There's an apocryphal quote, probably falsely, attributed to Mahatma Gandhi. "I like your Christ, but I do not like your Christians, they are so unlike your Christ." And that has always been my experience as a Believer and still is. I'm not letting myself off on this one, I can be a wretched asshole whose faith isn't at all visible, but I often try to never let my faith be the most visible part of my being such. And that's what's bugging me in this entry.
A few days ago, I had a friend die. He was only 44 years old, in bad health, and one of the smartest men I knew. I decided to venture back to a website I used to be a moderator on, to ask for prayers for the repose of his soul, and thus far, two people have said they will. Neither of them though, is the guy who is ranting at an atheist about how women should be forced to carry to term even if the baby will be stillborn, or is blasting someone else who said his dad often found it interesting that Catholics act holy at Mass and then becoming raging jerks at the grocery store. He blasted that man's father as being the real sinner. Not looking for the good in people, etc. No, let me assure you, from having worked retail and food service previously, Sunday is the worst day of the week to work in a service profession; "church people" are the most vile customers one can receive. They're angrier, louder, more demanding, more demeaning, tip less, and holier-than-thou than any other customer you'll get all week. And they always assume you're "UnSaved" and therefore, after being the worst witness they can possibly be for Jesus, will proceed to tell you about him.
Likewise, there's a former friend I follow on Facebook, who is a youth minister for a megachurch now. All of his posts fall into five broad categories: 1) Woe is me for being single, I'm a nice guy. 2) Notes that decry things like empathy, compassion, or making your future spouse happy. 3) Church stuff. 4)Trying to whip up a moral panic against a person. 5) Telling people how they don't get Christianity. Today was number 5 and he went on a tear about how Jesus never "hung out" with sinners, and how it's part of the "liberal agenda" to make Christians more "tolerant", "and "accepting" and "less judgmental" of blatant, unrepentant sin. Becoming a "new creature" means that the old one has to die, and that's what Jesus does."
How do you think people are reached, man? If you read the excellent Triumph of Christianity by Dr. Bart Ehrman, you'll see that his personal theory is that Saint Paul would talk to people while he worked and plied a trade. Paul "hung out" with his customers and would tell them about his God. Jesus dined with prostitutes and tax collectors. Or as we would call it today, "hanging out". He wasn't going "no brah, your sins don't matter," but He also wasn't being a jerk to his hosts, unlike yourself. One of the kindest women I know told me recently, about youth minister, "I hate him." She never uses that word lightly, but she uses it for the same reason I do: When a person is so into controlling others, their behaviors, and has to always be right, it's difficult to feel any compassion for them while they try to enforce a broken view onto others.
And that, Youth Minister, is what you're trying to do with the AmeriGod you worship. To borrow from a far better writer than I, you've been raised in a broken system. A self perpetuating harmful environment cloaking itself in the words and rituals of Christianity, but it does not know Christ. You seek to perpetuate that which you have been taught, including your misguided and heavily misogynistic form of "love" for people. You outright state that you want others to become a "new creation" like you have, because Jesus says the old one has to die and you become new in accepting Him.
Dude, I worship Jesus the Christ. But if I weren't a Believer? I never would be watching you. I would think, "If that's what accepting Jesus does to a person, then I want no part in that!" Because since you were "Saved" a second time, and went to a Christian high school, and got involved with your Evangelical megachurch, you have left behind love, compassion, and empathy. Now your "love" is about controlling others. Now your Christ is about ideological purity, not about Christ. You have become the epitome of Saint Paul's words in 1 Corinthians 13:1-3, "If I speak in the tongues of men or of angels, but do not have love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal. If I have the gift of prophecy and can fathom all mysteries and all knowledge, and if I have a faith that can move mountains, but do not have love, I am nothing. If I give all I possess to the poor and give over my body to hardship that I may boast, but do not have love, I gain nothing."
You have nothing man, nothing but your broken system and your indoctrinated desire to help perpetuate and preserve it. Nothing but a lust for power and dominance. And for that, I pity you.
Wednesday, July 04, 2018
Friday, June 01, 2018
START: The Americans Series Finale
The Americans has come to an end, and I had to watch it on-demand because I was at a retreat in the middle of cow country. Waiting for two days was worth it, however. So...spoilers ahead.
Our favorite Soviet spies are on the run as the episode begins, and they collect their daughter quickly, only to run into Stan...Stan who confronts them at gunpoint. This is the scene I've craved all season; Stan must come to grips with the fact his best friends are KGB agents, and Noah Emmerich plays the betrayal in a visceral and perfect manner. Phillip admits, Stan was his best friend, his only friend in his "shitty life". As Stan reluctantly lets them go, Phillip tells him he doesn't have evidence, but thinks Stan's new wife is a Soviet spy...a thread that will never be resolved.
Oleg is in prison at the episode's end, Paige has fled her parents to be on her own, and Stan is seen comforting a heartbroken Henry, after telling the boy his entire family were Soviet spies while he was at a boarding school. And yet, the end of this journey is not failure for our characters, at least our protagonists.
Phillip and Elizabeth have returned to the Soviet Union and meet Arkady Ivanovich, who sent Oleg to America to stop the conspiracy against Gorbachev and the START treaty. It's never spoken aloud, but to those who know history, and who have paid attention in this season, the meaning is clear. They've saved Gorbachev for now, bringing the evidence to Arkady, and START will be signed in a few years time. Phillip and Elizabeth Jennings, nyet, Mikhail and Nadezhda, have saved the world by saving the treaty and the General Secretary of the Soviet Union. Their names will never be known, their work against the same sort of "Deep State" forces Trump fears, except in the USSR, will never be released to the public.
The Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty will be signed a few years after this series finale, on July 1, 1991. Mikhail Gorbachev, not deposed under false evidence thanks to our protagonists, and George H.W. Bush will sign a reduction of nuclear weapons in the world. One month later, a massive coup, one our protagonists don't manage to prevent, will take place. Gorbachev will be held at his Black Sea dacha, martial law will be declared, and Russian President Boris Yeltsin will denounce the coup attempt and its leaders. Though the coup will fail after the Soviet military refuses to fire on its civilians in Moscow, and upon Yeltsin, some units even switching their allegiances, it will be the death knell of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. On December 25, 1991, a mere five months after the signing of START the Soviet Union's iconic flag will lower over the Kremlin for the last time. The Cold War will end, the USSR will dissolve, and a period of American dominance over the world will begin.
We know all of this with the hindsight of history. Our protagonists do not, for they are entering a brave new world, one brought about, because, in the end, they are patriots to their nation, and not the forces that seek to dominate it from within. The finale of The Americans leaves us with a sobering look into the past, to realize that the future is ever in motion. Mikhail and Nadezdha embraced a cold truth that Anderholt has previously stated in his own back and forth with the Russian Orthodox priest, Father Andrei, that we were all meant to be something more. Through that realization, the Jennings' sacrifice all they personally have to save their nation, and for that brief few years, it will be enough...and in their own way, they save the world.
Our favorite Soviet spies are on the run as the episode begins, and they collect their daughter quickly, only to run into Stan...Stan who confronts them at gunpoint. This is the scene I've craved all season; Stan must come to grips with the fact his best friends are KGB agents, and Noah Emmerich plays the betrayal in a visceral and perfect manner. Phillip admits, Stan was his best friend, his only friend in his "shitty life". As Stan reluctantly lets them go, Phillip tells him he doesn't have evidence, but thinks Stan's new wife is a Soviet spy...a thread that will never be resolved.
Oleg is in prison at the episode's end, Paige has fled her parents to be on her own, and Stan is seen comforting a heartbroken Henry, after telling the boy his entire family were Soviet spies while he was at a boarding school. And yet, the end of this journey is not failure for our characters, at least our protagonists.
Phillip and Elizabeth have returned to the Soviet Union and meet Arkady Ivanovich, who sent Oleg to America to stop the conspiracy against Gorbachev and the START treaty. It's never spoken aloud, but to those who know history, and who have paid attention in this season, the meaning is clear. They've saved Gorbachev for now, bringing the evidence to Arkady, and START will be signed in a few years time. Phillip and Elizabeth Jennings, nyet, Mikhail and Nadezhda, have saved the world by saving the treaty and the General Secretary of the Soviet Union. Their names will never be known, their work against the same sort of "Deep State" forces Trump fears, except in the USSR, will never be released to the public.
The Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty will be signed a few years after this series finale, on July 1, 1991. Mikhail Gorbachev, not deposed under false evidence thanks to our protagonists, and George H.W. Bush will sign a reduction of nuclear weapons in the world. One month later, a massive coup, one our protagonists don't manage to prevent, will take place. Gorbachev will be held at his Black Sea dacha, martial law will be declared, and Russian President Boris Yeltsin will denounce the coup attempt and its leaders. Though the coup will fail after the Soviet military refuses to fire on its civilians in Moscow, and upon Yeltsin, some units even switching their allegiances, it will be the death knell of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. On December 25, 1991, a mere five months after the signing of START the Soviet Union's iconic flag will lower over the Kremlin for the last time. The Cold War will end, the USSR will dissolve, and a period of American dominance over the world will begin.
We know all of this with the hindsight of history. Our protagonists do not, for they are entering a brave new world, one brought about, because, in the end, they are patriots to their nation, and not the forces that seek to dominate it from within. The finale of The Americans leaves us with a sobering look into the past, to realize that the future is ever in motion. Mikhail and Nadezdha embraced a cold truth that Anderholt has previously stated in his own back and forth with the Russian Orthodox priest, Father Andrei, that we were all meant to be something more. Through that realization, the Jennings' sacrifice all they personally have to save their nation, and for that brief few years, it will be enough...and in their own way, they save the world.
Sunday, February 18, 2018
"You don't seem happy"
A friend told me once, that I don't seem happy any more. I'm not. Not really. Not usually. I probably should see my doctor about antidepressants, but that's probably not the only thing. I'm far from home and from friends, and those my own age or share my hobbies are students I can't hang out with. Meetup has no groups for anything I'm interested in. I've tried going to a few conferences, but none of them were that good, and one ended up loudly (and correctly) decried as a "shit show".
"Try church, there's plenty at church" people say, but in Catholic Churches that's not true. You've got to be elderly or still in high school, there's no in between. Even volunteering, it seems like no one will speak to an 'outsider' who has been there for two and a half years.
Work is...work. I put in 60-80 hours per sleep and my department Chair is still never happy with me. Well, actually she thanked me for a good job for only the second or third time this week, as I covered the classes of the current target of her ire, and submitted 83 pages of supporting documentation for my merit review (which she decreed not enough and demanded more). I think we'll have another search committee next year at this rate. It causes me no small amount of stress and unhealthy eating. That's why I gave up pizza for Lent, I need to break it as a staple of my diet in one form or another, as work stress consumes me.
It's not like I've had a break from it in a while either. Other than two week home in Summer (and still replying to Chair's almost daily emails) and Christmas (doing the same), I've barely had any time off. I prep, I grade, I teach, and I do my service. I'm on five committees and the Faculty Senate and teach full loads in Spring and Fall, and teach over Summer and Winter, and am expected to work on my research as well. I do workshops and four week summer courses to improve my pedagogy and meeting after meeting. I spend a minimum of six days a week on campus; usually all seven. When I was snowed in for three days last weekend, I felt almost panic, not relief, because I wasn't working.
And I'm tired of dealing with the new breed of Libertarian Anarcho Capitalist Evangelicals who belong to a megachurch back home and keep trolling my social media with their comments on how public schools are "government indoctrination centers" and that we should just shut them down and homeschool or private school, because that will stop school shootings and "indoctrination". I'm tired of them saying I'm not a real Christian due to being Catholic, because they know jack shit about the compilation of the Bible nor about theology. I'm tired of them feeling like anyone who disagrees with them is wrong and is going to Hell. Listen guys, I can hang out all day with atheist activists, and I have, and be treated better as a Christian than I am by you all. And unlike dealing with you all, when I was with them and with the warm and friendly Presbyterians they were cohosting and cosponsoring the event with, I was doing actual good, because the proceeds of that gathering went to help victims of sexual abuse. With you though, it's all about "capital campaigns" and tithing ever more and discriminating and lie about almost everyone who isn't you.
I love Jesus. He is the Christ. And I can't help but think He is ashamed of you for lying in His name.
"Try church, there's plenty at church" people say, but in Catholic Churches that's not true. You've got to be elderly or still in high school, there's no in between. Even volunteering, it seems like no one will speak to an 'outsider' who has been there for two and a half years.
Work is...work. I put in 60-80 hours per sleep and my department Chair is still never happy with me. Well, actually she thanked me for a good job for only the second or third time this week, as I covered the classes of the current target of her ire, and submitted 83 pages of supporting documentation for my merit review (which she decreed not enough and demanded more). I think we'll have another search committee next year at this rate. It causes me no small amount of stress and unhealthy eating. That's why I gave up pizza for Lent, I need to break it as a staple of my diet in one form or another, as work stress consumes me.
It's not like I've had a break from it in a while either. Other than two week home in Summer (and still replying to Chair's almost daily emails) and Christmas (doing the same), I've barely had any time off. I prep, I grade, I teach, and I do my service. I'm on five committees and the Faculty Senate and teach full loads in Spring and Fall, and teach over Summer and Winter, and am expected to work on my research as well. I do workshops and four week summer courses to improve my pedagogy and meeting after meeting. I spend a minimum of six days a week on campus; usually all seven. When I was snowed in for three days last weekend, I felt almost panic, not relief, because I wasn't working.
