Hello friends and readers. A few months ago, my girlfriend and I
joked "We should totally review God's Not Dead for YouTube sometime".
Well, not YouTube, but I am writing this review for Facebook and
Blogspot. Before I begin, I'd like to do a bit of housekeeping. First,
I'm a Roman Catholic Christian and former Baptist; I believe in the
Nicene Creed. Short version: I believe in God the Father, in Jesus
Christ, in the Holy Spirit. I believe in the ressurection of Christ,
the judgment at the end of our lives, Heaven, and Hell. I believe in
sin, I believe in Grace with a capital G.
What I
don't believe in is rampant consumerism. Aside from theology, that's my
main problem with modern Evangelical Christianity. It's become
infected (and the Catholic Church isn't immune either) with the idea of
Jesus as a product to be sold, not as a Savior who gave up His life so
that we might have eternal life. And honestly, as we start...that's the
vibe I'm already getting from God's Not Dead before it even begins.
I'm trying to not think of the massive ad campaign for it, including
multiple commercials at the Winterjam concert I attended in January, but
it's hard to forget that. Popping in the DVD, the first thing that
greets me is ads for "Pureflix" a Christian film company that has done a
surprisingly large number of films. Some of them even look kind of
decent, which given the low bar of Christian cinema at times, is a good
thing. The good ads give me hopes that this movie will also be good,
even if I don't anticipate it rocking my world like The Prince of
Egypt. As for our welcome/intro screen for the DVD, we have a student
hard at work studying as soft yet menacing piano music plays in the
background, which kind of negates the good vibe I was getting from the
ads.
Before I hit play, one other thing I need to
confess, as it were. I'm a college professor. I've never met the
militant atheist professor archetype displayed in the trailers for this
film. However, my old Baptist church warned us about liberal atheist
professors who would try to lead us astray from our faiths, back when I
was a Senior in high school. Fortified by that talk, I went into my
first class to find a minister and adjunct faculty teaching it, bouncing
sermon title ideas off of us before we started. Anyhow, join me,
friends, as we embark on the epic journey into a film that every
Evangelical church in America seemed to be pushing on its members with
the zeal of a drug dealer in a 1980s After School Special.
We
start by telling us it's from PureFlix...I realize this is standard
enough to show the production company. But between the insert in the
case for their films, only their movies being advertised, and so forth,
it really pushes the line of tasteful self promotion. That said, I have
to admit that I'm mostly enjoying this intro credits thing that's going
on. It's a nice little microcosm of college life: People shopping,
the person whose power went out and slept in past her alarm because it
was reset to blinking 12:00, a stereotyped Chinese student, riding his
bike and way overdressed. A very angry looking man I assume is a
Muslim, who keeps adjusting his daughter's hijab, which she takes off as
soon as he's out of sight.
Wow...registration guy
is breaking some federal privacy laws there, or at least heavily
skirting them, to warn off our protagonist over the whole Christian
thing. Subplots are developing here. Kid from China, Alzheimer's old
woman and her daughter she doesn't recognize. Our oversleeping reporter
has just ambushed the Duck Dynasty people, and already said to the
wife, "I thought you would be back home barefoot and pregnant." And
Kevin Sorbo, Hercules himself, has come in, late and snarky for his
first class. He lists a lot of great thinkers and reveals they're all
atheists, and that the students should be too, and uses things which are
stereotypical like "fairy in the sky" and such. Everyone is writing
"God is dead", but not our protagonist, he refuses to bow to peer pressure from the other 100+ students.
Wow,
Kevin Sorbo...if you were a real professor you would have been fired
already. You've repeatedly insisted a student's personal beliefs are
"Superstition" and such. You've outright told him you intend to fail
him, that you won't be objective in grading, etc. Any actual university
would fire you for this bullying behavior against your students.
Oh
come on, the "God is good" "All the time" "All the time" "God is good"
thing was just used. That made me sigh at stereotypicalness. And his
girlfriend is talking about loving him, but forbidding him from going up
against a professor. This movie doesn't know how to do reporters
either; this woman's questions are more pointed than a Fox News
reporter's and with more of an agenda as she ambushes a Duck Dynasty
couple at their church, and the redneck comes off as the sympathetic one
due to the hamfisted writing by the people who made this film...and
she's busy as her doctor tries to keep telling her the test results.
And this being a PureFlix film, I'm completely unsurprised she has
cancer. But it's okay, I'm sure by the end of the film, she'll at least
accept Jesus as her Lord and Savior and repent of her vegetarian,
humanist, and evil liberal ways.
"And now I will
turn the podium over to Mr. Wheaton to begin making the case for a
Supreme Celestial Dictator, otherwise known as God." Kevin Sorbo,
you're the only good actor in this film, and it's proven by your ability
to pull off that line without shaking your head incredulous. He's
followed by the African missionary character, who despite my best
efforts, I can't find the name of the actor who plays him...he's also a
cardboard cutout of a character, but the actor seems to be having such a
good time playing him, that I can forgive that.
It's
the job of the missionary to be shown as a contrast to his pastor
friend that he's visiting, an overworked man who sees no value in the
different church groups he meets with, like the women's crafting group.
Meanwhile our African friend, portraying what Spike Lee dubbed "The
Magic Negro", is dispensing wise spiritual advice, and gently chides his
American friend to know that God is in the small things, even the
everyday minutiae that we may not think of as Godly. That part of how
we live our lives, should be with the knowledge that God is in all we
are and all we do, if we are to be a part of the world but not of it.
The missionary's other role is to fulfill multiple stereotypes. He's
wide eyed and idealistic about America, wanting nothing more than to go
to Disney and get a pair of Mickey Mouse ears and a photo with the
eponymous mouse. This fits in well with Americans overall worldview of
"the third world" compared to the "shining city on a hill" as Reagan
called the United States. The other stereotype is that "Africa is more
deeply spiritual and religious than us by nature", which when you have
half the main plot being about how religion is nothing but superstition,
you get some deeply unpleasant ideas behind how the people behind this
film may feel about the continent. That said, racism and poor
stereotyping aside, I'd definitely prefer African missionary preacher to
any other religious figure we've seen in the film thus far, because
he's the only one who seems to actually care about Christ.
I
should also note that we're 30 minutes in by this point and I drink 2-4
drinks per year, usually at 2 conferences I attend. Never before has
my reaction to a film been, "I wonder if this would be better with a
Long Island Iced Tea", but God's Not Dead is full of...I was going to
say surprises, but what's surprising is how awful this film is. Nothing
is actually surprising, because so far, this is every stereotype anyone
who grew up in an Evangelical subculture has ever been exposed to.
