 21 years, and fear of being wrong if I made the choice to cross the Tiber. Fear of Confession. Fear of, all people, Mary. Fear of being disowned by my family and cut off in my Senior year of university.

So, if I'm going to come out and say that, perhaps a laundry list is in order, of doubts, of what I've read, etc? Mention the notebooks worth of notes in the past five years? No, I'm not trying to come across bitter, far from it, but you asked a question which I might as well try to answer fully.

So let's see, last year I read (Catholic Literature wise):
Catholicism for Dummies
The Complete Idiot's Guide to Popes and the Papacy
Rome Sweet Home
Born Fundamentalist, Born Again Catholic
Humanae Vitae
Dives in misericordia
An Introduction to Christianity
The Chalice (Okay, I wrote this one for NaNoWriMo)

The Quick List of Issues I've had with Catholicism:
1) Sola Scriptura
2) Sola Fide
3) Apostolic Authority
4) The Eucharist
5) Purgatory
6) Mary

Addressing Issue One: Sola Scriptura

As I told my lovely girlfriend, "Darn you Scott Hahn". Dr. Hahn thoroughly convinced me of how un-scriptural Scripture Alone is.

Anyhow, some verses:
Matthew 28:20, Jesus commands to listen to all He has taught, which implies far more than the Bible shows. Thus, Sola Scriptura is not enough, Sacred Tradition is required.

Luke 1, he writes in addition to what has already been taught to the readers of the original letter. Again, this is showing Sacred Scripture as only a portion of what is needed.

1 Corinthians 11, at the beginning Paul gives them props for sticking to tradition that he handed down to them.

2 Thessalonians 3, Paul again talks about Tradition.

Addressing Issue Two: Sola Fide

Again...Dr. Scott Hahn pwned me.

Some Scripture:
James 2: 19-26, really is all I can think of that should ever be needed for this. Particularly in verse 24, where James makes a point of saying we are not justified by faith alone.

Addressing Issue Three: Apostolic Authority/Succession

Again, I was really ticked off at Dr. Scott Hahn. And no, I've never heard the infamous "tape". ;)

So some Scripture and other stuff:
Saint Ignatius of Antioch once wrote, "You must follow the bishop as Jesus Christ follows the Father, and the presbytery [that is, the council of priests] as you would the Apostles. Reverence the deacons as you would the command of God. Let no one do anything of concern to the Church without the bishop."

Part One, Section One, Chapter Two, Number Seventy-Seven of the Catechism of the Catholic Church states, "In order that the full and living Gospel might always be preserved in the Church the apostles left bishops as their successors. They gave them their own position of teaching authority. Indeed, "the apostolic preaching, which is expressed in a special way in the inspired books, was to be preserved in a continuous line of succession until the end of time."

John 20:20-23 says, "When he had said this, he showed them his hands and his side. The disciples rejoiced when they saw the Lord. (Jesus) said to them again, "Peace be with you. As the Father has sent me, so I send you." And when he had said this, he breathed on them and said to them, "Receive the holy Spirit. Whose sins you forgive are forgiven them, and whose sins you retain are retained."

Matthew 16: 17-29 states, quite famously, "Jesus said to him in reply, "Blessed are you, Simon son of Jonah. For flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, but my heavenly Father. And so I say to you, you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of the netherworld shall not prevail against it. I will give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven. Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven."

The verse in Matthew hearkens back of course to Isaiah 22, the symbol of the keys being for a Prime Minister of Israel. One whom has authority to rule in the stead of the King.

Addressing Issue Four: The Eucharist

Scott Hahn got me again there...pointing out how Jesus would not have repeated himself if speaking figuratively. Amongst other things.

So Scripture and Such:
John 6, just...almost all of it.

1 Corinthians 11:27 states, "Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty of profaning the body and blood of the Lord."
If it's a symbol, then how is it able to be profaned?

St. Ignatius to the Smyrnaeans, section seven, stated, "From Eucharist and prayer they hold aloof, because they do not confess that the Eucharist is the Flesh of our Savior Jesus Christ, which suffered for our sins, and which the Father in His loving-kindness raised from the dead. And so, those who question the gift of God perish in their contentiousness. It would be better for them to have love, so as to share in the resurrection. It is proper, therefore, to avoid associating with such people and not to speak about them either in private or in public, but to study the Prophets attentively and, especially, the Gospel, in which the Passion is revealed to us and the Resurrection shown in its fulfillment. Shun division as the beginning of evil."

Addressing Issue Five, Purgatory

I'm just going to out and out quote Doctor Hahn here, because he peppered an intense amount of Scripture in what I'm quoting. It's long enough I'll even use the quote tag...from [u]Rome Sweet Home[/u], pages 126-127,
[quote]In no time at all, the conversation was deteriorating into another debate over the doctrine of Purgatory. I decided to transpose the doctrine into major key, so to speak, by framing it in God's covenant love.