And I'm tired of dealing with the new breed of Libertarian Anarcho Capitalist Evangelicals who belong to a megachurch back home and keep trolling my social media with their comments on how public schools are "government indoctrination centers" and that we should just shut them down and homeschool or private school, because that will stop school shootings and "indoctrination". I'm tired of them saying I'm not a real Christian due to being Catholic, because they know jack shit about the compilation of the Bible nor about theology. I'm tired of them feeling like anyone who disagrees with them is wrong and is going to Hell. Listen guys, I can hang out all day with atheist activists, and I have, and be treated better as a Christian than I am by you all. And unlike dealing with you all, when I was with them and with the warm and friendly Presbyterians they were cohosting and cosponsoring the event with, I was doing actual good, because the proceeds of that gathering went to help victims of sexual abuse. With you though, it's all about "capital campaigns" and tithing ever more and discriminating and lie about almost everyone who isn't you.
I love Jesus. He is the Christ. And I can't help but think He is ashamed of you for lying in His name.
Saturday, February 10, 2018
"Fellowship" and "Community"
One thing that has always bothered me since my conversion is just how bad Catholicism is at providing a community. If you walk into jut about any Evangelical church in America, they'll warmly welcome the visitor and someone will decide that you're their new best friend. They'll invite you to small groups, or Sunday School, or to some big upcoming event. You know what Catholic Churches don't do? Sunday School and small groups. They also don't sit next to people they don't know. People come with their families, their spouse, or the people they've sat next to since childhood.
I was ruminating on that tonight at the Mass. No one was on either side of me, an island alone amidst the pews of people. As I looked around during the homily, I saw that while I was alone, I was not alone in that. Any place there was a person who came alone, there was a void. No one dared come close, none dared extend a simple greeting other than at the Sign of Peace, where the person who came alone must wait until those who came with others have finished.
It made me think of how long it takes to become part of even the margins of that "in-group" in my experience since converting to Catholicism. After I converted it took 2 years of 7am Masses for people to talk to me. Then I moved to doc program; took 3 years of prison ministry and book sales and weekly Mass attendance for people to start talking to me. Then moved for a temp one year, never had anyone speak to me. I moved here two and a half years ago, and never get a word from others unless I don't wear a coat and an old woman wants to scold me; any attempt to go to an event is met by again sitting alone, even to the point where others will sit down and then move.
It really does seem that people in Catholic Churches hate sitting next to strangers, so people always come in couples and sit by themselves, or with family, or people they've sat near their entire lives. Likewise, unlike Evangelical churches, no one sings, and those who do are looked at askance. Just a rumination after a homily about community and fellowship, and how we're all one big family; because the Lord knows, it sure never feels that way.
I was ruminating on that tonight at the Mass. No one was on either side of me, an island alone amidst the pews of people. As I looked around during the homily, I saw that while I was alone, I was not alone in that. Any place there was a person who came alone, there was a void. No one dared come close, none dared extend a simple greeting other than at the Sign of Peace, where the person who came alone must wait until those who came with others have finished.
It made me think of how long it takes to become part of even the margins of that "in-group" in my experience since converting to Catholicism. After I converted it took 2 years of 7am Masses for people to talk to me. Then I moved to doc program; took 3 years of prison ministry and book sales and weekly Mass attendance for people to start talking to me. Then moved for a temp one year, never had anyone speak to me. I moved here two and a half years ago, and never get a word from others unless I don't wear a coat and an old woman wants to scold me; any attempt to go to an event is met by again sitting alone, even to the point where others will sit down and then move.
It really does seem that people in Catholic Churches hate sitting next to strangers, so people always come in couples and sit by themselves, or with family, or people they've sat near their entire lives. Likewise, unlike Evangelical churches, no one sings, and those who do are looked at askance. Just a rumination after a homily about community and fellowship, and how we're all one big family; because the Lord knows, it sure never feels that way.
Saturday, August 12, 2017
Charlottesville
I love my country. It has its flaws, for certain, but I love it. I love the urban areas teeming with people and the rural areas showcasing the majesty of nature. However, today, for the first time in my life, I was truly ashamed to be an American.
We're 8 months into the Trump Presidency now. There are threats of nuclear war, which have frightened me all week. However, what truly broke me was today in Virginia. Nazis. I hate Nazis, to lift from Indiana Jones. My grandfather returned home from World War Two with shrapnel in his arm from his time in Germany. He was told he'd never work again due to the damage done to his arm, but he founded and ran his own business for five decades. Yet, every week, he would awaken screaming at the horror of the memories from his experiences with the Nazis and the war. I'm glad my grandfather isn't alive today, because men like him fought the Nazis, and their children and grandchildren have become them.
Last night, a torchlit procession took place prior to the Unite the Right even today (where people were encouraged to bring guns). A small band of brave college students stood against them. Today, a small line of clergy locked arms to temporarily block white supremacist militiamen with assault weapons. Those students and those clergy are representative of what is good in this nation; the spirit that we will not surrender into hate.
Today, Klansmen and Nazis and other white supremacists gathered and a riot erupted. There were chants of "heil Trump" and "blood and soil". There were chants against the Jews, against African Americans, and others. Former Grand Wizard of the Klan, David Duke, gave a speech about how awesome Trump is.
And then a white supremacist emulated the terrorist attacks recently in Europe, committed by Islamic terrorists, and ran a car into a crowd of peaceful counterprotesters. As I write this, there are three dead and over a dozen injured from this terrorist attack. As I write this, the President of the United States said that there is violence from "many sides", but refuses to call out these terrorists by name...after making a rather big deal of calling Islamic terrorists, Islamic terrorists, during the campaign. As I write this, the Daily Stormer, the world's leading Neo Nazi publication has thanked the President of the United States for his support of their cause by not condemning them and by not singling them out.
There are bright spots politically though. The President may not condemn these Nazis, but many of his fellow Republicans are doing so. Senator Rubio of Florida was the first to condemn the attack. Senator Hatch of Utah has come out saying that his brother didn't die fighting the Nazis for them to be in our streets now. Senator Cruz has asked the Department of Justice to investigate the car attack as domestic terrorism. Meanwhile, among the Democrats, it has been condemned almost universally, including by former President Obama and Secretary Clinton.
That said, I've spent all day reading things by Nazi apologists on my Facebook feed. I've spent all day watching the President of the United States refuse to condemn Nazi terrorists who have killed innocent Americans in the streets of this nation. And for the first time in my life, I'm ashamed of this country, and I'm ashamed to be an American.
We're 8 months into the Trump Presidency now. There are threats of nuclear war, which have frightened me all week. However, what truly broke me was today in Virginia. Nazis. I hate Nazis, to lift from Indiana Jones. My grandfather returned home from World War Two with shrapnel in his arm from his time in Germany. He was told he'd never work again due to the damage done to his arm, but he founded and ran his own business for five decades. Yet, every week, he would awaken screaming at the horror of the memories from his experiences with the Nazis and the war. I'm glad my grandfather isn't alive today, because men like him fought the Nazis, and their children and grandchildren have become them.
Last night, a torchlit procession took place prior to the Unite the Right even today (where people were encouraged to bring guns). A small band of brave college students stood against them. Today, a small line of clergy locked arms to temporarily block white supremacist militiamen with assault weapons. Those students and those clergy are representative of what is good in this nation; the spirit that we will not surrender into hate.
Today, Klansmen and Nazis and other white supremacists gathered and a riot erupted. There were chants of "heil Trump" and "blood and soil". There were chants against the Jews, against African Americans, and others. Former Grand Wizard of the Klan, David Duke, gave a speech about how awesome Trump is.
And then a white supremacist emulated the terrorist attacks recently in Europe, committed by Islamic terrorists, and ran a car into a crowd of peaceful counterprotesters. As I write this, there are three dead and over a dozen injured from this terrorist attack. As I write this, the President of the United States said that there is violence from "many sides", but refuses to call out these terrorists by name...after making a rather big deal of calling Islamic terrorists, Islamic terrorists, during the campaign. As I write this, the Daily Stormer, the world's leading Neo Nazi publication has thanked the President of the United States for his support of their cause by not condemning them and by not singling them out.
There are bright spots politically though. The President may not condemn these Nazis, but many of his fellow Republicans are doing so. Senator Rubio of Florida was the first to condemn the attack. Senator Hatch of Utah has come out saying that his brother didn't die fighting the Nazis for them to be in our streets now. Senator Cruz has asked the Department of Justice to investigate the car attack as domestic terrorism. Meanwhile, among the Democrats, it has been condemned almost universally, including by former President Obama and Secretary Clinton.
That said, I've spent all day reading things by Nazi apologists on my Facebook feed. I've spent all day watching the President of the United States refuse to condemn Nazi terrorists who have killed innocent Americans in the streets of this nation. And for the first time in my life, I'm ashamed of this country, and I'm ashamed to be an American.
Friday, April 14, 2017
Pilate
Pat of me believes that how a person views Pontius Pilate in the Gospels is correlated to how they view their form of Christianity. One Traditionalist Catholic I knew is all about how Pilate was lukewarm in Passion of the Christ and will burn in Hell for all eternity for what he did...as part of God's plan. His whole view of Christianity is often sharp black and white and tempered with plenty of judgment and hellfire and how anyone who disagrees with his intensely legalistic framework is in the wrong.
Meanwhile, I see Pilate as a more easy to relate to figure, despite being a Roman Governor. He's between a rock and a hard place. If he executes Jesus, he risks a revolt by Christ's followers, plus sentencing someone to die during Passover is an insult to the Jews, which can also possibly cause a revolt. Not sentencing Jesus to die can also possibly cause a revolt. Any way he goes, he's potentially screwed and that's without thinking about how will the Emperor react to another revolt in Judea? Will it be Pilate's head on the chopping block? At the same time, he's a Governor of the Roman Empire, he's had to be brutal, cunning, and not a real good person by modern moral standards to probably ascend to his position. In the end he does what's best for him, and what he believes is best for the most number of people, taking a somewhat selfish but still utilitarian position.
In my view of Pilate, perhaps the most telling thing to me, is that Jesus forgives him, at least in part, saying that it's the one who has given Him over who has committed the greater sin. Pontius Pilate is shaken, but washes his hands of Christ's blood. There, I think, is how I see Grace; God's mercy is capable of washing away even the worst of our decisions.
Meanwhile, I see Pilate as a more easy to relate to figure, despite being a Roman Governor. He's between a rock and a hard place. If he executes Jesus, he risks a revolt by Christ's followers, plus sentencing someone to die during Passover is an insult to the Jews, which can also possibly cause a revolt. Not sentencing Jesus to die can also possibly cause a revolt. Any way he goes, he's potentially screwed and that's without thinking about how will the Emperor react to another revolt in Judea? Will it be Pilate's head on the chopping block? At the same time, he's a Governor of the Roman Empire, he's had to be brutal, cunning, and not a real good person by modern moral standards to probably ascend to his position. In the end he does what's best for him, and what he believes is best for the most number of people, taking a somewhat selfish but still utilitarian position.
In my view of Pilate, perhaps the most telling thing to me, is that Jesus forgives him, at least in part, saying that it's the one who has given Him over who has committed the greater sin. Pontius Pilate is shaken, but washes his hands of Christ's blood. There, I think, is how I see Grace; God's mercy is capable of washing away even the worst of our decisions.
Wednesday, September 07, 2016
9/11 15 years later
I intended to write this post on 9/11, but as I watch History Channel, it finds itself bubbling to the fore now. And it's best to not ignore the muse when she strikes. I'm thirty years old now, that means that half of my lifetime ago, 9/11 happened. The time I was on this Earth before the events of September the 11th, 2001 and afterward are now equal.
When I was young, I sometimes wondered if my generation would have one of those "defining" horrible moments that go in the history books. Morbid I know, but still: Pearl Harbor, the assassination of JFK, etc. I couldn't conceive of what would happen, because we were at seemingly the top of the world, having bought into the myth of our own invincibility. The Clinton years left the nation feeling on a high and proud of itself. Our biggest issues were that we had a President who had lied about a blowjob, a disputed Election count in Florida, and a new President who seemed to invent what were being called "Bushisms". For a bit, at the end of the 20th century, I thought Columbine would be the closest thing my generation had to a defining moment...and I was wrong.
I can tell you that when Columbine happened in middle school I walked up the hill to my grandparents' house as usual and grandma, granddad, and another relative were watching the news. I can remember watching the footage, but that's all I can really tell you about that day, from that day. Though later I'd read books on it and meet one of the first cops who went inside. But 9/11? I can remember a lot of it in vivid detail. I was in Mrs. Secreta's Keyboarding course, third row, second seat from the right. We had someone run in from Mr. Poling's room, telling us a plane hit the World Trade Center...and we turned it on just in time to see the second plane hit live. We didn't even realize, until we turned up the volume, it was a second plane, we just assumed it was the first again. Then Mrs. Secreta let us stop working and watch, she never let us stop before the bell before or after. Part of me went, "that explosion looks so fake" and then, it really hit, this is real. One plane is an accident or someone committing suicide. Two planes isn't an accident, no way. Some guys in the back of the room were laughing at it all.
As the announcements came on, it became apparent the office didn't know things were going on. Mrs. Secreta tried calling down to tell them to shut up, but they'd not stop the principal, with his signature ending of "Make it a great day or not, the choice is yours". Then the bell to switch classes occurred...and something was on the TV about a fire at the Pentagon. Next was Mrs. Garton's science class, where we had a test, and she announced no one would be missing the test due to, "some accident in New York". During the test the principal came on the intercom again to enforce a media blackout, telling teachers to turn off their computers and televisions.
Now this was 2001, cell phones were not in every pocket. Bit by bit I watched more people leave my classes, picked up by their parents. Not a clue as to what was happening. The principal came around to ask us if we wanted to discuss what happened, but he knew what we didn't, and what I wouldn't discover until we left and I got a ride home and KLOVE was on the radio. The Twin Towers were gone. A plane had hit the Pentagon. A fourth plane was down in a field in Pennsylvania (I'd later go get my doctorate only a few counties away). There was a mass exodus from Midtown Manhattan going on. No one was sure how many NYPD officers and firefighters were dead, because so many had been in the towers, no one knew how many people were dead. The President was on the run (though later to return to Washington for a speech that night). The FAA had grounded every aircraft in America and closed our aerial borders, sending worldwide flight travel patterns into a tightly controlled chaos.