From the evil militant liberal atheist professor who wants to destroy
faith in God among his students, to how you shouldn't be yoked unequally
with those who don't believe as much as you do, which the film has thus
far been less than subtle about with Josh (our protagonist) who loves
God with all of his heart, and his more worldly, domineering, and *gasp*
feminist, girlfriend who refuses to submit to traditional gender
roles....who also keeps trying to get him to deny God on paper to pass
the class, because she's more worried about their careers than God. To
show just how blatant this is, earlier in the film when she first tells
him to deny God for an A, he goes to pray afterward and gets a Bible
verse from a campus pastor about if you deny Christ on Earth, He will
deny you in front of His Father in Heaven. She's essentially Eve,
trying to temp Josh as Adam into his own Fall from Grace.
Anyhow,
our first of a few showdowns between Kevin Sorbo and his student.
Kevin totally destroys him...and what the hell? He grabs the student in
the hallway, shoves him against the window, "There is a God in that
classroom and it's me. I'm a jealous God, and I will make it my
personal mission to destroy any chance you have of a law degree in the
future". Again, Kevin Sorbo's character would NOT still be employed at
any university. Seriously. Oh and look, worldly girlfriend of six
years dumps Josh for going through with his argument, as she essentially
forsakes God for the world, because the evil liberal education system
has gotten to her! Because yes, after six years of being in love,
you're going to totally dump someone for standing up in what you also
supposedly believe in.
Meanwhile the "I'm secretly not
wearing the hijab" girl is secretly also listening to Franklin Graham
podcasts about Jesus. This is a totally unsurprising development given
the course of the film. Why at this rate, I bet we go back to our
reporter friend and she gets dumped too--oh wait. She just got dumped
by her boyfriend who says the cancer violates their relationship
agreement, when she thought they were in love. He meanwhile says love doesn't exist.
Turns out he's the son of the poor Alzheimer's suffering lady and he
shows as little care for his mother as his girlfriend. And his sister,
the daughter of Alzheimer's woman is Kevin Sorbo's character's wife,
sorry, girlfriend apparently (who creepily enough was his undergraduate
student when in his class when they began to date after the midterm...he
teaches Freshman philosophy). Oh it all starts coming together. Oh
and she's a Christian too! "There's only room in this relationship for
two. I don't get a mistress, you don't get to drag around a two
thousand year old Jewish carpenter."
Oh nice an
evil cabal of professors meet in Kevin Sorbos' home and they're all
militant atheists! Laughing at his wife's (sorry, girlfriend's) belief
in God, which he shouts down and claims "She's a work in progress".
Again, this resembles no faculty I've ever shared a workspace with.
Meanwhile, Chinese kid calls home, and Good Communist Yet Businessman
Stereotype dad reassures his son that the professor is right, that God
does not exist. And after being ripped a new one all night, the wife
tearfully announces, "it's time for the help to leave". And of course
her pastor is our frustrated American pastor.
I
would go into this film's views on evolution, but that would take more
knowledge than I have. I can, however, safely state that almost
everything the protagonist says from "Darwinists believe" onward is
wrong or misinformed or misconstrued at best. In fact, he rips Darwin
himself for thinking evolution was in place of God. Meanwhile, anyone
who has actually read Darwin's works will tell you that he once stated
he saw no reason why a person could not remain a Christian while
believing in evolution. "Nature does not jump" he quotes Darwin, but in
a way such as Darwin renounced evolution. And now we read from Genesis
as a literal account. Only to find that twelve year old Kevin Sorbo's
character watched his mother die of cancer, and that's why he doesn't
believe in God. Sorbo delivers one of the most true statements of the
film in this bit of exposition, "Some of the most ardent atheists were
once Christians".
Third best actor in the movie is an
actress. Our Humanist Vegetarian Reporter is actually developing a
reasonably strong character in the face of her cancer. The actress
portraying her has done a brilliant job of going from bubbly, perky, and
silly person with an agenda to grief stricken and lost in a sea of
grief and emotion. Also as we move to yet another subplot, "Angry
Muslim Dad" as I called him has lived up to his stereotype by finding
out his daughter listens to Christian podcasts and flies into a rage.
Slapping her, throwing her against walls and furniture, then throwing
her out of the house with his hands around her throat, before deciding
not to kill her. He slams the door in her face as she tries to shove
her way back in, and goes to cry. How one dimensional are the
characters in this film for the most part? Well, so far there's been
nothing I had not already predicted from the very first time we met any
of these characters, because all we're doing is using well worn tropes
of Christian fiction that have been shown to work time and again.
Speaking of, there's "China is evil" as the excited Chinese kid talks
again to his dad on the phone about how the arguments for Jesus are
making sense and his father's reaction is "you don't know who is
listening, you are jeopardizing your brother's chances to study
abroad". Girlfriend leaves militant atheist prof too.
This
forms an interesting dichotomy as it were, and a roll reversal that I
expected from the beginning of the film. Arguable, as we enter the
zenith of this, we find that our protagonist, the Christian, Josh and
the Atheist, Kevin Sorbo's Character, are alike. They share much the
same experiences. At the beginning, the students side with Sorbo
against Josh, Josh loses his girlfriend over his faith in God, and Josh
must fight an uphill battle. Meanwhile, as things shift, Sorbo loses
his girlfriend over his being a douchebag (pardon the language) and over
reasons of faith, or lack there of. The class is also turning against
Sorbo, siding with Josh, as they are being won over by strawman
arguments against atheism and a literal reading of the book of Genesis.
Two sides of the mirror, yin and yang, light and dark, good and evil,
Christian and Atheist. This is the main plot of the film, even though
it continues to be lost in an altogether too large number of subplots.
"Yes
I hate God. He took everything from me. All I have for Him is hate!"
"Well, how can you hate someone who doesn't exist?" Actually I know
plenty of atheists who hate God and religion while still refusing to
believe in His existence. Oh look, one by one, starting with our
Chinese student, every kid rises to say "God is not dead" one by one.
No one stands with the atheist professor, who leaves the room. Have to
admit, saw that one coming from a mile away. Just as it was inevitable
that the lawyer son would visit his mother, who would be perfectly lucid
about life, faith, and give a speech about the Devil to her son...then
asked who he was.
Now, Amy, the reporter, bursts into a
random Newsboys concert and demands to know how they know God exists.
"When pressed you quote ancient scribblings and say it's all in there".
And they ask her where she finds her hope, and she replies after
silence, "I'm dying". The Newsboys realize she's not there to trash
them, but hoping that Jesus is for real. Because one felt that was what
God was saying to tell her. She's not alone either. Everyone's
showing at the concert from the youth demographic: Beaten ex-Muslim
girl looking happy, Sorbo's ex girlfriend, protagonist and Chinese kid.