"Kimberly, the Bible shows how many times God revealed himself in fire to his people in order to renew his covenant with them: as a 'fire pot and a flaming torch' with Abraham in Genesis 15; in the burning Bush with Moses in Exodus 3,; in the pillar of fire with Israel in Numbers 9; in the heavenly fire that consumed the altar sacrifices with Solomon and Elijah in 1 Kings 8 and 18,; in the 'tongues of fire' with the apostles at Pentecost in Acts 2...."

Kimberly interrupted, "All right Scott, what's your point?"

I had one chance to get it right. "Simply this. When Hebrews 12:29 describes God as a 'consuming fire', it isn't necessarily referring to his anger. There's the fire of God himself. So fire refers to God's infinite love even more than his eternal wrath. God's nature is like a raging inferno of fiery love. In other words, heaven must be hotter than hell.

"No wonder Scripture refers to the angels who are closest to God as the Seraphim, which literally means 'the burning ones' in Hebrew. That's also why Saint Paul can describe in 1 Corinthians 3:13 how all saints must pass through a fiery judgment in which 'each man's work will become manifest, for the Day will disclose it, because it will be revealed with fire...'

"Clearly, he's not talking about the fire of hell, since they're saints who are being judged. He's talking about a fire that prepares them for eternal life with God in heaven; so the purpose of the fire is manifest: to reveal whether their works are pure ('gold and silver') or impure (wood, hay and straw').

"Verse 15 makes it clear that some saints who are destined for heaven will pass through the fire and suffer: 'If any man's work is burned up, he will suffer loss, though he himself will be saved, but only as through fire.' The fire is there for the purpose of purging saints. That means it is a purgatorial fire; one that purifies and prepares the saints to be enveloped in the consuming fire of God's presence forever." [/quote]

On Issue Six, Mary

Ah Mary, my hardest to reconcile issue...or person, or Blessed Virgin if one prefers. Funny enough, I think my biggest issue is with the only two ex cathedra statements in church history, both regarding her. If I accept the Apostolic Succession, then ex cathedra statements shouldn't matter, but they do to me. Even if Marian devotion can be traced back to the very beginning of Christianity.

Luke 1:46-55 makes a good case for Marian devotion scripturally, known in Catholic circles as the Magnificat.

Exodus 34, makes a decent point on how first-born does not imply there being a second born, when it comes to biblical conventions on birthing.

John 19:26, why bother leaving Mary to the disciple if Jesus had brothers to care for her?

Revelation 12:1, the 'woman' is clothed with the stars? It never seems to speak of the clothing of souls elsewhere in Revelation, which could support the Assumption I suppose. Also, Assumption bodily into Heaven is hardly something new, Enoch in Genesis, Elijah in Second Kings, Chapter Eight, is taken up by a whirlwind.

Revelation 12:16 also tends to imply, if this woman is indeed Mary, would be a spiritual mother as the Catholic Church claims. As her offspring are the followers of the Christ.

Okay...blogspotting this to not hijack the thread...

Monday, December 24, 2007

Merry Christmas

Adventgif

Just a little thing I whipped up due to the reason for the season...

Monday, November 19, 2007

The Roman Catholic Church

Is right.

The Meaning of Babylon Five

Final Note of The Deconstruction of Falling Stars
spoken as Earth's sun explodes


This is how the world ends, swallowed in fire... but not in darkness.

You will live on – the voice of all our ancestors, the voice of our fathers and our mothers, to the last generation.

We created the world we think you would have wished for us.

And now we leave the cradle for the last time.

Thursday, November 15, 2007

Televangelists

So I sent Eudaimonia a link to Jesse Duplantis's Wikipedia article. She had a good question, "Why do all these televangelists look the same?" I was going to defend them for a moment, then I realized, she's right. Aside from Joel Olsteen, all of them are old white guys with white hair and the same suit on...and they look the same.

Anyhow, she also brought up some good questions on what we value as Protestants on suffering, passion, and redemption. I think the answer is summed up nicely in our bit of a flawed system with a question I was once asked at summer camp, "A man accepts Christ as his Savior and commits a serial killing spree...does he go to Heaven?"

The "correct" answer is yes, his sins are forgiven, even those he has not committed yet. If you can figure out how that works, you're better than I at our Protestant theology.

Thursday, October 04, 2007

"The riddles of God are more statisfing than the answers of men."
-G.K. Chesterton

Wednesday, September 12, 2007

From Nightmare

You Are 86% Evil

You're the most evil person you know.
The devil is even a little scared of you!

Tuesday, August 28, 2007

"Knives were invented because it was too hard to kill a person with your bare hands. Man then invented guns because we got too lazy to run up to our enemies to stab them. Then we invented bombs so that we could actually sit down comfortably while killing. ICBMs were the next logical step, since some people get airsick. If you ask me, the limitations of military technology have nothing to do with efficiency, but convenience."
-Tiro Yamazaki

Wednesday, July 25, 2007

Hope?

Baghdad was filled with a different sound today, the sound of celebrations. Iraq's soccer team beat South Korea in the semi-finals for the Asian Cup tournament.