I went home and watched television the rest of the afternoon until the President's speech in the evening, there was no homework to be done. Every detail of that day from Mrs. Secreta's class onward is burned vividly into my head. I can, in the words of one person on the History Channel just now, "not remember all I did yesterday, but can tell you small details about that Tuesday." Today my new Freshmen started and for their entire lives more or less, America has been at war with someone, or involved in some form of military action.
It's been fifteen years since the moment that was frozen in history for my generation, and the world has changed, not for the better. We've been involved in two costly wars. We're more afraid than we used to be; I can't go through an airport without being patted down, forced to take off shoes, and body scanned...I say this as a criminologist who used to volunteer in a prison: it is easier for me to enter a prison than get on an airplane.
As for the sites of these attacks, the Pentagon section has been rebuilt and a beautiful memorial of benches stands sentinel outside. In rural Pennsylvania, there stands a monument to the passengers who fought back. Meanwhile, where the Twin Towers once stood, the "Freedom Tower" now pierces the sky and a memorial and museum stand in its shadow. I went there at a conference too, as I had gone to the Twin Towers as a child, and wound my way through security checkpoints for the opening hour of its operation the day I visited. In the beginning it was solemn and quiet; the museum had yet to open, so it was the memorial and gift shop. People in that first hour of the day I was there, just milled about, looking at the names engraved around the base of where the towers once jutted into the sky and now waterfalls fell into the void. I saw names I recognized from a documentary I saw about firefighters on 9/11, made by the Naudet brothers, who went into the Towers with them, and paused to mourn those I had never met, but still felt a connection to, because I had seen their lives through the lens of a filmmaker before that day, and then their last day. However, after the first hour, more people began to arrive, some chattier, some not.
Then I heard a sound that I wouldn't have guessed I would hear there, a child's laughter. Some people were scowling, but I could only smile. In a time when we've been consumed by our fears of the "other" after those attacks, I can think of no better memorial than to know that not everyone who visits the site will be mired in loss and dread, but that there is a hopeful future. A chance to laugh and not to cry.
When I was young, I sometimes wondered if my generation would have one of those "defining" horrible moments that go in the history books. Morbid I know, but still: Pearl Harbor, the assassination of JFK, etc. I couldn't conceive of what would happen, because we were at seemingly the top of the world, having bought into the myth of our own invincibility. The Clinton years left the nation feeling on a high and proud of itself. Our biggest issues were that we had a President who had lied about a blowjob, a disputed Election count in Florida, and a new President who seemed to invent what were being called "Bushisms". For a bit, at the end of the 20th century, I thought Columbine would be the closest thing my generation had to a defining moment...and I was wrong.
I can tell you that when Columbine happened in middle school I walked up the hill to my grandparents' house as usual and grandma, granddad, and another relative were watching the news. I can remember watching the footage, but that's all I can really tell you about that day, from that day. Though later I'd read books on it and meet one of the first cops who went inside. But 9/11? I can remember a lot of it in vivid detail. I was in Mrs. Secreta's Keyboarding course, third row, second seat from the right. We had someone run in from Mr. Poling's room, telling us a plane hit the World Trade Center...and we turned it on just in time to see the second plane hit live. We didn't even realize, until we turned up the volume, it was a second plane, we just assumed it was the first again. Then Mrs. Secreta let us stop working and watch, she never let us stop before the bell before or after. Part of me went, "that explosion looks so fake" and then, it really hit, this is real. One plane is an accident or someone committing suicide. Two planes isn't an accident, no way. Some guys in the back of the room were laughing at it all.
As the announcements came on, it became apparent the office didn't know things were going on. Mrs. Secreta tried calling down to tell them to shut up, but they'd not stop the principal, with his signature ending of "Make it a great day or not, the choice is yours". Then the bell to switch classes occurred...and something was on the TV about a fire at the Pentagon. Next was Mrs. Garton's science class, where we had a test, and she announced no one would be missing the test due to, "some accident in New York". During the test the principal came on the intercom again to enforce a media blackout, telling teachers to turn off their computers and televisions.
Now this was 2001, cell phones were not in every pocket. Bit by bit I watched more people leave my classes, picked up by their parents. Not a clue as to what was happening. The principal came around to ask us if we wanted to discuss what happened, but he knew what we didn't, and what I wouldn't discover until we left and I got a ride home and KLOVE was on the radio. The Twin Towers were gone. A plane had hit the Pentagon. A fourth plane was down in a field in Pennsylvania (I'd later go get my doctorate only a few counties away). There was a mass exodus from Midtown Manhattan going on. No one was sure how many NYPD officers and firefighters were dead, because so many had been in the towers, no one knew how many people were dead. The President was on the run (though later to return to Washington for a speech that night). The FAA had grounded every aircraft in America and closed our aerial borders, sending worldwide flight travel patterns into a tightly controlled chaos.
I went home and watched television the rest of the afternoon until the President's speech in the evening, there was no homework to be done. Every detail of that day from Mrs. Secreta's class onward is burned vividly into my head. I can, in the words of one person on the History Channel just now, "not remember all I did yesterday, but can tell you small details about that Tuesday." Today my new Freshmen started and for their entire lives more or less, America has been at war with someone, or involved in some form of military action.
It's been fifteen years since the moment that was frozen in history for my generation, and the world has changed, not for the better. We've been involved in two costly wars. We're more afraid than we used to be; I can't go through an airport without being patted down, forced to take off shoes, and body scanned...I say this as a criminologist who used to volunteer in a prison: it is easier for me to enter a prison than get on an airplane.
As for the sites of these attacks, the Pentagon section has been rebuilt and a beautiful memorial of benches stands sentinel outside. In rural Pennsylvania, there stands a monument to the passengers who fought back. Meanwhile, where the Twin Towers once stood, the "Freedom Tower" now pierces the sky and a memorial and museum stand in its shadow. I went there at a conference too, as I had gone to the Twin Towers as a child, and wound my way through security checkpoints for the opening hour of its operation the day I visited. In the beginning it was solemn and quiet; the museum had yet to open, so it was the memorial and gift shop. People in that first hour of the day I was there, just milled about, looking at the names engraved around the base of where the towers once jutted into the sky and now waterfalls fell into the void. I saw names I recognized from a documentary I saw about firefighters on 9/11, made by the Naudet brothers, who went into the Towers with them, and paused to mourn those I had never met, but still felt a connection to, because I had seen their lives through the lens of a filmmaker before that day, and then their last day. However, after the first hour, more people began to arrive, some chattier, some not.
Then I heard a sound that I wouldn't have guessed I would hear there, a child's laughter. Some people were scowling, but I could only smile. In a time when we've been consumed by our fears of the "other" after those attacks, I can think of no better memorial than to know that not everyone who visits the site will be mired in loss and dread, but that there is a hopeful future. A chance to laugh and not to cry.
Tuesday, August 23, 2016
The firing of Mark Shea and Simcha Fischer
Recently, the biggest topic in the Catholic blogosphere is not the pro-life movement. Nor is it homosexuality. It's not the endless debates about modesty; nor whether or not the SSPX is correct about the Novus Ordo Mass. It isn't the seemingly endless angry people who decry anything Pope Francis does to help the poor. No, instead, we are focused on the recent termination of two individuals who are well known to, quite frankly, the entire Catholic internet.
The other day, popular blogger and now former National Catholic Reporter author, Mark Shea was fired from his job at the NCR. Not long after that, popular blogger, mother of ten, pro-life superstar, and now also former NCR author Simcha Fischer was also fired from her job at the NCR. What heinous crime did they do? Well, the exact details don't seem to be floating around as of this post, because it was done "quietly", but people at NCR just happened to email a lot of leading Traditionalist Catholic bloggers about it. Apparently their comments weren't in keeping with the social media policies of the NCR and there had been a growing number of people complaining about their Patheos and Facebook postings. Before I give my opinions, NCR is a private company, and legally they can do what they want to their employees if violations occurred.
The reaction has been immediate. It's difficult to go to a Traditionalist Catholic website without seeing posts that are crowing in victory over the evil modernist liberals, saying it's a blow for the True Church that they've been excised from a position where they can influence readers. Others, not so happy. And that includes myself. Let's face it, Fischer and Shea, mainly Shea, has always been a bit feisty when it comes to dealing with negative commenters, it's part of the charm. However, this never seemingly violated NCR's social media policy before, or if it did, it was never dealt with publicly, maybe there were words spoken behind the scenes, it's entirely probable. So when did their comments seem to become too much?
Why, that would be when they began to point out that other than swearing he's pro-life now, almost everything else about Donald Trump's comments are things that the Catholic Church disagrees with. This ranges from building a wall with Mexico, to his ad portraying all non-whites as illegal criminals in the U.S., to his desire to use nuclear weapons, his criticism of the Pope, his desire to torture innocent people for the 'crime' of being related to terrorists. Their main crime, at least from appearances, is as one Eye of the Tiber commenter put it, "refusing to bow to the Magesterium of the GOP, not the Magesterium of the Church". America's Catholic Church has a major problem when it comes to political identity, diehard liberals and conservatives both claim it as their faith, both say its teachings justify their beliefs, and both groups to an extent are right. However, something I've been dealing with since my own conversion is the constant issue that many American Catholics feel that a Catholic can't be anything but a Republican, due to the life issue.
Comedian George Carlin once remarked, "Pro-life conservatives are obsessed with the fetus from conception to nine months. After that, they don't want to know about you. They don't want to hear from you. No nothing. No neonatal care, no day care, no head start, no school lunch, no foodstamps, no welfare, no nothing. If you're preborn, you're fine, if you're preschool, you're fucked." I know a lot of pro-lifers who do care about all those things, but the sort of people who led the charge to drive out Fischer and Shea belong to this group.
And the comments against them make Carlin's language look downright friendly. Some commenters who once praised Fischer's ten children, now make snide remarks about how she "surely knows how to navigate the welfare system". Others call her an "ingrate". Some have denounced her as "impure" for making a single sex joke once on her personal Facebook page. The comments against Shea are far more strident and vulgar.
If I had a subscription to National Catholic Register, I would cancel it due to this, but I do not. However, I have spent hundreds of dollars in EWTN's store. EWTN, or the Eternal Word Television Network, owns the National Catholic Register, and helped in my own conversion to Catholicism. However, its placement of the Republican Party ideological purity ahead of decency and the teachings of the Catholic Church, have insured that I will not spend another cent in their store.
The other day, popular blogger and now former National Catholic Reporter author, Mark Shea was fired from his job at the NCR. Not long after that, popular blogger, mother of ten, pro-life superstar, and now also former NCR author Simcha Fischer was also fired from her job at the NCR. What heinous crime did they do? Well, the exact details don't seem to be floating around as of this post, because it was done "quietly", but people at NCR just happened to email a lot of leading Traditionalist Catholic bloggers about it. Apparently their comments weren't in keeping with the social media policies of the NCR and there had been a growing number of people complaining about their Patheos and Facebook postings. Before I give my opinions, NCR is a private company, and legally they can do what they want to their employees if violations occurred.
The reaction has been immediate. It's difficult to go to a Traditionalist Catholic website without seeing posts that are crowing in victory over the evil modernist liberals, saying it's a blow for the True Church that they've been excised from a position where they can influence readers. Others, not so happy. And that includes myself. Let's face it, Fischer and Shea, mainly Shea, has always been a bit feisty when it comes to dealing with negative commenters, it's part of the charm. However, this never seemingly violated NCR's social media policy before, or if it did, it was never dealt with publicly, maybe there were words spoken behind the scenes, it's entirely probable. So when did their comments seem to become too much?
Why, that would be when they began to point out that other than swearing he's pro-life now, almost everything else about Donald Trump's comments are things that the Catholic Church disagrees with. This ranges from building a wall with Mexico, to his ad portraying all non-whites as illegal criminals in the U.S., to his desire to use nuclear weapons, his criticism of the Pope, his desire to torture innocent people for the 'crime' of being related to terrorists. Their main crime, at least from appearances, is as one Eye of the Tiber commenter put it, "refusing to bow to the Magesterium of the GOP, not the Magesterium of the Church". America's Catholic Church has a major problem when it comes to political identity, diehard liberals and conservatives both claim it as their faith, both say its teachings justify their beliefs, and both groups to an extent are right. However, something I've been dealing with since my own conversion is the constant issue that many American Catholics feel that a Catholic can't be anything but a Republican, due to the life issue.
Comedian George Carlin once remarked, "Pro-life conservatives are obsessed with the fetus from conception to nine months. After that, they don't want to know about you. They don't want to hear from you. No nothing. No neonatal care, no day care, no head start, no school lunch, no foodstamps, no welfare, no nothing. If you're preborn, you're fine, if you're preschool, you're fucked." I know a lot of pro-lifers who do care about all those things, but the sort of people who led the charge to drive out Fischer and Shea belong to this group.
And the comments against them make Carlin's language look downright friendly. Some commenters who once praised Fischer's ten children, now make snide remarks about how she "surely knows how to navigate the welfare system". Others call her an "ingrate". Some have denounced her as "impure" for making a single sex joke once on her personal Facebook page. The comments against Shea are far more strident and vulgar.
If I had a subscription to National Catholic Register, I would cancel it due to this, but I do not. However, I have spent hundreds of dollars in EWTN's store. EWTN, or the Eternal Word Television Network, owns the National Catholic Register, and helped in my own conversion to Catholicism. However, its placement of the Republican Party ideological purity ahead of decency and the teachings of the Catholic Church, have insured that I will not spend another cent in their store.
Thursday, December 24, 2015
Merry Christmas
"Do Not Be Afraid". Four words that always precede the angelic visitors of the Bible, and for good reason. They're not the cute things we depict in our stained glass and figurines, they tend to be powerful and horrible and awe inspiring in their appearances. Yet, they tell us, not to fear.