American Pastor and his African Missionary friend are stuck in traffic
due to the concert, and once again, the missionary character is an
utterly stereotypical yet great straight man about it all, "Shouldn't we
be happy they're all here to worship God?"
Meanwhile
Sorbo reads his mother's deathbed letter that begs him to remain with
the Lord and says how much she loves him. He calls his ex and asks her
to call him, showing true emotion; I'm betting he goes to the Newsboys
too. Oh there he goes, he sees an ad for their concert.
Okay
movie, you got me there, Kevin Sorbo gets hit by a driver, who drives
off, in the rain. "I can't die, I'm not ready" he tells Pastor Dave and
African Missionary. Pastor Dave is trying to do a deathbed conversion
here, realizing it's all been leading to this with his car trouble.
"I'm so scared to die", "If it helps, so was Jesus." "Are you willing
to put your faith in Jesus Christ, are you willing to take that
chance?" "Yes." "Do you accept Him as Lord and Savior." "Yes...I...I
accept him." And Kevin Sorbo dies in the street, converting only before
death...i have to admit, I sort of appreciate that. It's a bit
trope-ish, but fits well with the Parable of the Worker in the Vineyard
and how the Master paid each the same, no matter when they learned of
the job and began it. The Kingdom of Heaven is the same way, according
to the parable; even by coming in at the end, one can receive the same
reward as those who have been working towards the goal for years.
Because that is God's mercy. Even someone like Professor Raddison,
Sorbo's character, who persecuted those who follow God is welcome in the
end if they but acknowledge Him and what He did on the cross. We also
have the subtext here of "only the fool says in his heart that there is
no God" and "do you not know that this night your life will be demanded
of you?"
As the film ends, people joyously text "God's
not dead!" and the viewer is invited to as well. The formerly Muslim
girl flirts a bit with Josh, hinting that he will be equally yolked soon
with a Godly woman. Martin, the Chinese kid, texts his father that God isn't dead and is Saved.
God's
Not Dead has several themes and briefly I'd like to go over the ones I
saw in this excruciating viewing. The first theme is that of "the world
hates Christians". This is a theme which is pretty subjective. In the
Bible, Jesus tells His followers that the world will hate them, because
it first hated Him. And this is true on a sliding scale of hate quite
often, from simple derision to more drastic things. Honestly, I think
this theme is part of why I disliked the movie as a whole...I'm supposed
to sympathize with a protagonist who is facing an unrealistic depiction
of an evil militant atheist academic who really wouldn't still be
employed, when yesterday I saw photos of decapitated children who died
for Christ. American Christianity likes to paint itself as an entity
under siege and attack from all sides, and yes, while it faces
pressures, it's just that...pressure. American Christians aren't dying
for Christ like others are in some nations, including Iraq, where ISIS
is systematically beheading Christian children as their parents watch.
Second
would be, "a career isn't as good as God". Time and again this gets
demonstrated. First it's Josh's girlfriend of six years, who ends up
leaving him, because his zeal for God is jeopardizing her future
career. Ditto with the humanist atheist vegetarian reporter with
terminal cancer; she gets dumped for being dead soon, and had a hatred
of God and made sport of making fun of Christians in her job with the
"liberal media". She, however, comes around with her conversion at the
hands of the Newsboys. Sorbo's career drove away his girlfriend, who
valued her faith more than his atheism.
Third is
"deathbed conversions". Professor Raddisson has one in his last moments
of life, previously described. And Amy, our liberal media member, has
one as well, and finds the love of God is enough to face her impending
death with dignity, thanks to being Saved by Jesus.
Fourth,
we've got "the international community needs Christ if only America
could develop some missionary spirit again". This is exemplified in a
number of ways. First, by the African Missionary character, who I still
think was awesome, despite the racist undertones. His American pastor
friend describes him as "being on the front lines, winning souls for the
Lord". The girl who was Muslim is Saved by Franklin Graham's podcast
on 1st Corinthians, though this costs her in the form of her family, as
Jesus said, His coming would pit family against one another. The
Chinese student is Saved as well, and once knew about a hidden house
church in China.
Fifth, "academics are evil atheists
who want to steal your children's souls". Again, pretty self
explanatory, but a real talk that people often have with their kids
before sending them to the university. I know this sort of talk, though
not as dramatically phrased, came up in my old Baptist church before I
went to college.
The last major theme of the film is an unintentional one. And that theme is "Evangelical Consumerism".
This film is like one giant generic Evangelical commercial. We start
with Pureflix advertising its own films. Then we start advertising
everything from Franklin Graham's products to the Newsboys music (their
latest hit song is the film title) to Duck Commander duck calls. No,
secular films aren't angels either at this, but quite frankly, I
expected more of a Christian film. I expect product placement from
secular cinema, but it came off as tasteless and downright tacky in
this, much like when K-LOVE advertises different movies...including this
one.
All in all. God's Not Dead is exactly what
the title says. Our God is not dead. He's alive! The same cannot be
said of my brain cells, however, after watching this piece of cinema
that falls drastically short of any number of standards, ranging from
the script to actual character development. Despite it's awkward
beginning, plethora of subplots, and seeming to be composed of every
Christian chain letter and trope to have ever existed in the twentieth
and twenty-first centuries in the United States...the film really wasn't
too bad overall. Yes, it was stupid. Yes, there are probably
pornographic films out there with more character development than anyone
short of our liberal reporter went through. Yes, it relied heavily on
the "we're persecuted" mentality that certain groups in American
Christianity try to drum up. Yes, I predicted the fate of almost every
single character (except Raddisson and Amy's deaths) and how they'd end
up...the first time we saw them. Yes, they got evolution wrong
factually.
However, the ending, for the most part,
makes up for this. As the voiceover from Raddisson's dead mother read
her deathbed letter to him, I choked up a bit. Not because it was well
done, but because it sounded like something my own mother would write.
And the filmmakers actually did a pretty decent job tying every single
subplot together at the very end. It shows that while at first it all
looked like someone threw crap at a wall until something stuck, idea
wise, that it was all planned and interwoven before hand. This isn't
something that's readily apparent as you're watching the film, even when
you guess how the characters will end up.