Then, suicide bombers struck the crowds, killing at least fifty, and wounding many others. This is the key point to the title of my post; these people had gathered to celebrate something achieved by Sunnis, Shias, and Kurds on the soccer team. This war will not be won by force of arms, but by ideals, and by the strength of the human spirit. In an earlier post, I spoke of how Al Quaeda had become an ideology; the only way to fight ideology is with ideology, and the people of Iraq have proven that they have the spirit to fight such ideologies.

We all watched as they voted, and showed off their purple fingers as proof of voting. Now we have watched as the Iraqi people have for the most part, celebrated as one at the victory of their soccer team. Even as these celebrations are marred by violence, some will undoubtedly continue. The most dangerous thing in the universe is hope, and the people of Iraq have proven time and time again that while it may be weakening, hope is something they still have.

Monday, July 23, 2007

Basra Badgers

UK military spokesman Major Mike Shearer said: "We can categorically state that we have not released man-eating badgers into the area.

Click the link to read more about the British being accused of releasing man-eating badgers in Basra. If only I could make stuff like this up...

Friday, July 20, 2007

Random Thoughts

Al Quaeda is no longer a group as we understand it, yet it is. Al Quaeda exists as a group of course, and according to the National Intelligence Estimate, is now stronger than on the events of September the Eleventh; it also exists in a far more dangerous form however. It exists as an ideology.

This is an ideology aimed against the percieved immorality and imperialism of the West, one that offers a message of "freedom" and "Salvation". We are not winning this so called "War on Terror" because we do not offer such things as eternal salvation as a part of our ideological package in the "fight for hearts and minds".

In many of the areas where this ideology is taking root, we are foreigners, another strike against us. If you have someone preaching that it is good to die for God, someone you have known all your life, would you not be more likely to listen to that person, than say, a person from a nation we have strained relations with, who tells you that this person you've known all your life is wrong? I doubt it...

Wednesday, July 04, 2007

Happy Fourth

Happy Fourth everyone! I'm off to the warzone of the family picnic.

Monday, July 02, 2007

plottage

Legends don't die, they come back with a vengeance. Myth always holds a bit of truth. Gods can die. Sometimes the mistakes of the past will haunt an entire population. The lesson of the Setara is that if you want to become a god, the gods won't stand for it.

"Every race within this galaxy has a legend of beings of light and dark fighting amongst the stars, casting them down from the Heavens. This, my friend, is the legacy of our great mistake...

Saturday, June 30, 2007

Well...

Now that that's over with, more or less, I feel a great deal of relief, and do believe I shall continue to pray upon the matter which has been giving me so much sorrow, and anger. Such things are sinfully unhealthy, both in the spiritual sense and the emotional sense.

As the Good Word says, never cease praying.

Monday, June 18, 2007

Guilt

Six years...more six and a half really. I was the one who decided we shouldn't go see him, that the blizzard was too bad, that we'd be risking our lives. Then by morning, the pneumonia had taken him from his nursing home bed, despite the best efforts of the staff.

You see...in my eyes...I was a wretched grandchild. I can remember him taking me to see a giant traveling aquarium when I was six...and I threw such a fit about wanting to go watch cartoons. I can still recall how awesome the huge fish in there seemed, so much larger than they would now, by virtue of my age and physical stature.

I...when he had his stroke, it was right before we were supposed to go to Las Vegas. At first I was angry, it didn't occur to me that "he had fallen" really meant a stroke...and by the time the first few hours in the waiting room were over, I wanted to go off in a corner and cry for being so selfish. They gave him hours to live...it took years for him to die.

I remember not allowing myself the luxury of sleep, just waiting for him to pass on...praying to God to allow him to pass on, realizing at long last, that some things were worse than the death I had so feared. Yet then came rehab...and sometime during the rehab, he had been showing signs of improvement, it was like he just gave up...and we tried to care for him at home. Eventually we had to send him to the nursing home, and for those years...I came, every day after school with mom.

I did my best to ignore him, do homework, watch his TV...anything so that I didn't have to gaze upon the strongest man I'd ever known as a human being just lying there...unable to do anything himself.

I've always been the favorite grandchild...because I care. I may not always show it, but I do...and I can't apologize to him now, for all I did wrong. For all the lack of compassion I showed in the nursing home years...I know sitting with him was a sort of compassion, but I wanted nothing more than to flee.

I should have been there when he passed on, but I was so blinded by my own fear of death, that I didn't want to go out in that blizzard. I thought I buried these damn emotions of guilt, but I guess not...

I want to be there when grandma passes on...I feel as though I owe it to her. Who knows when that will be though...and for one reason, I hope I am not there when she passes on. If I am there at her deathbed then she will be suffering, and I don't want that. When it is her time, I hope she can go peacefully, as I too hope to go when it is my time.

Saturday, June 16, 2007

College not enemy of religion

When I went to college I got a big speech at Youth Group on how college makes people abandon their faith, research apparently shows that this is not the case.