The most famous of these messages comes tonight to a group of shepherds tending to their flocks in the Gospel of Luke, “Do not be afraid. I bring you good news that will cause great joy for all the people. Today in the town of David a Savior has been born to you; he is the Messiah, the Lord. This will be a sign to you: You will find a baby wrapped in cloths and lying in a manger.” The shepherds went and they gave glory to Him, the Messiah, and promised King.
Around the world, we go to do the same on this evening. Even amidst the world's darkness: A shooting in a mall in North Carolina this evening, beheadings and war being waged by ISIS, the nearing of a possible Third Intifada in Israel, and the demagoguery of fascism disguised as a Republican Presidential candidate. There are so many bad things in this world, so much that seems frightening...but we are told by the angels, "Do not be afraid", because we have found the one truth. Christ is born. And we know how His story will end: Sin is crushed. Death is defeated. Salvation is freely given.
But for now, let us pause and reflect upon that still soft cry of a baby, piercing the darkness. Christ has come to Bethlehem, and though we're a bit late, we too shall lend our voices in praise.
The most famous of these messages comes tonight to a group of shepherds tending to their flocks in the Gospel of Luke, “Do not be afraid. I bring you good news that will cause great joy for all the people. Today in the town of David a Savior has been born to you; he is the Messiah, the Lord. This will be a sign to you: You will find a baby wrapped in cloths and lying in a manger.” The shepherds went and they gave glory to Him, the Messiah, and promised King.
Around the world, we go to do the same on this evening. Even amidst the world's darkness: A shooting in a mall in North Carolina this evening, beheadings and war being waged by ISIS, the nearing of a possible Third Intifada in Israel, and the demagoguery of fascism disguised as a Republican Presidential candidate. There are so many bad things in this world, so much that seems frightening...but we are told by the angels, "Do not be afraid", because we have found the one truth. Christ is born. And we know how His story will end: Sin is crushed. Death is defeated. Salvation is freely given.
But for now, let us pause and reflect upon that still soft cry of a baby, piercing the darkness. Christ has come to Bethlehem, and though we're a bit late, we too shall lend our voices in praise.
Wednesday, November 25, 2015
The Good Samaritan: A Parable for Our Era?
One of the parables that we hear Jesus tell in the Gospel of Saint Luke (10: 29-37) is that of the Good Samaritan. In it, a traveler, implied to be a Jew, is stripped of his clothing, beaten, and left for dead alongside the road. First a priest comes by, but he does not help the man. Then a Levite comes by, who also does not help the man. Finally, a Samaritan comes by, and he helps the injured man, cleans his wounds, and pays for his care at an inn. It actually loses a lot of its impact when we read it through modern eyes, despite still being rather provocative.
Let’s start with the most obvious thing to an ancient reader, if he or she was a Jew. The Jews and Samaritans hate one another. In fact, the few remaining Samaritans in the Middle East, still loathe the Jews to this day. The Samaritans claim to hold the true religion of ancient Israel, from before the Babylonian Exile, preserved by those who remained in Israel, as opposed to Judaism, which they view as being tainted, altered, and otherwise influenced by the Pagan faiths of Babylon. Furthermore, they believe that the most holy place in their faith is Mount Gerizim, as opposed to most Jews, who hold that to be Jerusalem, where Solomon’s Temple once stood.
To the good Jew, a Samaritan was someone to be avoided; when the lawyer replies in the parable as to who helped the traveler, he says “the one who had mercy on him”, possibly showing that he was unwilling to even use the term “Samaritan”. They were heretics of the highest order (even accused of desecrating the Temple in the early first century), held different traditions, and a mutual distrust of their Jewish neighbors. So the idea that one would step in and help a beaten Jewish man on the side of the road seemed to be mind blowing, even in a parable form. The priest and Levite were among the most upstanding people in ancient Israelite culture, but they skirted the other side of the road, but the man who should hate him on principle is the one who was moved by compassion.
This brings us to the second point that the audience would have understood well, and has been cited by the likes of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. during his own trip to the Holy Land. The road from Jerusalem to Jericho, which our unfortunate traveler was attacked upon, is windy and filled with spots where one is easily ambushed. In the time of Jesus it was known as the “bloody pass”. It’s entirely possible that the priest and the Levite weren’t uncaring of their fellow man, or afraid of ritual uncleanliness if they touched a corpse, but rather could have been afraid of the possibility that it was a ruse and that they too would suffer assault and robbery by the forces that had assailed him. Thus, they kept away. However, the Samaritan, the one with nothing to gain by helping this Jew, is the one who would risk his life for a fellow traveler who had been attacked and left for dead.
Over the years, many have held this parable to be an allegory for Heaven and our trip there, from Saints Augustine and Origen, to some in the modern day. Others, however, say it tells us how we should behave as followers of Christ. Saint Cyril of Alexandria pointed out we learn to wear a “crown of love” by first showing such love to our neighbors, as the Good Samaritan showed to the Jew. Twentieth century Presbyterian theologian Francis Schaeffer used the parable to point out that Christians are, “not to love their believing brothers to the exclusion of their non-believing fellowmen.” And of course, Dr. Martin Luther King pointed out, in addition to how easy it would be to rob someone on the road, that the compassion of saving the man is only an initial act, but what if we were able to transform the whole of the road to Jericho to assure it never happened again?
What we now face is the crippling fear of the priest and the Levite. Governors are up in arms, demanding we take no refugees from Syria, people who have no place to go. Common citizens are proclaiming Christ’s name while marching outside of mosques with firearms to demand we not take in refugees. Some are afraid we’ll taint our purity as a nation by letting in Muslims, or people from “over there”. To those who do so in Christ’s name, I ask you these two questions. Do you love your neighbor as yourself? Who is your neighbor?
In the parable of the Good Samaritan, the one who followed the Law, the one who was a good neighbor, was the one who was not welcome amongst the Jews. Now, people come to our shores. They are downtrodden, physically and emotionally exhausted, bruised, beaten, bloodied, and filled with enough bad memories and post-traumatic stress that their whole lives may be spent in the shadow of their journey. Will we pass them by as the priest and the Levite did? Or will we be like the Samaritan and offer aid? Will we follow the advice of the likes of Schaeffer and King, Cyril and Christ? How would we feel in the place of these people, who are quite literally running for their lives? And to paraphrase the French officer in the film The Patriot, is our sense of freedom, as pale as our skin?
As I write this, French President Francois Hollande has announced he will take an additional 30,000 refugees above what France had initially pledged. France, who was battered and bruised upon the road, is willing to return the favor of others, and help those who need it most. France, who actually has a reason to be afraid, is willing to stand firm and be the neighbor to the travelers who flee from those who would leave them for dead. Meanwhile, despite what the plaque may say on the Statue of Liberty’s base, America wants to stand by idly; we are now paralyzed by a fear of, “your tired, your poor, your huddled masses, yearning to breathe free.” We fear we will become “unclean”, and we fear that we’ll be hurt if we help.
Perhaps we need to remember the parable of the Good Samaritan and what it means to be a good neighbor. And perhaps, in addition to the words of Jesus, we need to remember one final quote from Dr. King, as our nation descends into a dark place over this issue, “darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that.” And perhaps we should also take the time then, to remember three simple words. Deus Caritas Est. God Is Love.
Saturday, October 03, 2015
Mass as an Immigrant Experience
Today I went in search of the other parish in town, not the one I've been going to, because I wanted to try Confession there. At first I was confused, only seeing a school, and then I crept inside carefully, scared I'd set off an alarm or something and inside the lobby, saw a single door open. Inside that door, my breath was taken away by a place lit by candles (at least for then), statuary scattered about, and a high altar the likes of which I've not seen since I attended a Traditional Latin Mass. Well...I waited and never got to Confession. However, before I could leave, Mass began, and so I settled in for a liturgy I knew like the back of my hand, but a liturgy flavored in different dialects of speech and careful worn years of experience. As the priest began in strongly accented English from Eastern Europe, I found myself transplanted from the Midwest of the United States to another time, even if it was the same place.
I felt connected to those who have come before me in a way that I rarely do, and in particular have felt three times since becoming a Catholic. The first was walking through the fog and mists to RCIA, in secret from so many who knew me, and chuckling that I was being so furtive about it in a free nation of tolerance, when early Christians had to go through the fog to meet and do so in fear of their lives. In that moment, I felt a connection to them, born of an understanding that came as a flash of insight. The second time was in San Diego at the Mission Basilica there and before the Mass began I knelt to pray and could pick up at least half a dozen languages being spoken, and all around me we were a display of seemingly every race in the city, and it hit me, "Unlike so many 'whites only' churches I've been to, this is what Heaven will look like one day."
Today, was that third such experience. I felt connected for the first time to the roots of the Catholic Church in America, how it would have been for small groups of settlers to bring their faith with them as they lived their hardscrabble lives. Priests were speaking in broken English, other times in Latin. The lectors spoke with very pronounced Scandinavian accents, as if they had just come from Ellis Island, not as though they had been raised here in the United States. And we weren't in a dedicated church to be built as such; no, as I discovered, this was their 50th anniversary as a parish, and they had never left the space attached to the school that was supposed to be temporary. But generations of immigrants to this nation, poor as they were, had made it their own, especially in the years following World War Two.
The priest spoke in his homily about the history of the parish and of the temporary space that had become home to them. How the organ took years to assemble and get to work. He asked what part of the space was most moving to people: Was it the Tabernacle? The high altar? The hand made pews created by those first parishoners? Or, he asked, was it something that he often found himself reflecting on; was it the main aisle? He had watched generations come down that aisle in his time as a priest, new parents bringing their children for baptisms, those children later coming down the aisle for Confirmation, then those children coming down the aisle as bride and groom, only to repeat the cycle again as they brought forth new children for baptism. Eventually, he said, he had seen so many people brought down that aisle, no longer able to walk, but carried for their funeral Mass with their casket upon the altar, the crucifix above them, and also hanging there, the promise of eternal life that Christ offers. I nearly cried at that point.
However, he said, even the aisle wasn't the most important thing in the parish to him, as much as it represented. Rather, Christ was. It seems elementary, but so often overlooked. None of this exists without Jesus. The liturgy is empty without Him, the praises would ring hollow, the words merely words upon a page penned by lunatics long ago. Nothing matters without Christ. and that fit well with the day's readings about love, because we know the simple and often unspoken truth of our faith, deus caritas est, God is Love.
As my experience as a stranger in a somewhat familiar land came to an end, two things struck me. The first, is that everyone should have an "immigrant experience" once in a while in their own faith, as it were, to be able to see things from a perspective they normally do not. The second was another simple truth that is overlooked so often in faith; none of us is a native of Heaven, for the trek there, the embracing of Christ and following that path, we are all immigrants to an eternal kingdom.
I felt connected to those who have come before me in a way that I rarely do, and in particular have felt three times since becoming a Catholic. The first was walking through the fog and mists to RCIA, in secret from so many who knew me, and chuckling that I was being so furtive about it in a free nation of tolerance, when early Christians had to go through the fog to meet and do so in fear of their lives. In that moment, I felt a connection to them, born of an understanding that came as a flash of insight. The second time was in San Diego at the Mission Basilica there and before the Mass began I knelt to pray and could pick up at least half a dozen languages being spoken, and all around me we were a display of seemingly every race in the city, and it hit me, "Unlike so many 'whites only' churches I've been to, this is what Heaven will look like one day."
Today, was that third such experience. I felt connected for the first time to the roots of the Catholic Church in America, how it would have been for small groups of settlers to bring their faith with them as they lived their hardscrabble lives. Priests were speaking in broken English, other times in Latin. The lectors spoke with very pronounced Scandinavian accents, as if they had just come from Ellis Island, not as though they had been raised here in the United States. And we weren't in a dedicated church to be built as such; no, as I discovered, this was their 50th anniversary as a parish, and they had never left the space attached to the school that was supposed to be temporary. But generations of immigrants to this nation, poor as they were, had made it their own, especially in the years following World War Two.
The priest spoke in his homily about the history of the parish and of the temporary space that had become home to them. How the organ took years to assemble and get to work. He asked what part of the space was most moving to people: Was it the Tabernacle? The high altar? The hand made pews created by those first parishoners? Or, he asked, was it something that he often found himself reflecting on; was it the main aisle? He had watched generations come down that aisle in his time as a priest, new parents bringing their children for baptisms, those children later coming down the aisle for Confirmation, then those children coming down the aisle as bride and groom, only to repeat the cycle again as they brought forth new children for baptism. Eventually, he said, he had seen so many people brought down that aisle, no longer able to walk, but carried for their funeral Mass with their casket upon the altar, the crucifix above them, and also hanging there, the promise of eternal life that Christ offers. I nearly cried at that point.
However, he said, even the aisle wasn't the most important thing in the parish to him, as much as it represented. Rather, Christ was. It seems elementary, but so often overlooked. None of this exists without Jesus. The liturgy is empty without Him, the praises would ring hollow, the words merely words upon a page penned by lunatics long ago. Nothing matters without Christ. and that fit well with the day's readings about love, because we know the simple and often unspoken truth of our faith, deus caritas est, God is Love.
As my experience as a stranger in a somewhat familiar land came to an end, two things struck me. The first, is that everyone should have an "immigrant experience" once in a while in their own faith, as it were, to be able to see things from a perspective they normally do not. The second was another simple truth that is overlooked so often in faith; none of us is a native of Heaven, for the trek there, the embracing of Christ and following that path, we are all immigrants to an eternal kingdom.
Thursday, September 10, 2015
A Beautiful Passage from "The Islamist" and some thoughts on it
So, it's been a while. I've moved 650 miles from home since I last posted. I miss my family and friends, but life has to keep moving on. So please enjoy this blog post.
On a personal level, my relationship with God had deteriorated. If we were working to establish God’s rule on earth, as we claimed, then Hizb-ut-Tahrir activists were the most unlikely candidates, God could have chosen. My comrades were heady and headstrong young people. We were ecstatic at the thought that soon a “real Islamic state” would emergy in the Middle East, reverse history, and allow a return to the glory days of Islam.