Really,
from a Christian standpoint, most of our characters get happy endings
too. That's a refreshing change compared to some cinema. Yes, Amy is
going to die, but at least she's at peace with it now, and will go to
Heaven. Likewise, Raddisson dies on the street, but at the last minute,
he is Saved. Christian pastor guy with car issues gets to actually do
something "worthwhile" as he had put it earlier, helping lead
Raddisson's girlfriend out of a bad relationship, and making sure
Raddisson avoids the fires of Hell. The son of the woman with dementia
must face the fact that his mother gained lucidity enough to tell him
the Devil likes to trap people in guilded cages, and it seems like he's
questioning his own lack of belief at the end of the film. Martin, our
Chinese kid, embraces Christianity because of the witness of our
protagonist Josh, who is probably soon to have a new girlfriend in the
girl who left Islam thanks to Franklin Graham. Happy endings all
around.
God's Not Dead isn't a good film. However, I
expected far worse, from the reviews I read of it, where even Christian
reviewers were calling it "Spiritual Masturbation". I would definitely
put it in the "Preaching to the Choir" territory, and deeply inside it
at that. It's biggest weakness is its lack of follow through; it never
makes an actual argument against atheism in favor of Christianity.
Likewise, it's atheism is made of similar straw. It's greatest strength
is that despite it being cheesy, poorly written, and relying heavily on
tropes...God's mercy and grace still manages to shine through. God's
Not Dead probably won't be winning a lot of converts, but if even one
person comes to Christ, then PureFlix should say that it was worth its
$2 million budget...and if that's not enough for them, after budget it
still made $60 million at the box office.
In conclusion, God is NOT Dead. However, my desire to speak any further about this film is.
Sunday, August 10, 2014
Saturday, May 24, 2014
Godzilla: A Spoilerific Review
When I read CNN's review of Godzilla the week before release, they
said, "It will make you feel like a kid again" and they weren't wrong. I
felt like I was a little kid again, watching old Godzilla films with my
dad on VHS on a Saturday afternoon. I went into this movie with low
expectations, but I was totally blown away by what was there.
Once thirty minutes of previews were done, we moved on to a 1999 excursion in the Philippines, where we find fossilized remains of a giant radioactive creature and then run into a cocoon and a shattered cocoon, which leads to a hole in the side of the mountain. One of the things had awoken when the mining company found it and moved on to Japan to a nuclear power plant...where our protagonist's father and mother work and he's but a boy. It's his dad's birthday, but he's detecting bad things seismically (unknown to him, the burrowing monster). Disaster befalls the plant and the father has to seal the mother in with radiation to die, barely escapes himself, and our then little kid protagonist is watching on as the plant falls apart from his classroom out the window. This brings us to my first two full on snark points about the movie:
1) I feel like I'm in a Disney film here, the protagonist just lost one parent (and until later, you think it's both).
2) I never learned the protagonist's first name until the credits. If it was ever used, it was only in passing. People call him son, dad, Lt., etc. but if we ever heard this guy's name in the entire film, I totally missed it!
At this point we do a cut away to fifteen years later, explained helpfully by the words "fifteen years later". Our now old Protagonist is back from a 14 month deployment as an explosive ordinance disposal officer with the U.S. Navy and is looking forward to seeing his family. We meet his wife Elle, who seems to be a pretty strong female character at first, having held the family together during the deployment and having been a single mother while he's been gone, and his son Sam. See, these people have names! Why doesn't Protagonist Everyman!? There's a touching scene with the little Sam asking his "dad", no names for Protagonist Everyman, if he's going to be there tomorrow still, or if he's going to leave again. Protagonist Everyman gently assures his son he will be. We have an awkward half sex scene that satisfies the MPAA need to keep Godzilla PG-13 rather than R, so parents will be more likely to bring their kids to it; they sure did at my showing, along with a very drunk redneck who kept laughing at every single lame joke.
Then we get the call...it's the Japanese consulate in San Francisco. Protagonist Everyman's dad has been arrested in the quarantine zone in Janjiro, Japan, outside of their old house. Protagonist Everyman now has to break the promise to his son, Sam, and go bail his father out of Japanese jail, flying off to Japan. We next see him waiting in a police station, where a punk kid is released first to some VERY angry parents who berate him the entire walk out of the building. It's one of those nice fun moments that breaks up the monotony before the coming of our monster friends. Then Joe, Protagonist Everyman's father is released...for his son to berate him and tell him to stop living in the past, that there is no cover up of any sort.
Joe is still not recovered from shutting the radiation doors on his wife to save himself and others and leads his son, Protagonist Everyman back to his lair. Well, tiny apartment, but it resembles a lair. There are paper clippings everywhere about nuclear coverups and accidents, books on echolocation that he explains loosely are related to tracking what's really happening, but he's still not sure what they're hiding. Seriously, I mean lair, it looks like Joe has become a total serial killer; it's the set up that you expect when the cops burst through the door of some guy who has been chopping up and raping people nonstop. They totally sell me on how mentally unbalanced Joe is, even though I know, due to genre savviness, and a pretty much dotted line path between the shattered cocoon and the nuclear plant 15 years ago, that he's got to be right.
Somehow, Joe convinces Protagonist Everyman to breach the quarantine zone with him by boat. It's all overgrown and foggy, and it looks like the movie makers really did their homework here. This is completely believable growth and decay in the quarantine zone, resembling things like the Chernobyl Exclusion Zone and the Hashima Island, an abandoned coal mining island off of Japan's coast. They find what they want in their old house, including old Zip disks with information on the plant from the date of the meltdown. They stop to gawk across the bay at where it looks like the plant is being rebuilt and get captured and interrogated. Dr. Serizawa tries to kill the creature in the cocoon after reading the information from the zip disks, because, you know, archaic technological media readers are just everywhere apparently, and realizing what's about to happen, but fails. The U.S. Military steps in afterward and seizes control of Project Monarch that is in charge of dealing with these creatures. Joe dies in front of Serizawa and Protagonist Everyman, who is now being called Lieutenant, and will be for the rest of the film.
It's time for Dr. Serizawa and his vaguely British assistant to do an exposition/info-dump on Protagonist Everyman, now that we're on an aircraft carrier off the coast of Japan. We're told that the monsters are MUTOs (Massive Unidentified Terrestrial Organism), an ancient breed of creature which feeds off radiation. The largest of these was discovered in 1954 by a nuclear sub, which was never heard from again in the Pacific Ocean, with both the U.S. and Soviets blaming each other for its disappearance. All the nuclear tests in the Pacific, such as the Bikini Atoll, were actually attempts to kill this MUTO, which Dr. Serizawa has named "Godzilla", because it is like a God, the apex predator of these creatures. The MUTOs are leftovers from an era when Earth was far more irradiated, and they feed on radiation.