Yet, as I had become more active in the Hizb, my inner consciousness of God had hit an all time low. The presence of God in my life, a gift from my parents to me, was lost. Externally I portrayed signs of piety to maintain a standing among my target audience, but I was no longer an observant Muslim.
We sermonized about the need for Muslims to return to Islam, but many of the shahab did not know how to pray. I witnessed at least four new converts to Islam at different university campuses, convinced of the superiority of the “Islamic political ideology” as an alternative to capitalism, but lacking basic knowledge of worship. Within three weeks of their conversion, they were lecturing others about the need for a khilafah, the role of the future Muslim army, and the duties of citizens in the future Islamic state. But when it came to reciting the Koran or maintaining basic Muslim etiquette, they were clueless.
When Patrick and Bernie came to ask me about basic verses of the Koran for recital in prayers after they had delivered sermons at prayer rooms in universities, I began to realize how little these people knew about the Koran. I was getting older and the Hizb seemed suddenly like pretentious, counterfeit intellectualism.
Despite huge political success, I despised myself for appearing pious and upright in Muslim eyes when all the while I knew there was a vacuum in my soul where God should be. I spoke to several Hizb-ut-Tahrir members about this and they were unanimous in saying that this was my personal responsibility. That response annoyed me. They were shirking responsibility for developing the Islamicness of their Islamic recruits – but content to use these same recruits to promote a seemingly Islamic cause. I was not persuaded.
I went to the top. I found myself alone with Omar Bakri one night in a car on the way to a mosque in Edmonton. I put it to him that we were not sufficiently Muslim in our personal lives and asked how we could establish the Islamic state if we, as a group, did not master the acts with which we earn God’s pleasure. How did we expect Muslims to trust us? Omar was candid: he agreed. He went as far as saying that the founder of the Hizb believed members of the group, especially in the 1970s Middle East, were not sufficiently pious. Why else was God withholding the state from Hizb-ut-Tahrir? Nabhani had believed that within thirteen years of the Hizb’s establishment, the Islamic state would be set up. In later life he blamed his members’ distance from God for the Hizb’s failure to secure the state. But the effort to gain a state never evaporated. If anything it increased in intensity. Omar said that he had noticed vast gaps in the knowledge of group members in the 1990s. Omar reassured me that something out be done; a training session had to be held. Months passed and nothing happened. I approached Jamal Harwood, a leading Hizb apparatchik and city accountant. He instructed the shahab to pray at mosques ‘to show Muslims we were serious, to provide leadership’. As usual, prayers were linked to political ambitions, but at least instructions to worship were given. Still nothing changed: members knew that prayers were not the first priority. Islam’s first command to Muslims, but not of much interest to Islamism’s activists.
We continued to disrupt meetings of other Muslim groups, to plaster the walls of inner-city London with our posters late into the night, come home in the early hours of the morning, and go to bed without saying our prayers. We were too tired to pray; establishing the Islamic state was more important than minor matters such as praying, reciting the Koran, giving to charity, or being kind to our parents and fellow Muslims.
At home, I no longer knew I had a family. By day I was active on campus, and in the evenings I kept myself away from my parents and siblings. I could not bear discussions with my parents any longer. All subjects returned to what my father called my “going astroy to the enemies of Islam”. Those words angered me. My life was consumed by fury, inner confusion, a desire to dominate everything, and my abject failure to be a good Muslim. I had started out on this journey “wanting more Islam” and ended up losing its essence.
Nevertheless, in public, I was still the mighty leader of the Hizb on campus, the challenger of the kuffar in the name of Islam, the leader of the Muslims. I went around college with Majid and many of our new recruits, maintaining our visible presence and making ourselves available to the ummah. Of the many faced I encountered on a daily basis there was one belonging to a girl called Faye that did what mine used to do a lot: smile. As an Islamist I had lost my ability to smile. Every time I approached Faye with an invitation to our meetings, she smiled, accepted, then failed to turn up. Faye confounded me, I wanted to get to know her more. Slowly, we became very good friends.
Faye was no ordinary girl: her genuine and illuminating smile, caring eyes, her endearing face with its olive complexion, her warm ways, drew me to her. I discovered that we had identical ancestral and social backgrounds, a common interest in Arabic, and a shared desire to travel. In time we realized that our friendship was no longer platonic. The new threshold of our relationship to mark a milestone in many ways.
We could write to each other, and Faye’s letters and verses spoke of a God that was close, loving, caring, facilitating, forgiving, and merciful. Faye was close to God: she prayed regularly, I , by contrast, believed in a God who was full of vengeance, a legislator, a controller, a punisher.
I could not envisage a future without Faye. I marshalled sufficient courage to write and ask if she would consider me for a future husband. She paused for thought for a week and eventually said yes, but only on condition that we both complete our studies and pursue careers. Love illuminated beyond all expectations. For the first time in many years, I was uplifted from within.
-From Ed Husain’s The Islamist.
When I read this passage the other day, it spoke to me. I know I’ve been in a similar position before; so worried about pleasing God and acting “the right way” that prayers and relationship with Him have gone by the wayside. It’s why I make such an effort not to get drawn into arguments where legalism can rear its ugly head.
Yet, as I stay on Facebook and a few Christian websites of various denominations, this is what I see time and again. Imagine the horror that some of the people I know would feel, if they thought I were comparing them to a man who once sought the overthrown of the British government and the institution of a new Islamic state. A man who attended halaqa cells and whose group influenced the creation of the ideology of Al Quaeda. And yet, that is what this reminds me of. So many people I know who are so full of “this is how Tradition works, just do it, don’t bother understanding, just follow the orders”. Tradition, without knowing why it is done, and without genuine faith and love is dead.
So many people I know are wrapped up in their Christian culture bubble that anything outside of the bubble should be declared haram, forbidden for Christians to indulge in. I know people who have non-ironically suggested burning books for not being Christian. And yet, wrapped up in that bubble, are the commands of Christ really followed, or is it like Ed discovered, he was not really holding to the pillars of his Islamic faith.
And so many I know are wrapped up in their pride for being some sort of super Christian, posting nothing but statuses about God or Bible verses. Swift to condemn those who disagree with them as lacking in Truth. And you know what I notice, as someone who is just trying to live the faith? Those people so rarely smile in their photos. And they often speak of the wrath and vengeance of God, a God who is a controller and punisher, as Ed states here. But that’s not who God is.
Deus caritas est. Three simple Latin words, one meaning that transcends all. God. Is. Love. Ed discovers that through his talking about God with his future (and as of the book, wife of four years) wife, Faye. We discover that in Scripture and through our interactions with others. Saint Paul, not exactly known as the fluffiest and most huggable of guys says in 1 Corinthians 13,
“If I speak in the tongues of men or of angels, but do not have love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal. If I have the gift of prophecy and can fathom all mysteries and all knowledge, and if I have a faith that can move mountains, but do not have love, I am nothing. If I give all I possess to the poor and give over my body to hardship that I may boast, but do not have love, I gain nothing.
“Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It does not dishonor others, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil, but rejoices with truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always perseveres.
“Love never fails. But where there are prophecies, they will cease; where there are tongues, they will be stilled; where there is knowledge, it will pass away. For we know in part and we prophesy in part, but when completeness comes, what is in part disappears…and now these three remain: faith, hope, and love. But the greatest of these is love.”
Some may read this and go, “oh all of this is hippie dippie bullshit”. Some may read this and go, “oh I totally agree”. Really, I don’t care. What I do care about is that far too often we become so enamored with “the cause”, be it Tradition at the expense of Love, Christian Culture at the expense of Love, legalism at the expense of Love, or even trying to proclaim how much we love and care for others, at the expense of actual Love. We make false idols all too often, out of things which should help us on our journey, and then get sidetracked for days, months, years, decades, or even a lifetime.
In Ed’s case, it took falling in love, to remember the God of love that he had known as a child, rather than a God whose cause was political. What does it take each of us to do the same? Deus caritas est.
Tomorrow is the fourteenth anniversary of the 9/11 attacks. It would not be wrong to say that the course of history was changed by nineteen men hijacking four planes. Ninety-two nations would lose a combined three thousand plus individuals, each of them someone’s relative, friend, or beloved. The march towards war would begin, the butterflies of those wars would take flight. Fourteen years later, we still deal with the repercussions of repercussions begun on that day. U.S. soldiers are still in Afghanistan and Iraq, though the latter had nothing to do with 9/11. The Arab Spring, so full of hope, lies in ashes of sectarian strife and civil wars. The greatest refugee crisis the world has known since the end of the Second World War is well under way. A group seeking the Hizb’s establishment of an Islamic State rampages across the Middle East, destroying lives, temples, towns, and priceless historical relics.
There are so many things that are easy to get caught up in, so many causes that need help, so many people who are displaced. And it’s not wrong to help people. It’s not wrong to get involved in a cause. It’s not wrong to be involved with something that you can use to aid yourself in worship and in things that should be supplementary to the faith. We just need to remember to do so out of love, lest we lose track of Him who is Love incarnate.
On a personal level, my relationship with God had deteriorated. If we were working to establish God’s rule on earth, as we claimed, then Hizb-ut-Tahrir activists were the most unlikely candidates, God could have chosen. My comrades were heady and headstrong young people. We were ecstatic at the thought that soon a “real Islamic state” would emergy in the Middle East, reverse history, and allow a return to the glory days of Islam.
Yet, as I had become more active in the Hizb, my inner consciousness of God had hit an all time low. The presence of God in my life, a gift from my parents to me, was lost. Externally I portrayed signs of piety to maintain a standing among my target audience, but I was no longer an observant Muslim.
We sermonized about the need for Muslims to return to Islam, but many of the shahab did not know how to pray. I witnessed at least four new converts to Islam at different university campuses, convinced of the superiority of the “Islamic political ideology” as an alternative to capitalism, but lacking basic knowledge of worship. Within three weeks of their conversion, they were lecturing others about the need for a khilafah, the role of the future Muslim army, and the duties of citizens in the future Islamic state. But when it came to reciting the Koran or maintaining basic Muslim etiquette, they were clueless.
When Patrick and Bernie came to ask me about basic verses of the Koran for recital in prayers after they had delivered sermons at prayer rooms in universities, I began to realize how little these people knew about the Koran. I was getting older and the Hizb seemed suddenly like pretentious, counterfeit intellectualism.
Despite huge political success, I despised myself for appearing pious and upright in Muslim eyes when all the while I knew there was a vacuum in my soul where God should be. I spoke to several Hizb-ut-Tahrir members about this and they were unanimous in saying that this was my personal responsibility. That response annoyed me. They were shirking responsibility for developing the Islamicness of their Islamic recruits – but content to use these same recruits to promote a seemingly Islamic cause. I was not persuaded.
I went to the top. I found myself alone with Omar Bakri one night in a car on the way to a mosque in Edmonton. I put it to him that we were not sufficiently Muslim in our personal lives and asked how we could establish the Islamic state if we, as a group, did not master the acts with which we earn God’s pleasure. How did we expect Muslims to trust us? Omar was candid: he agreed. He went as far as saying that the founder of the Hizb believed members of the group, especially in the 1970s Middle East, were not sufficiently pious. Why else was God withholding the state from Hizb-ut-Tahrir? Nabhani had believed that within thirteen years of the Hizb’s establishment, the Islamic state would be set up. In later life he blamed his members’ distance from God for the Hizb’s failure to secure the state. But the effort to gain a state never evaporated. If anything it increased in intensity. Omar said that he had noticed vast gaps in the knowledge of group members in the 1990s. Omar reassured me that something out be done; a training session had to be held. Months passed and nothing happened. I approached Jamal Harwood, a leading Hizb apparatchik and city accountant. He instructed the shahab to pray at mosques ‘to show Muslims we were serious, to provide leadership’. As usual, prayers were linked to political ambitions, but at least instructions to worship were given. Still nothing changed: members knew that prayers were not the first priority. Islam’s first command to Muslims, but not of much interest to Islamism’s activists.
We continued to disrupt meetings of other Muslim groups, to plaster the walls of inner-city London with our posters late into the night, come home in the early hours of the morning, and go to bed without saying our prayers. We were too tired to pray; establishing the Islamic state was more important than minor matters such as praying, reciting the Koran, giving to charity, or being kind to our parents and fellow Muslims.
At home, I no longer knew I had a family. By day I was active on campus, and in the evenings I kept myself away from my parents and siblings. I could not bear discussions with my parents any longer. All subjects returned to what my father called my “going astroy to the enemies of Islam”. Those words angered me. My life was consumed by fury, inner confusion, a desire to dominate everything, and my abject failure to be a good Muslim. I had started out on this journey “wanting more Islam” and ended up losing its essence.
Nevertheless, in public, I was still the mighty leader of the Hizb on campus, the challenger of the kuffar in the name of Islam, the leader of the Muslims. I went around college with Majid and many of our new recruits, maintaining our visible presence and making ourselves available to the ummah. Of the many faced I encountered on a daily basis there was one belonging to a girl called Faye that did what mine used to do a lot: smile. As an Islamist I had lost my ability to smile. Every time I approached Faye with an invitation to our meetings, she smiled, accepted, then failed to turn up. Faye confounded me, I wanted to get to know her more. Slowly, we became very good friends.
Faye was no ordinary girl: her genuine and illuminating smile, caring eyes, her endearing face with its olive complexion, her warm ways, drew me to her. I discovered that we had identical ancestral and social backgrounds, a common interest in Arabic, and a shared desire to travel. In time we realized that our friendship was no longer platonic. The new threshold of our relationship to mark a milestone in many ways.
We could write to each other, and Faye’s letters and verses spoke of a God that was close, loving, caring, facilitating, forgiving, and merciful. Faye was close to God: she prayed regularly, I , by contrast, believed in a God who was full of vengeance, a legislator, a controller, a punisher.