When it becomes evident they really need the deceased Joe, Protagonist Everyman's father, he gets sent home via helicopter to Honolulu to catch a connecting flight to San Francisco. He calls his wife, whose phone is on vibrate and then she apparently never checks it again for voice mail, to tell her there was "an accident" in Japan and his dad is dead and that he's coming home. Unfortunately, a Russian sub disappears near Hawaii, and the task force is on the case. They find it, in the middle of jungle near Honolulu, being sucked on by a flying MUTO we saw escape earlier. Bad things happen, the military begins deploying to a rooftop of a hotel and I'm dragged completely out of the film by Snark Point three:
3) How much did Hilton pay to be the only product placement in the film itself, I mean sure, Fiat has TV commercials, but this is in the film? The U.S. military sets up on the Hilton rooftop, it's the only logo visible in all of downtown Honolulu during all of this, and we watch them painstakingly slowly rope down from the helicopter to the Hilton roof. For about two straight minutes, all they tell you to do is book your Hilton Hawaiian vacation today.
Protagonist everyman and a tourist kid are on a tram, he's assured the parents through the glass he'll bring their son back. He calms the kid by giving him a toy soldier from his own childhood, picked up at his old house. Then an EMP blast happens...that's right, the MUTO is on the move in downtown Honolulu and all the electronics get temporarily fried. Because whoever did the research on EMP somehow thinks it's just like tripping a circuit breaker, because every time it gets used, electronics come back on in about a minute. Protagonist Everyman even reassures the kid of this. Sure enough the lights come back on and we find ourselves staring at the now illuminated MUTO who takes a moment to snack on the radiation free train, even though it eats radiation, and so we can see Protagonist Everyman heroically save the kid from becoming monster poop.
Now we get to a shout out to the 2004 Tsunami that devastated Southeast Asia, and in particular a little British girl. You see, when this little girl noticed the sea was foaming and receding, she shouted to her parents that they needed to run, because in school, they learned that was a sign of a tsunami. Sure enough, a little girl, American this time, points out the sea to her parents doing the exact same thing as happened in real life and the father is the one to shout "tsunami". It's a great piece of minor storytelling in a film that seems more interested in action, and really sets the mood, as well as being a nice nod of the head to that little girl's heroism in real life and the lives she saved. Why am I talking about a tsunami? Because Godzilla causes one by coming ashore. Now it's time, I'm pumped, the entire theater is pumped, we're all ready for a fight between Godzilla and the MUTO and...
There's a small fight, we learn this flying MUTO is putting out a mating call. It and Godzilla barely touch each other before it runs away because it's thinking with its penis. Protagonist Everyman and the kid reunite with the kids' parents at a FEMA setup in Honolulu come daylight, and the Navy gives out of uniform and no ID Protagonist Everyman a ride back to California because he says he's in the Navy. Godzilla for some reason swims towards San Francisco, content to have a U.S. Navy escort. Dr. Serizawa looks like a kid on Christmas to get to be on an aircraft carrier, watching his apex nuclear predator up close in the wild.
We get to California and Protagonist Everyman gets sent with a pair of nukes by train; they've got analog triggers to survive EMP. They're going to be sent to San Francisco to be detonated in the bay as bait and to kill the monsters, even though Dr. Serizawa just warns us that it'll make them stronger. What does he know, right? He's just spent his entire career studying this stuff. Dr. Serizawa shows his pocket watch to the admiral in an attempt to make him reconsider; it stopped at 8:15am, on August 6, 1945. The admiral notes it was Hiroshima's bombing time and date, and Dr. Serizawa nods and quietly remarks that it was his father's watch. The admiral decides to continue on with the plan anyhow.
This was a great shout out and brings me to what we'll label Snark Point four, even though it's not really a snark, as much as something that brought me out of the film. This scene made me realize two things, which will both be under this point:
4a) America does not have the same nuclear experience as Japan. This scene is a warning of the danger of nuclear weapons, just as Kaiju films, in particular Godzilla, were meant to be in Japan when they were first produced. Japan has felt their sting, and has a right to fear them. American Kaiju films never measure up usually, because we don't understand culturally, the roots behind them, they're more than 'scary big monster' films. This is an attempt to reconcile that in this scene. Ken Watanabe, playing Dr. Serizawa, is a master of exposition throughout the film, including an exposition to the audience here, if they'll allow his words to reach beyond the Fourth Wall.
4b) Protagonist Everyman keeps being in the places where these MUTOs attack. He's either extremely lucky or unlucky, depending on your point of view, and reminded me of a Japanese businessman at the end of the Second World War. Tsutomu Yamaguchi, worked for Mitsubishi, and was in Hiroshima when it was bombed. He was wounded, but made his way home to Nagasaki, just in time for the second atomic bomb to be dropped on him. Though an estimated 160 people were affected by both atomic bombings, he was the only one recognized by the Japanese government officially as surviving being nuked twice; he only died four years ago in 2010. Protagonist Everyman, here, is essentially our American Tsutomu Yamaguchi; each time he goes somewhere in this film, he encounters a MUTO and he is hurt by them, but continues to survive.
Anyhow, yeah, the pocketwatch totally pulled me out of the film as the action was about to blitzkrieg. The evacuation is stalled as Godzilla arrives. Buses of kids are still on the bridge as the military pulls in Abrams tanks and guys with shoulder mounted rocket launchers. The Navy has what looks like the entire freaking Pacific Fleet in the bay, and they begin to open fire on Godzilla, despite the yelling of one soldier on the bridge that there are civilians there. We're taken out of the film by the actions of an actual everyman character, who in my opinion, is the biggest damn hero of the entire film:
5) The short bus driver. This guy ignores the cops, the military, and all common sense and pushes his busload of child evacuees through the military lines on the bridge with explosions falling all around them and Godzilla ripping a chunk of bridge out next to the bus, in order to save the kids under his care. He's the only person in this film that you can see is genuinely caring more about the civilians than themselves or the monster, and he's risking his life to do so. He steps up to the plate when the U.S. Military is too busy trying not to wet its pants.
Protagonist Everyman is the only survivor when the second, female MUTO, attacks the train and steals a nuke. He gets picked up and patched up as the military recovers the second nuke, and does a Halo drop into San Francisco as part of the bomb disposal team, as the only survivor of the people who put the original trigger in. They make it in, and begin to go on foot towards the nuke and find it in the midst of China Town with a ton of Kaiju eggs all around it. They work to get it free of the nest, and meanwhile Godzilla FINALLY begins an EPIC fight with the two MUTOs. And then Snark Point Six rears its head:
6) What the Hell are the balloons in China Town made of exactly? They survive everything. We see Godzilla roar loud enough to shatter building facades next to these balloons and they stay intact. MUTOs and Godzilla crash through them, and they're still normally inflated on the ground. Seriously, if we made our buildings out of whatever material this is, a Kaiju rampage would never be more than a nuisance to humanity again!