I could not envisage a future without Faye. I marshalled sufficient courage to write and ask if she would consider me for a future husband. She paused for thought for a week and eventually said yes, but only on condition that we both complete our studies and pursue careers. Love illuminated beyond all expectations. For the first time in many years, I was uplifted from within.
-From Ed Husain’s The Islamist.
When I read this passage the other day, it spoke to me. I know I’ve been in a similar position before; so worried about pleasing God and acting “the right way” that prayers and relationship with Him have gone by the wayside. It’s why I make such an effort not to get drawn into arguments where legalism can rear its ugly head.
Yet, as I stay on Facebook and a few Christian websites of various denominations, this is what I see time and again. Imagine the horror that some of the people I know would feel, if they thought I were comparing them to a man who once sought the overthrown of the British government and the institution of a new Islamic state. A man who attended halaqa cells and whose group influenced the creation of the ideology of Al Quaeda. And yet, that is what this reminds me of. So many people I know who are so full of “this is how Tradition works, just do it, don’t bother understanding, just follow the orders”. Tradition, without knowing why it is done, and without genuine faith and love is dead.
So many people I know are wrapped up in their Christian culture bubble that anything outside of the bubble should be declared haram, forbidden for Christians to indulge in. I know people who have non-ironically suggested burning books for not being Christian. And yet, wrapped up in that bubble, are the commands of Christ really followed, or is it like Ed discovered, he was not really holding to the pillars of his Islamic faith.
And so many I know are wrapped up in their pride for being some sort of super Christian, posting nothing but statuses about God or Bible verses. Swift to condemn those who disagree with them as lacking in Truth. And you know what I notice, as someone who is just trying to live the faith? Those people so rarely smile in their photos. And they often speak of the wrath and vengeance of God, a God who is a controller and punisher, as Ed states here. But that’s not who God is.
Deus caritas est. Three simple Latin words, one meaning that transcends all. God. Is. Love. Ed discovers that through his talking about God with his future (and as of the book, wife of four years) wife, Faye. We discover that in Scripture and through our interactions with others. Saint Paul, not exactly known as the fluffiest and most huggable of guys says in 1 Corinthians 13,
“If I speak in the tongues of men or of angels, but do not have love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal. If I have the gift of prophecy and can fathom all mysteries and all knowledge, and if I have a faith that can move mountains, but do not have love, I am nothing. If I give all I possess to the poor and give over my body to hardship that I may boast, but do not have love, I gain nothing.
“Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It does not dishonor others, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil, but rejoices with truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always perseveres.
“Love never fails. But where there are prophecies, they will cease; where there are tongues, they will be stilled; where there is knowledge, it will pass away. For we know in part and we prophesy in part, but when completeness comes, what is in part disappears…and now these three remain: faith, hope, and love. But the greatest of these is love.”
Some may read this and go, “oh all of this is hippie dippie bullshit”. Some may read this and go, “oh I totally agree”. Really, I don’t care. What I do care about is that far too often we become so enamored with “the cause”, be it Tradition at the expense of Love, Christian Culture at the expense of Love, legalism at the expense of Love, or even trying to proclaim how much we love and care for others, at the expense of actual Love. We make false idols all too often, out of things which should help us on our journey, and then get sidetracked for days, months, years, decades, or even a lifetime.
In Ed’s case, it took falling in love, to remember the God of love that he had known as a child, rather than a God whose cause was political. What does it take each of us to do the same? Deus caritas est.
Tomorrow is the fourteenth anniversary of the 9/11 attacks. It would not be wrong to say that the course of history was changed by nineteen men hijacking four planes. Ninety-two nations would lose a combined three thousand plus individuals, each of them someone’s relative, friend, or beloved. The march towards war would begin, the butterflies of those wars would take flight. Fourteen years later, we still deal with the repercussions of repercussions begun on that day. U.S. soldiers are still in Afghanistan and Iraq, though the latter had nothing to do with 9/11. The Arab Spring, so full of hope, lies in ashes of sectarian strife and civil wars. The greatest refugee crisis the world has known since the end of the Second World War is well under way. A group seeking the Hizb’s establishment of an Islamic State rampages across the Middle East, destroying lives, temples, towns, and priceless historical relics.
There are so many things that are easy to get caught up in, so many causes that need help, so many people who are displaced. And it’s not wrong to help people. It’s not wrong to get involved in a cause. It’s not wrong to be involved with something that you can use to aid yourself in worship and in things that should be supplementary to the faith. We just need to remember to do so out of love, lest we lose track of Him who is Love incarnate.
Saturday, April 11, 2015
A Matter of Faith: A Matter of Reviews
When I first saw a trailer for the movie "A Matter of Faith", I told several friends, "This movie just seems to cry out for great snarking." Having seen the film now, it does, but I find myself with a problem. It was so utterly horrible in all facets, that it makes the last cheesy Christian movie I reviewed look like Casablanca, The Great Dictator, or any other number of great works of cinema.
Basically it's the story of a young girl who goes off to college named Rachel. Her dad hides $50 in her Bible for her to find, but she starts going out and meeting guys and doesn't find it at first and when visiting home, her dad still finds it in her unopened Bible. She speaks glowingly of her Biology prof, who is the only person in this film capable of sounding like a human being who isn't in some sort of wooden speaking cult. Thus her dad visits the college and confronts the professor in his office, who then challenges the dad to a debate. Other subplots ensue with various guys wanting to date Rachel, including Super Evangelical Evan, who passes along "Biblical science" to her dad while interviewing him pre-debate and putting him in touch with Professor Porter, who was fired for teaching Creationism 12 years before. Over the course of the film, Rachel re-dedicates herself to God, she gets together with Evan at the end, the father loses the debate...but Professor Porter comes in and supposedly destroys Professor Karan from Biology (through the use of a complete lack of understanding of how evolution actually works, no less). And the professor is left wondering if the Chicken came first and Creationism is right.
There, with the story summed up, let's hit some snark worthy stuff:
1) The dad wants to make sure she finds a good church and is scared Karan is making her think for herself. Dear goodness, surely you don't mean that people shouldn't think for themselves! Actually, that's arguably one of the biggest messages of the movie.
2) The dialogue sucks. I wrote better dialogue in my Pokémon fanfiction back in sixth and seventh grade. It's awkward, it's stilted, and the only person who doesn't sound like a pod person while delivering it is the "evil liberal atheist professor" stereotype. He's far and away the only one in this film that can actually act! Which brings me to the next point...
3) The walking stereotype is the most sympathetic character in this film. As a devoted follower of Christ who believes we were given brains for a reason, I cheered the villain of the movie in just about everything he did, except singling her out in class over the debate coming up, and saying man invented God. He's funny, he's smart, and while the dad and Super Evangelical Evan try to paint him as having an agenda, he's shown to actually care about the physical and mental well being of his students. Like when the dad goes to confront him the first time, they set up the debate, the daughter comes in and is horrified her father is taking umbridge at what her prof is teaching, and the villainous professor's reaction? It's to make sure the daughter, his student, is okay. For goodness sake, the man gives you a C if you actually show up each class and he can tell you're making an effort.
However, much like Kevin Sorbo dies at the end of God's Not Dead and accepts Jesus, we see similar here. A shaken Professor Karan returns to his office the next monday, barely speaking and takes out the rubber chicken from his box where he made a chicken and egg joke, seriously considering he was wrong about God and about Creationism.
4) The humor was very targeted to its audience. At one point, as Professor Porter returns to take on Karan on the dad's behalf, he makes a joke that the stars could descend from the sky and spell out evolution being a lie in words and Karan would blame it on "clever Baptists". Everyone on film and in the theater laughed.
5) Whoever wrote all of this doesn't understand evolution, at all. Or the Big Bang. Or anything resembling science. Porter never disproves anything, he just says Creationism and Evolution are both matters of faith (ooh title drop!).
All in all, A Matter of Faith is a matter of sitting through stereotype after stereotype. There's a quote about how Christian cinema's greatest failing is that it's like pornography. You know the stereotypes, you know the plot, and you know exactly how things are going to end. Nothing surprised me the entire length of the film. I predicted every single thing. Literally. Every. Single. Thing.
Final BG Review?: 1/10
Bonus Mini Rant: They used the same exterior shot all the time to transition between scenes at the university. Ivy or kudzu or something crawling across a building but kept meticulously off the windows. After the 10th or so time, I could recall exactly what that building looked like.
Basically it's the story of a young girl who goes off to college named Rachel. Her dad hides $50 in her Bible for her to find, but she starts going out and meeting guys and doesn't find it at first and when visiting home, her dad still finds it in her unopened Bible. She speaks glowingly of her Biology prof, who is the only person in this film capable of sounding like a human being who isn't in some sort of wooden speaking cult. Thus her dad visits the college and confronts the professor in his office, who then challenges the dad to a debate. Other subplots ensue with various guys wanting to date Rachel, including Super Evangelical Evan, who passes along "Biblical science" to her dad while interviewing him pre-debate and putting him in touch with Professor Porter, who was fired for teaching Creationism 12 years before. Over the course of the film, Rachel re-dedicates herself to God, she gets together with Evan at the end, the father loses the debate...but Professor Porter comes in and supposedly destroys Professor Karan from Biology (through the use of a complete lack of understanding of how evolution actually works, no less). And the professor is left wondering if the Chicken came first and Creationism is right.
There, with the story summed up, let's hit some snark worthy stuff:
1) The dad wants to make sure she finds a good church and is scared Karan is making her think for herself. Dear goodness, surely you don't mean that people shouldn't think for themselves! Actually, that's arguably one of the biggest messages of the movie.
2) The dialogue sucks. I wrote better dialogue in my Pokémon fanfiction back in sixth and seventh grade. It's awkward, it's stilted, and the only person who doesn't sound like a pod person while delivering it is the "evil liberal atheist professor" stereotype. He's far and away the only one in this film that can actually act! Which brings me to the next point...
3) The walking stereotype is the most sympathetic character in this film. As a devoted follower of Christ who believes we were given brains for a reason, I cheered the villain of the movie in just about everything he did, except singling her out in class over the debate coming up, and saying man invented God. He's funny, he's smart, and while the dad and Super Evangelical Evan try to paint him as having an agenda, he's shown to actually care about the physical and mental well being of his students. Like when the dad goes to confront him the first time, they set up the debate, the daughter comes in and is horrified her father is taking umbridge at what her prof is teaching, and the villainous professor's reaction? It's to make sure the daughter, his student, is okay. For goodness sake, the man gives you a C if you actually show up each class and he can tell you're making an effort.
However, much like Kevin Sorbo dies at the end of God's Not Dead and accepts Jesus, we see similar here. A shaken Professor Karan returns to his office the next monday, barely speaking and takes out the rubber chicken from his box where he made a chicken and egg joke, seriously considering he was wrong about God and about Creationism.
4) The humor was very targeted to its audience. At one point, as Professor Porter returns to take on Karan on the dad's behalf, he makes a joke that the stars could descend from the sky and spell out evolution being a lie in words and Karan would blame it on "clever Baptists". Everyone on film and in the theater laughed.
5) Whoever wrote all of this doesn't understand evolution, at all. Or the Big Bang. Or anything resembling science. Porter never disproves anything, he just says Creationism and Evolution are both matters of faith (ooh title drop!).
All in all, A Matter of Faith is a matter of sitting through stereotype after stereotype. There's a quote about how Christian cinema's greatest failing is that it's like pornography. You know the stereotypes, you know the plot, and you know exactly how things are going to end. Nothing surprised me the entire length of the film. I predicted every single thing. Literally. Every. Single. Thing.
Final BG Review?: 1/10
Bonus Mini Rant: They used the same exterior shot all the time to transition between scenes at the university. Ivy or kudzu or something crawling across a building but kept meticulously off the windows. After the 10th or so time, I could recall exactly what that building looked like.
Wednesday, April 01, 2015
Palm Sunday
"Crucify Him!" the interactive Gospel with the Passion has us shout. "Crucify Him!" It always strikes a bit close to home during Holy Week, because each time I sin, that's what I'm doing, shouting "Crucify Him!" You see, Christ died for our sins, so each sin, it's as if I'm again calling for Him to be put upon the cross.
It's a morbid thought, perhaps, but one of two that came with this Palm Sunday and one I have time to put into writing only now. The other is just a thought that's been bugging me a lot lately; how we've lost a sense of the sacred in modern western Christianity. As we read and hear the Gospel on Palm Sunday, we hear about Christ's entrance into Jerusalem, with people laying down their cloaks and even the leaves from trees (such as palms) so that the lowly beast of burden He rode wouldn't have to touch the dirt; how the people sang "Hosanna" at this triumphal appearance of a man so many considered to be a prophet. It would have to be quite a sight to behold, and it's not a sight we would probably see anywhere today.
Partially, it's cultural, or so I would suspect. But also, we're losing a sense of the sacred and becoming more corporate, more secular, in worship. "Sanctuary" is now "Auditorium". "Campus" has replaced "church", the building, not the body of believers. The "altar" becomes "the stage". "Gatherings" replace "worship service", "Mass", etc. Becoming "relevant" to people has placed Jesus in the backseat, or so it often seems. I don't know, maybe it's just me.
And maybe I'm just tired of hearing Evangelical non-denominational folks tell me things like "Prayer isn't important" or "If we talk about Hell, we'll drive people away" or my personal favorite for vomit inducing, "God wants you to be rich! If ya ain't prospering, ya ain't right with God. Give us money now!" Or Catholics saying, "We need to modernize the Mass" or "Maybe if we just add some rock music" or "The liturgy is the source and summit of our faith!".
Do you know the source and summit of my faith? Jesus, the Christ. Do you know what I consider "relevant"? Jesus, and His death and resurrection. And so I find myself pondering, if Jesus were to walk into an American church tomorrow, would he be welcomed in such a way that His feet would not touch the ground? Or would we all think ourselves so far above Him?
It's a morbid thought, perhaps, but one of two that came with this Palm Sunday and one I have time to put into writing only now. The other is just a thought that's been bugging me a lot lately; how we've lost a sense of the sacred in modern western Christianity. As we read and hear the Gospel on Palm Sunday, we hear about Christ's entrance into Jerusalem, with people laying down their cloaks and even the leaves from trees (such as palms) so that the lowly beast of burden He rode wouldn't have to touch the dirt; how the people sang "Hosanna" at this triumphal appearance of a man so many considered to be a prophet. It would have to be quite a sight to behold, and it's not a sight we would probably see anywhere today.
Partially, it's cultural, or so I would suspect. But also, we're losing a sense of the sacred and becoming more corporate, more secular, in worship. "Sanctuary" is now "Auditorium". "Campus" has replaced "church", the building, not the body of believers. The "altar" becomes "the stage". "Gatherings" replace "worship service", "Mass", etc. Becoming "relevant" to people has placed Jesus in the backseat, or so it often seems. I don't know, maybe it's just me.
And maybe I'm just tired of hearing Evangelical non-denominational folks tell me things like "Prayer isn't important" or "If we talk about Hell, we'll drive people away" or my personal favorite for vomit inducing, "God wants you to be rich! If ya ain't prospering, ya ain't right with God. Give us money now!" Or Catholics saying, "We need to modernize the Mass" or "Maybe if we just add some rock music" or "The liturgy is the source and summit of our faith!".
Do you know the source and summit of my faith? Jesus, the Christ. Do you know what I consider "relevant"? Jesus, and His death and resurrection. And so I find myself pondering, if Jesus were to walk into an American church tomorrow, would he be welcomed in such a way that His feet would not touch the ground? Or would we all think ourselves so far above Him?
Tuesday, December 23, 2014
The Scandal of the Incarnation and the Worth of a Soul
I'm a fan of the Georgina Kincaid series by Richelle Meade, so you may want to skip this post now if you intend to read the last book of that series.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Okay, spoiler time it is. Georgina, our heroine, has just gotten out of her contract with Hell. There was a loophole and she and her friends have managed to return our plucky heroine to a "Daughter of Man" instead of a "Daughter of Lilith" as the archangel Carter puts it. But then he drops a bombshell on her at the wedding reception...the whole series, she was his assignment. He was there to help her find the loophole, to return from darkness, to save her soul.
What is our chance? To accept that Christ became man and died for us, fully human and fully divine. But that doesn't sound scandalous, does it? It really should, because as we approach Christmas this year, we approach what my favorite theologian, Dr. Scott Hahn, calls "the scandal of the Incarnation". Place yourself in the shoes of a devout first century Jew. You observe the hundreds of laws as commanded, you know what the Torah says, you listen to the Rabbis, and you make the proscribed sacrifices. You do not mix with Gentiles, and you undertake the arduous trip to the Temple when it is required by your faith. You may even follow around your favorite teacher from the Saducees or Pharisees as they debate the finer points of theology, like that concept of the resurrection of the dead. And of course, laboring under the harsh rule of the Roman Empire, you're longing and waiting for the prophesied Messiah.
Then, a strange thing happens, but you don't know it yet. A woman is visited by an angel of the Lord, and told that she is full of grace and she says that she has been blessed and will be called so by all generations, that she is carrying the Son of God after she says yes, because unlike Zeus of the Greeks, the God of Abraham is not a rapist. She becomes known as Mary, the Mother of God, the Blessed Virgin, or the Theotokos (God-Bearer) depending on your denominational interpretation. Her righteous betrothed learns of her pregnancy, and even though he can have her killed under the law, he decides to quietly divorce her, because he is indeed a righteous man, but an angel appears to him as well, revealing the truth and he too, says yes to God's plan. They can find no room as they go for the census, and so they end up in a stable, most likely in some sort of dank cave, with little lighting to give birth. Then, after hours of labor, probably, an infant's cry pierces the night. God the Son has been born of an earthly mother, fully human and fully divine; the plan for the salvation of humanity has been set into motion and the scandal of the Incarnation has begun.
You know nothing of this though, as a first century Jew. You don't know that shepherds are leaving their flocks to worship as told by angels. You don't know that wise men are coming from the East with very symbolic gifts: Gold fit for a King, Frankincense fit for a Priest whose prayers wafted up to Heaven, and Myrrh...an embalming agent which foreshadowed death. You don't know that these men have followed a star, nor that the young family will sell these gifts to run to Egypt. You don't know what happens really, at all. Not until one day some twelve year old is learning and even teaching in the temple and remarks to his worried parents, "Did you not know I would be in my Father's house?" Gee, you think, that's sorta strange, does the High Priest have a kid no one knows about? Eventually you forget it though, and the years go by.
More than a decade passes and you hear rumors of some new prophet out in Nazareth. Nothing good ever comes from Nazareth, so you're skeptical. Poverty stricken Galileans aren't good for much besides being the butt of jokes. But the rumors keep coming: that He turned water to wine in a wedding your cousin attended in Cana; that the crazy wild man baptizing people proclaimed himself unworthy to untie this prophet's sandals; that He heals the sick and casts out demons; that he raised one of your friend in Bethany's acquaintances from the dead, a chap by the name of Lazarus; that He somehow fed five thousand men and even more women and children with only a few fish and bread chunks; that He calmed a storm upon a sea and walked across the water according to a fisherman in a tavern. You resolve to see this prophet as He comes to Jerusalem for the Passover...people line the streets and place cloaks and palm branches before His donkey and shout in celebration and then by the week's end, He is hanging upon a Cross for the blasphemous assertion that He is the Son of God! Earthquakes strike, the Veil in the Temple is torn and the Holy of Holies has been exposed for all to see. The priests tear their garments in lamentation.
Then there are further rumors three days later. Rumors that the prophet's tomb is empty. That people keep meeting him in roads and elsewhere. That hundreds saw Him in one appearance. Quiet investigations are launched by the Roman Governor, needing to know if this Prophet is dead or has truly risen. There are rumors that even Pontius Pilate is afraid. It's scandalous to think that this Man may have risen from the dead, especially after claiming to be the Son of God. In your curiosity though, you seek out His followers, who are mainly hiding in locked rooms. One of His Disciples begins to tell you of this prophet's genealogy, as described in the Gospel of Matthew:
Hezron the father of Ram,
Ram the father of Amminadab,
Then this Disciple hits you with the wham line...this man was the Messiah, and you stood in a crowd and watched as people you knew shouted "Crucify Him". He came like a thief in the night, born to poverty in a manger, working humbly over the years, and you even crossed His path when He was younger in the Temple. The Veil in the Temple was torn at the moment of His death, as were the earthquakes and other strange signs. That He died for your sins, that He was the final Sacrifice, leaving behind only the sacrifice of Himself and the Todah sacrifice (Leviticus 7:13-15)...as an observant Jew you know it as the thanksgiving sacrifice of bread and blood often offered by someone whose life has been saved from mortal danger, and now this Disciple is talking about it being linked to this prophet, no, this Messiah's sacrifice for you and all, to be offered by a person saved from the fires of Hell by this Messiah. It, and the Disciple go into far more theological detail, but you're not a Rabbi, a Saducee, or a Pharisee, you're just a humble everyday person, caught up in the zeal of this orator as he tells you the stories of his Messiah.
When it is all said and done, you tell the man you will think about what he has told you. It seems scandalous. That God would take human form? That He would lower Himself in such a way? That He would live and die as one of us? And that He had the lineage of the prophesied Messiah, and that the lineage in itself, when you thought about it, was filled with scandal after scandal. But then you think about it a little more and you begin to see typings and patterns. Abraham, your father in faith, was going to sacrifice his son Isaac at the Lord's command and even had Isaac carry his wood, just as God sacrificed His Son and this Jesus was forced to carry His cross. Melchizedek, the King and High Priest of legend of early Jerusalem, who offered sacrifices of bread and wine; this so called Christ who offered His Body and Blood as Bread and Wine in that last Passover meal with His Disciples and that they have continued to celebrate. How scandalous this all is, how it rocks you to your core, but perhaps most frightening of all...what if this prophet's followers are right? What if the Messiah was born of a virgin in Bethlehem and you missed the entire time He spent upon the Earth? What if something good did come from Nazareth, in the form of the salvation of the world? It's almost enough to make your brain want to shut down: a genealogical history of sinners and gentiles, of pagans and kings. A number of miracles people claimed to witness. This prophet's own testimony that He was the Son of God! Such blasphemy...but then there are also the signs; the darkness, the earthquakes, the tearing of the Veil.
And so you realize, you have to decide...did this Jesus come and be born of a virgin? Was He born in Bethlehem? And is He the Messiah, so long awaited and prophesied?
---
Merry Christmas everyone! The Scandal of the Incarnation is upon us, that God sent His Son to be born among us. That He would do so in a family tree filled with the forsaken, the fearful, the greatest sinners of an age, the fallen and the failures. Out of the darkness of so much, there came a great Light, the Light of the world.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Okay, spoiler time it is. Georgina, our heroine, has just gotten out of her contract with Hell. There was a loophole and she and her friends have managed to return our plucky heroine to a "Daughter of Man" instead of a "Daughter of Lilith" as the archangel Carter puts it. But then he drops a bombshell on her at the wedding reception...the whole series, she was his assignment. He was there to help her find the loophole, to return from darkness, to save her soul.
"I'm just one person. One soul. All your work and energy....I mean, it can't have all been just for one soul. An angel can't be soley dedicated to that."
"Well," he said, clearly enjoying my confusion, "it was actually for two souls, since you and Seth were both saved. But even if it wasn't, it still would've been worth it. Do you know the price of one soul, Georgina? It's beyond rubies and diamonds, beyond any mortal reckoning. If it had taken me centuries, if it had taken a dozen more angels to help me, it all would have been worth it."Never before in fiction, have I found the value of our souls so beautifully expressed. Beyond any riches, is the soul. It's no wonder then that the Bible tells us in Luke 15:10, that, "In the same way, I tell you, there is rejoicing in the presence of the angels of God over one sinner who repents." And that joy, my friends, is what brings us into the season we are soon to celebrate; a chance we have been given, one that allows for all of Heaven to rejoice. That chance though, is absolutely scandalous in its nature.
What is our chance? To accept that Christ became man and died for us, fully human and fully divine. But that doesn't sound scandalous, does it? It really should, because as we approach Christmas this year, we approach what my favorite theologian, Dr. Scott Hahn, calls "the scandal of the Incarnation". Place yourself in the shoes of a devout first century Jew. You observe the hundreds of laws as commanded, you know what the Torah says, you listen to the Rabbis, and you make the proscribed sacrifices. You do not mix with Gentiles, and you undertake the arduous trip to the Temple when it is required by your faith. You may even follow around your favorite teacher from the Saducees or Pharisees as they debate the finer points of theology, like that concept of the resurrection of the dead. And of course, laboring under the harsh rule of the Roman Empire, you're longing and waiting for the prophesied Messiah.
Then, a strange thing happens, but you don't know it yet. A woman is visited by an angel of the Lord, and told that she is full of grace and she says that she has been blessed and will be called so by all generations, that she is carrying the Son of God after she says yes, because unlike Zeus of the Greeks, the God of Abraham is not a rapist. She becomes known as Mary, the Mother of God, the Blessed Virgin, or the Theotokos (God-Bearer) depending on your denominational interpretation. Her righteous betrothed learns of her pregnancy, and even though he can have her killed under the law, he decides to quietly divorce her, because he is indeed a righteous man, but an angel appears to him as well, revealing the truth and he too, says yes to God's plan. They can find no room as they go for the census, and so they end up in a stable, most likely in some sort of dank cave, with little lighting to give birth. Then, after hours of labor, probably, an infant's cry pierces the night. God the Son has been born of an earthly mother, fully human and fully divine; the plan for the salvation of humanity has been set into motion and the scandal of the Incarnation has begun.
You know nothing of this though, as a first century Jew. You don't know that shepherds are leaving their flocks to worship as told by angels. You don't know that wise men are coming from the East with very symbolic gifts: Gold fit for a King, Frankincense fit for a Priest whose prayers wafted up to Heaven, and Myrrh...an embalming agent which foreshadowed death. You don't know that these men have followed a star, nor that the young family will sell these gifts to run to Egypt. You don't know what happens really, at all. Not until one day some twelve year old is learning and even teaching in the temple and remarks to his worried parents, "Did you not know I would be in my Father's house?" Gee, you think, that's sorta strange, does the High Priest have a kid no one knows about? Eventually you forget it though, and the years go by.
More than a decade passes and you hear rumors of some new prophet out in Nazareth. Nothing good ever comes from Nazareth, so you're skeptical. Poverty stricken Galileans aren't good for much besides being the butt of jokes. But the rumors keep coming: that He turned water to wine in a wedding your cousin attended in Cana; that the crazy wild man baptizing people proclaimed himself unworthy to untie this prophet's sandals; that He heals the sick and casts out demons; that he raised one of your friend in Bethany's acquaintances from the dead, a chap by the name of Lazarus; that He somehow fed five thousand men and even more women and children with only a few fish and bread chunks; that He calmed a storm upon a sea and walked across the water according to a fisherman in a tavern. You resolve to see this prophet as He comes to Jerusalem for the Passover...people line the streets and place cloaks and palm branches before His donkey and shout in celebration and then by the week's end, He is hanging upon a Cross for the blasphemous assertion that He is the Son of God! Earthquakes strike, the Veil in the Temple is torn and the Holy of Holies has been exposed for all to see. The priests tear their garments in lamentation.