Anyhow, the bomb is damaged and they rush to Plan B, moving it onto a boat to get it as far into the bay as they can, so as not to hurt the citizens of San Francisco. Except for Protagonist Everyman that is. He stays behind, despite orders, to open up fuel lines so that he can torch the nest and kill all the Kaiju eggs. Smart move dude...there are thousands of them after all. This has an added bonus of enraging/distracting the female MUTO from the fight and Godzilla kills the flying male by bashing it repeatedly into a skyscraper.
Protagonist Everyman is the only survivor of his squad, again, and manages to set the boat on auto pilot out to sea. The female MUTO is roaring after the boat when Godzilla grabs her and his scales begin to shimmer and then HELL YES!!! The moment everyone in the theater has been waiting for, Godzilla uses his atomic breath like a momma bird puking into her baby bird's mouth by shoving it straight down the female MUTOs mouth, killing it, and then collapsing himself. Protagonist Everyman is flopped out on the deck of the boat as well, in a very "Do you get the Messianic overtones" crucified pose, bar the crucifixion. Yes, we get it, he's essentially Navy Jesus, except Jesus has never made me wish He was eaten by monsters for being so blandly annoying and Mary-sue-ish.
And now for EVERY OTHER SNARK POINT (or two):
7) The boat is barely moving, maybe pulling ten knots an hour as it goes into the bay. There's 5.5 minutes left on the nuke timer when Protagonist Everyman collapses and looks over from his Navy Jesus pose. We've been told that this is the largest yield nuke ever, that it makes Hiroshima look like a firecracker. The Tsar Bomba, in 1961, had a yield of 50 megatons and could be seen 59 miles away and destroyed an entire village 34 miles away. San Francisco should be entirely and totally doomed then, if this is bigger than that. Yet, Protagonist Everyman, in that five minutes, gets rescued by helicopter, and it detonates with a tiny mushroom cloud and doesn't hurt the city at all, when it should take at least a 40-60 mile chunk out of California.
8) The helicopter, with mere minutes to spare, outruns the shockwave (and actual, you know, EMP) of a double digit megaton nuclear explosion. Just...no. It doesn't work either. No one with even a simple knowledge of nuclear weapons worked on this film. No one looked at Google, no one checked a book out of a library, no one even bothered to watch a documentary on the Manhattan Project. Seriously, there's no other explanation.
Godzilla wakes up as we dig for survivors in a very post-9/11 firefighter scene. Normally I'd think this was kind of exploitative, but really, people have kind of forgotten just how big a deal it was for these men and women to be digging for survivors, almost finding none, and in constant danger. Meanwhile, Dr. Serizawa and his assistant climb the wreckage and look at Godzilla, who suddenly takes a deep breath and stands up. Yes, Godzilla has just risen from the dead. He's Reptar Jesus. Media helicopters show him walking out to see with banners proclaiming, "King of the Monsters" and "The City's Savior" as they tell the world of his exploits. The King of King...erm...King of the Monsters goes back to sea, and we all eagerly await a sequel.
Our last scene is Protagonist Everyman and his family reuniting in a FEMA shelter set up in a stadium. The end. End credits begin to roll and...HOLY CRAP! PROTAGONIST EVERYMAN'S NAME IS FORD!?! COULD WE HAVE MAYBE MENTIONED THAT SOMETIME IN THE LAST TWO HOURS AND ELEVEN MINUTES?! Really folks, the giant monsters had more character development than "Ford", we at least knew their names! Also, I assumed the wife's name "Elle" was an abbreviation, it wasn't, she's just Elle. Like every other woman in the film, she's a very strong feminist figure...until after her first introduction, after that her entire purpose is screaming, crying, overreacting, and being the anti-thesis of a strong female character.
The film starts slow, has almost no character development, and gives entirely too little screentime to its Kaiju. That said, I loved this movie so much! It was an amazing ride, the fight scenes were top notch, and while I could care less about "Ford" and his bland Navy-Jesus thing, I did enjoy the scenes with Joe, his dad, as well as those with Dr. Serizawa. Ken Watanabe lent a lot of gravitas to this film, which made it more enjoyable than it would've been otherwise. The Godzilla reimagining is a classic Kaiju film and quite possibly the first America has actually managed to get right. CNN was correct, it did make me feel like a kid again, and I look forward to the DVD release.
Once thirty minutes of previews were done, we moved on to a 1999 excursion in the Philippines, where we find fossilized remains of a giant radioactive creature and then run into a cocoon and a shattered cocoon, which leads to a hole in the side of the mountain. One of the things had awoken when the mining company found it and moved on to Japan to a nuclear power plant...where our protagonist's father and mother work and he's but a boy. It's his dad's birthday, but he's detecting bad things seismically (unknown to him, the burrowing monster). Disaster befalls the plant and the father has to seal the mother in with radiation to die, barely escapes himself, and our then little kid protagonist is watching on as the plant falls apart from his classroom out the window. This brings us to my first two full on snark points about the movie:
1) I feel like I'm in a Disney film here, the protagonist just lost one parent (and until later, you think it's both).
2) I never learned the protagonist's first name until the credits. If it was ever used, it was only in passing. People call him son, dad, Lt., etc. but if we ever heard this guy's name in the entire film, I totally missed it!
At this point we do a cut away to fifteen years later, explained helpfully by the words "fifteen years later". Our now old Protagonist is back from a 14 month deployment as an explosive ordinance disposal officer with the U.S. Navy and is looking forward to seeing his family. We meet his wife Elle, who seems to be a pretty strong female character at first, having held the family together during the deployment and having been a single mother while he's been gone, and his son Sam. See, these people have names! Why doesn't Protagonist Everyman!? There's a touching scene with the little Sam asking his "dad", no names for Protagonist Everyman, if he's going to be there tomorrow still, or if he's going to leave again. Protagonist Everyman gently assures his son he will be. We have an awkward half sex scene that satisfies the MPAA need to keep Godzilla PG-13 rather than R, so parents will be more likely to bring their kids to it; they sure did at my showing, along with a very drunk redneck who kept laughing at every single lame joke.
Then we get the call...it's the Japanese consulate in San Francisco. Protagonist Everyman's dad has been arrested in the quarantine zone in Janjiro, Japan, outside of their old house. Protagonist Everyman now has to break the promise to his son, Sam, and go bail his father out of Japanese jail, flying off to Japan. We next see him waiting in a police station, where a punk kid is released first to some VERY angry parents who berate him the entire walk out of the building. It's one of those nice fun moments that breaks up the monotony before the coming of our monster friends. Then Joe, Protagonist Everyman's father is released...for his son to berate him and tell him to stop living in the past, that there is no cover up of any sort.