Then there are further rumors three days later. Rumors that the prophet's tomb is empty. That people keep meeting him in roads and elsewhere. That hundreds saw Him in one appearance. Quiet investigations are launched by the Roman Governor, needing to know if this Prophet is dead or has truly risen. There are rumors that even Pontius Pilate is afraid. It's scandalous to think that this Man may have risen from the dead, especially after claiming to be the Son of God. In your curiosity though, you seek out His followers, who are mainly hiding in locked rooms. One of His Disciples begins to tell you of this prophet's genealogy, as described in the Gospel of Matthew:
Perez the father of Hezron,
Abraham was the father of Isaac,Isaac the father of Jacob,Jacob the father of Judah and his brothers,Judah the father of Perez and Zerah, whose mother was Tamar, (Whoa there...we try not to think about Tamar, having to trick Judah into doing what he promised the Lord regarding giving her a son after his brother died without leaving an heir, forcing her to dress up as a prostitute to have relations with him and then keeping his seal as payment and producing it when he went to put her to death as Tamar, for being pregnant...really, look it up in Genesis 38).
Hezron the father of Ram,
Ram the father of Amminadab,
Amminadab the father of Nahshon,Nahshon the father of Salmon,Salmon the father of Boaz, whose mother was Rahab, (Whoa there, you exclaim to the Disciple, we do not bring up the R-word around here. A Pagan prostitute is someone we try to ignore in the royal family tree. And why are we even listing women, we never list women in genealogies.)Boaz the father of Obed, whose mother was Ruth, (Whoa, another foreigner, this one from Moab? Stop bringing up scandalous parts of the royal family lineage!)Obed the father of Jesse,and Jesse the father of King David.David was the father of Solomon, whose mother had been Uriah’s wife, (Erm yes...her. Uh...not King David's finest moment, that affair and then arranging her husband's death on the battlefield.)Solomon the father of Rehoboam,Rehoboam the father of Abijah,Abijah the father of Asa,Asa the father of Jehoshaphat,Jehoshaphat the father of Jehoram,Jehoram the father of Uzziah,Uzziah the father of Jotham,Jotham the father of Ahaz,Ahaz the father of Hezekiah,Hezekiah the father of Manasseh,Manasseh the father of Amon,Amon the father of Josiah,and Josiah the father of Jeconiah and his brothers at the time of the exile to Babylon. (Yeah dude, we all know, our Kings have a bad record of screwing up...we try not to dwell on their names.) After the exile to Babylon:Jeconiah was the father of Shealtiel,Shealtiel the father of Zerubbabel,Zerubbabel the father of Abihud,Abihud the father of Eliakim,Eliakim the father of Azor,Azor the father of Zadok,Zadok the father of Akim,Akim the father of Elihud,Elihud the father of Eleazar,Eleazar the father of Matthan,Matthan the father of Jacob,and Jacob the father of Joseph, the husband of Mary, and Mary was the mother of Jesus who is called the Messiah.
Then this Disciple hits you with the wham line...this man was the Messiah, and you stood in a crowd and watched as people you knew shouted "Crucify Him". He came like a thief in the night, born to poverty in a manger, working humbly over the years, and you even crossed His path when He was younger in the Temple. The Veil in the Temple was torn at the moment of His death, as were the earthquakes and other strange signs. That He died for your sins, that He was the final Sacrifice, leaving behind only the sacrifice of Himself and the Todah sacrifice (Leviticus 7:13-15)...as an observant Jew you know it as the thanksgiving sacrifice of bread and blood often offered by someone whose life has been saved from mortal danger, and now this Disciple is talking about it being linked to this prophet, no, this Messiah's sacrifice for you and all, to be offered by a person saved from the fires of Hell by this Messiah. It, and the Disciple go into far more theological detail, but you're not a Rabbi, a Saducee, or a Pharisee, you're just a humble everyday person, caught up in the zeal of this orator as he tells you the stories of his Messiah.
When it is all said and done, you tell the man you will think about what he has told you. It seems scandalous. That God would take human form? That He would lower Himself in such a way? That He would live and die as one of us? And that He had the lineage of the prophesied Messiah, and that the lineage in itself, when you thought about it, was filled with scandal after scandal. But then you think about it a little more and you begin to see typings and patterns. Abraham, your father in faith, was going to sacrifice his son Isaac at the Lord's command and even had Isaac carry his wood, just as God sacrificed His Son and this Jesus was forced to carry His cross. Melchizedek, the King and High Priest of legend of early Jerusalem, who offered sacrifices of bread and wine; this so called Christ who offered His Body and Blood as Bread and Wine in that last Passover meal with His Disciples and that they have continued to celebrate. How scandalous this all is, how it rocks you to your core, but perhaps most frightening of all...what if this prophet's followers are right? What if the Messiah was born of a virgin in Bethlehem and you missed the entire time He spent upon the Earth? What if something good did come from Nazareth, in the form of the salvation of the world? It's almost enough to make your brain want to shut down: a genealogical history of sinners and gentiles, of pagans and kings. A number of miracles people claimed to witness. This prophet's own testimony that He was the Son of God! Such blasphemy...but then there are also the signs; the darkness, the earthquakes, the tearing of the Veil.
And so you realize, you have to decide...did this Jesus come and be born of a virgin? Was He born in Bethlehem? And is He the Messiah, so long awaited and prophesied?
---
Merry Christmas everyone! The Scandal of the Incarnation is upon us, that God sent His Son to be born among us. That He would do so in a family tree filled with the forsaken, the fearful, the greatest sinners of an age, the fallen and the failures. Out of the darkness of so much, there came a great Light, the Light of the world.
Wednesday, September 10, 2014
Down the Rabbit Hole
Down the rabbit hole, a metaphor for the beginning of what may at first seem to be an interesting time, but in reality, is the beginning of something truly crazy. Such was what Alice encountered in her visits to Wonderland in the novel from which the phrase is drawn, and such is the world we live in today.
A colleague remarked the other day, "There's so much breaking bad news, that the media can't keep up with it, even in a 24 hour news cycle." I wanted to protest, but he's right. Israel and Hamas kept violating cease fires until this latest one and thousands of Palestinians and a handful of Israelis are dead. The psychological scarring on both peoples though, that will last a lifetime. Ukraine is still on fire, Russian backed rebels fighting against the government in Kiev, which in turn overthrew the Russian backed government in Kiev. The rebels brought down an airliner full of innocent civilians...and then mined the area so that evidence could not be recovered. For the Netherlands especially, this was difficult, as they lost proportionately as many people as the United States did on 9/11.
The drums of war once again beat in the heart of the American political machine, back to Iraq once more, because we left and things fell apart; ISIS has risen as a more vicious group than Al Quaeda had ever been (beheading even AQ's emissary). American soldiers are to return soon. On one hand, I want to scream and rage at this idea, but on the other, it's needed...ISIS intends to eliminate all of Iraq's Christians and Yazidis. Faced with the growing threat of ISIS to the region, even Turkey has begun to fly bombing missions in support of the Kurds, their generations' long enemies...indeed, it is only military action by the US, Turkey, and Kurds that saved forty thousand Yazidis from being forced to die of dehydration on a mountain recently. Meanwhile, ISIS continues to behead children and journalists for the world to see, and posts videos of mass executions of Iraqi Army soldiers.
In Africa, the ebola virus rampages almost unchecked. Over a thousand have died thus far since the initial outbreak that has spread across multiple countries, despite the closing of national borders. Many superstitious types have begun to burn western backed clinics as possible sources of the disease, allowing it to spread unchecked even further.
At home, racial tensions seem to be simmering to the fore again, courtesy of the execution of an unarmed black teen by a white cop in Ferguson, Missouri. Police have been overzealous in their attempts to crush the riots, and military grade weapons have been used not only on protesters but also on the media. Story after story has come out of that town where black neighborhoods are being shelled by the police with tear gas, where reporters are being arrested at gunpoint for doing their jobs by the people who have sworn an oath to defend the weak, where being black in America can get you killed. As a professional in the criminal justice field, I've followed things there closely, and more than once, I've wept.
Meanwhile, also here in America, one of the world's greatest comedians was unable to fight off the darkness that plagued him any longer. Robin Williams took his own life, and in so doing, triggered a new awareness about mental health, and how sometimes, a suicidal person just can't control their actions. Many celebrity suicides don't touch the world, but with Robin Williams, everyone had a fond memory of him, of some moment where he had given them hope. Be it his inspiration of an entire generation of teachers and professors in Dead Poet's Society, or for those who lost a loved one in What Dreams May Come, or even a laugh from his numerous comedies at a time when it was most needed.
To be honest, this entire post is inspired by the fact I just saw The Photo. It's the one image from 9/11 that thirteen years later, I can't help but think of...a man, tumbling to his death. Choosing suicide over death by smoke inhalation or flames. A theologian, Mark D. Thompson of Moore Theological College, perhaps put it best about the 'falling man' as the image is known, "perhaps the most powerful image of despair at the beginning of the twenty-first century is not found in art, or literature, or even popular music. It is found in a single photograph."
My last post was a snarky film review of God's Not Dead. Looking at our world, at all the evil that is so visible within it, it would be easy to side with Kevin Sorbo's character and say that God's dead, that He wouldn't allow all of this to happen. In a world where jumping a hundred stories to one's death is preferable to facing what is inside of a building, how can we not despair?
And that, my friends, is when I pause and need to listen. Sometimes faith's not a fire, it's a soft glow. It doesn't chase the monsters away and make everything better, as much as it provides comfort, despite the monsters. It burns within us and tells us that we are not alone, no matter how we may feel or how it may seem. It tells us that others are facing this too, and that they can do it, and we can do it. "Faith Manages" in the words of the fiction Brother Theo from Babylon 5.
The question then becomes, do we just merely seek to survive this world where despair seems to be so attractive an option, or do we want to thrive? Because personally, I agree with Casting Crowns, we were made to thrive. So perhaps, when we see that frazzled person, give them a smile. Hold the door for someone. Let the other person turn across the road before you go at the light. Do something small; it's often the little things in life that remind us to have faith, and remind us there is hope.
Thank you Lord Jesus Christ for that.
A colleague remarked the other day, "There's so much breaking bad news, that the media can't keep up with it, even in a 24 hour news cycle." I wanted to protest, but he's right. Israel and Hamas kept violating cease fires until this latest one and thousands of Palestinians and a handful of Israelis are dead. The psychological scarring on both peoples though, that will last a lifetime. Ukraine is still on fire, Russian backed rebels fighting against the government in Kiev, which in turn overthrew the Russian backed government in Kiev. The rebels brought down an airliner full of innocent civilians...and then mined the area so that evidence could not be recovered. For the Netherlands especially, this was difficult, as they lost proportionately as many people as the United States did on 9/11.
The drums of war once again beat in the heart of the American political machine, back to Iraq once more, because we left and things fell apart; ISIS has risen as a more vicious group than Al Quaeda had ever been (beheading even AQ's emissary). American soldiers are to return soon. On one hand, I want to scream and rage at this idea, but on the other, it's needed...ISIS intends to eliminate all of Iraq's Christians and Yazidis. Faced with the growing threat of ISIS to the region, even Turkey has begun to fly bombing missions in support of the Kurds, their generations' long enemies...indeed, it is only military action by the US, Turkey, and Kurds that saved forty thousand Yazidis from being forced to die of dehydration on a mountain recently. Meanwhile, ISIS continues to behead children and journalists for the world to see, and posts videos of mass executions of Iraqi Army soldiers.
In Africa, the ebola virus rampages almost unchecked. Over a thousand have died thus far since the initial outbreak that has spread across multiple countries, despite the closing of national borders. Many superstitious types have begun to burn western backed clinics as possible sources of the disease, allowing it to spread unchecked even further.
At home, racial tensions seem to be simmering to the fore again, courtesy of the execution of an unarmed black teen by a white cop in Ferguson, Missouri. Police have been overzealous in their attempts to crush the riots, and military grade weapons have been used not only on protesters but also on the media. Story after story has come out of that town where black neighborhoods are being shelled by the police with tear gas, where reporters are being arrested at gunpoint for doing their jobs by the people who have sworn an oath to defend the weak, where being black in America can get you killed. As a professional in the criminal justice field, I've followed things there closely, and more than once, I've wept.
Meanwhile, also here in America, one of the world's greatest comedians was unable to fight off the darkness that plagued him any longer. Robin Williams took his own life, and in so doing, triggered a new awareness about mental health, and how sometimes, a suicidal person just can't control their actions. Many celebrity suicides don't touch the world, but with Robin Williams, everyone had a fond memory of him, of some moment where he had given them hope. Be it his inspiration of an entire generation of teachers and professors in Dead Poet's Society, or for those who lost a loved one in What Dreams May Come, or even a laugh from his numerous comedies at a time when it was most needed.
To be honest, this entire post is inspired by the fact I just saw The Photo. It's the one image from 9/11 that thirteen years later, I can't help but think of...a man, tumbling to his death. Choosing suicide over death by smoke inhalation or flames. A theologian, Mark D. Thompson of Moore Theological College, perhaps put it best about the 'falling man' as the image is known, "perhaps the most powerful image of despair at the beginning of the twenty-first century is not found in art, or literature, or even popular music. It is found in a single photograph."
My last post was a snarky film review of God's Not Dead. Looking at our world, at all the evil that is so visible within it, it would be easy to side with Kevin Sorbo's character and say that God's dead, that He wouldn't allow all of this to happen. In a world where jumping a hundred stories to one's death is preferable to facing what is inside of a building, how can we not despair?
And that, my friends, is when I pause and need to listen. Sometimes faith's not a fire, it's a soft glow. It doesn't chase the monsters away and make everything better, as much as it provides comfort, despite the monsters. It burns within us and tells us that we are not alone, no matter how we may feel or how it may seem. It tells us that others are facing this too, and that they can do it, and we can do it. "Faith Manages" in the words of the fiction Brother Theo from Babylon 5.
The question then becomes, do we just merely seek to survive this world where despair seems to be so attractive an option, or do we want to thrive? Because personally, I agree with Casting Crowns, we were made to thrive. So perhaps, when we see that frazzled person, give them a smile. Hold the door for someone. Let the other person turn across the road before you go at the light. Do something small; it's often the little things in life that remind us to have faith, and remind us there is hope.
Thank you Lord Jesus Christ for that.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)