Joe is still not recovered from shutting the radiation doors on his wife to save himself and others and leads his son, Protagonist Everyman back to his lair. Well, tiny apartment, but it resembles a lair. There are paper clippings everywhere about nuclear coverups and accidents, books on echolocation that he explains loosely are related to tracking what's really happening, but he's still not sure what they're hiding. Seriously, I mean lair, it looks like Joe has become a total serial killer; it's the set up that you expect when the cops burst through the door of some guy who has been chopping up and raping people nonstop. They totally sell me on how mentally unbalanced Joe is, even though I know, due to genre savviness, and a pretty much dotted line path between the shattered cocoon and the nuclear plant 15 years ago, that he's got to be right.
Somehow, Joe convinces Protagonist Everyman to breach the quarantine zone with him by boat. It's all overgrown and foggy, and it looks like the movie makers really did their homework here. This is completely believable growth and decay in the quarantine zone, resembling things like the Chernobyl Exclusion Zone and the Hashima Island, an abandoned coal mining island off of Japan's coast. They find what they want in their old house, including old Zip disks with information on the plant from the date of the meltdown. They stop to gawk across the bay at where it looks like the plant is being rebuilt and get captured and interrogated. Dr. Serizawa tries to kill the creature in the cocoon after reading the information from the zip disks, because, you know, archaic technological media readers are just everywhere apparently, and realizing what's about to happen, but fails. The U.S. Military steps in afterward and seizes control of Project Monarch that is in charge of dealing with these creatures. Joe dies in front of Serizawa and Protagonist Everyman, who is now being called Lieutenant, and will be for the rest of the film.
It's time for Dr. Serizawa and his vaguely British assistant to do an exposition/info-dump on Protagonist Everyman, now that we're on an aircraft carrier off the coast of Japan. We're told that the monsters are MUTOs (Massive Unidentified Terrestrial Organism), an ancient breed of creature which feeds off radiation. The largest of these was discovered in 1954 by a nuclear sub, which was never heard from again in the Pacific Ocean, with both the U.S. and Soviets blaming each other for its disappearance. All the nuclear tests in the Pacific, such as the Bikini Atoll, were actually attempts to kill this MUTO, which Dr. Serizawa has named "Godzilla", because it is like a God, the apex predator of these creatures. The MUTOs are leftovers from an era when Earth was far more irradiated, and they feed on radiation.
When it becomes evident they really need the deceased Joe, Protagonist Everyman's father, he gets sent home via helicopter to Honolulu to catch a connecting flight to San Francisco. He calls his wife, whose phone is on vibrate and then she apparently never checks it again for voice mail, to tell her there was "an accident" in Japan and his dad is dead and that he's coming home. Unfortunately, a Russian sub disappears near Hawaii, and the task force is on the case. They find it, in the middle of jungle near Honolulu, being sucked on by a flying MUTO we saw escape earlier. Bad things happen, the military begins deploying to a rooftop of a hotel and I'm dragged completely out of the film by Snark Point three:
3) How much did Hilton pay to be the only product placement in the film itself, I mean sure, Fiat has TV commercials, but this is in the film? The U.S. military sets up on the Hilton rooftop, it's the only logo visible in all of downtown Honolulu during all of this, and we watch them painstakingly slowly rope down from the helicopter to the Hilton roof. For about two straight minutes, all they tell you to do is book your Hilton Hawaiian vacation today.
Protagonist everyman and a tourist kid are on a tram, he's assured the parents through the glass he'll bring their son back. He calms the kid by giving him a toy soldier from his own childhood, picked up at his old house. Then an EMP blast happens...that's right, the MUTO is on the move in downtown Honolulu and all the electronics get temporarily fried. Because whoever did the research on EMP somehow thinks it's just like tripping a circuit breaker, because every time it gets used, electronics come back on in about a minute. Protagonist Everyman even reassures the kid of this. Sure enough the lights come back on and we find ourselves staring at the now illuminated MUTO who takes a moment to snack on the radiation free train, even though it eats radiation, and so we can see Protagonist Everyman heroically save the kid from becoming monster poop.
Now we get to a shout out to the 2004 Tsunami that devastated Southeast Asia, and in particular a little British girl. You see, when this little girl noticed the sea was foaming and receding, she shouted to her parents that they needed to run, because in school, they learned that was a sign of a tsunami. Sure enough, a little girl, American this time, points out the sea to her parents doing the exact same thing as happened in real life and the father is the one to shout "tsunami". It's a great piece of minor storytelling in a film that seems more interested in action, and really sets the mood, as well as being a nice nod of the head to that little girl's heroism in real life and the lives she saved. Why am I talking about a tsunami? Because Godzilla causes one by coming ashore. Now it's time, I'm pumped, the entire theater is pumped, we're all ready for a fight between Godzilla and the MUTO and...
There's a small fight, we learn this flying MUTO is putting out a mating call. It and Godzilla barely touch each other before it runs away because it's thinking with its penis. Protagonist Everyman and the kid reunite with the kids' parents at a FEMA setup in Honolulu come daylight, and the Navy gives out of uniform and no ID Protagonist Everyman a ride back to California because he says he's in the Navy. Godzilla for some reason swims towards San Francisco, content to have a U.S. Navy escort. Dr. Serizawa looks like a kid on Christmas to get to be on an aircraft carrier, watching his apex nuclear predator up close in the wild.
We get to California and Protagonist Everyman gets sent with a pair of nukes by train; they've got analog triggers to survive EMP. They're going to be sent to San Francisco to be detonated in the bay as bait and to kill the monsters, even though Dr. Serizawa just warns us that it'll make them stronger. What does he know, right? He's just spent his entire career studying this stuff. Dr. Serizawa shows his pocket watch to the admiral in an attempt to make him reconsider; it stopped at 8:15am, on August 6, 1945. The admiral notes it was Hiroshima's bombing time and date, and Dr. Serizawa nods and quietly remarks that it was his father's watch. The admiral decides to continue on with the plan anyhow.
This was a great shout out and brings me to what we'll label Snark Point four, even though it's not really a snark, as much as something that brought me out of the film. This scene made me realize two things, which will both be under this point:
4a) America does not have the same nuclear experience as Japan. This scene is a warning of the danger of nuclear weapons, just as Kaiju films, in particular Godzilla, were meant to be in Japan when they were first produced. Japan has felt their sting, and has a right to fear them. American Kaiju films never measure up usually, because we don't understand culturally, the roots behind them, they're more than 'scary big monster' films. This is an attempt to reconcile that in this scene. Ken Watanabe, playing Dr. Serizawa, is a master of exposition throughout the film, including an exposition to the audience here, if they'll allow his words to reach beyond the Fourth Wall.
4b) Protagonist Everyman keeps being in the places where these MUTOs attack. He's either extremely lucky or unlucky, depending on your point of view, and reminded me of a Japanese businessman at the end of the Second World War. Tsutomu Yamaguchi, worked for Mitsubishi, and was in Hiroshima when it was bombed. He was wounded, but made his way home to Nagasaki, just in time for the second atomic bomb to be dropped on him. Though an estimated 160 people were affected by both atomic bombings, he was the only one recognized by the Japanese government officially as surviving being nuked twice; he only died four years ago in 2010. Protagonist Everyman, here, is essentially our American Tsutomu Yamaguchi; each time he goes somewhere in this film, he encounters a MUTO and he is hurt by them, but continues to survive.
Anyhow, yeah, the pocketwatch totally pulled me out of the film as the action was about to blitzkrieg. The evacuation is stalled as Godzilla arrives. Buses of kids are still on the bridge as the military pulls in Abrams tanks and guys with shoulder mounted rocket launchers. The Navy has what looks like the entire freaking Pacific Fleet in the bay, and they begin to open fire on Godzilla, despite the yelling of one soldier on the bridge that there are civilians there. We're taken out of the film by the actions of an actual everyman character, who in my opinion, is the biggest damn hero of the entire film:
5) The short bus driver. This guy ignores the cops, the military, and all common sense and pushes his busload of child evacuees through the military lines on the bridge with explosions falling all around them and Godzilla ripping a chunk of bridge out next to the bus, in order to save the kids under his care. He's the only person in this film that you can see is genuinely caring more about the civilians than themselves or the monster, and he's risking his life to do so. He steps up to the plate when the U.S. Military is too busy trying not to wet its pants.
Protagonist Everyman is the only survivor when the second, female MUTO, attacks the train and steals a nuke. He gets picked up and patched up as the military recovers the second nuke, and does a Halo drop into San Francisco as part of the bomb disposal team, as the only survivor of the people who put the original trigger in. They make it in, and begin to go on foot towards the nuke and find it in the midst of China Town with a ton of Kaiju eggs all around it. They work to get it free of the nest, and meanwhile Godzilla FINALLY begins an EPIC fight with the two MUTOs. And then Snark Point Six rears its head:
6) What the Hell are the balloons in China Town made of exactly? They survive everything. We see Godzilla roar loud enough to shatter building facades next to these balloons and they stay intact. MUTOs and Godzilla crash through them, and they're still normally inflated on the ground. Seriously, if we made our buildings out of whatever material this is, a Kaiju rampage would never be more than a nuisance to humanity again!
Anyhow, the bomb is damaged and they rush to Plan B, moving it onto a boat to get it as far into the bay as they can, so as not to hurt the citizens of San Francisco. Except for Protagonist Everyman that is. He stays behind, despite orders, to open up fuel lines so that he can torch the nest and kill all the Kaiju eggs. Smart move dude...there are thousands of them after all. This has an added bonus of enraging/distracting the female MUTO from the fight and Godzilla kills the flying male by bashing it repeatedly into a skyscraper.
Protagonist Everyman is the only survivor of his squad, again, and manages to set the boat on auto pilot out to sea. The female MUTO is roaring after the boat when Godzilla grabs her and his scales begin to shimmer and then HELL YES!!! The moment everyone in the theater has been waiting for, Godzilla uses his atomic breath like a momma bird puking into her baby bird's mouth by shoving it straight down the female MUTOs mouth, killing it, and then collapsing himself. Protagonist Everyman is flopped out on the deck of the boat as well, in a very "Do you get the Messianic overtones" crucified pose, bar the crucifixion. Yes, we get it, he's essentially Navy Jesus, except Jesus has never made me wish He was eaten by monsters for being so blandly annoying and Mary-sue-ish.
And now for EVERY OTHER SNARK POINT (or two):
7) The boat is barely moving, maybe pulling ten knots an hour as it goes into the bay. There's 5.5 minutes left on the nuke timer when Protagonist Everyman collapses and looks over from his Navy Jesus pose. We've been told that this is the largest yield nuke ever, that it makes Hiroshima look like a firecracker. The Tsar Bomba, in 1961, had a yield of 50 megatons and could be seen 59 miles away and destroyed an entire village 34 miles away. San Francisco should be entirely and totally doomed then, if this is bigger than that. Yet, Protagonist Everyman, in that five minutes, gets rescued by helicopter, and it detonates with a tiny mushroom cloud and doesn't hurt the city at all, when it should take at least a 40-60 mile chunk out of California.
8) The helicopter, with mere minutes to spare, outruns the shockwave (and actual, you know, EMP) of a double digit megaton nuclear explosion. Just...no. It doesn't work either. No one with even a simple knowledge of nuclear weapons worked on this film. No one looked at Google, no one checked a book out of a library, no one even bothered to watch a documentary on the Manhattan Project. Seriously, there's no other explanation.
Godzilla wakes up as we dig for survivors in a very post-9/11 firefighter scene. Normally I'd think this was kind of exploitative, but really, people have kind of forgotten just how big a deal it was for these men and women to be digging for survivors, almost finding none, and in constant danger. Meanwhile, Dr. Serizawa and his assistant climb the wreckage and look at Godzilla, who suddenly takes a deep breath and stands up. Yes, Godzilla has just risen from the dead. He's Reptar Jesus. Media helicopters show him walking out to see with banners proclaiming, "King of the Monsters" and "The City's Savior" as they tell the world of his exploits. The King of King...erm...King of the Monsters goes back to sea, and we all eagerly await a sequel.
Our last scene is Protagonist Everyman and his family reuniting in a FEMA shelter set up in a stadium. The end. End credits begin to roll and...HOLY CRAP! PROTAGONIST EVERYMAN'S NAME IS FORD!?! COULD WE HAVE MAYBE MENTIONED THAT SOMETIME IN THE LAST TWO HOURS AND ELEVEN MINUTES?! Really folks, the giant monsters had more character development than "Ford", we at least knew their names! Also, I assumed the wife's name "Elle" was an abbreviation, it wasn't, she's just Elle. Like every other woman in the film, she's a very strong feminist figure...until after her first introduction, after that her entire purpose is screaming, crying, overreacting, and being the anti-thesis of a strong female character.
The film starts slow, has almost no character development, and gives entirely too little screentime to its Kaiju. That said, I loved this movie so much! It was an amazing ride, the fight scenes were top notch, and while I could care less about "Ford" and his bland Navy-Jesus thing, I did enjoy the scenes with Joe, his dad, as well as those with Dr. Serizawa. Ken Watanabe lent a lot of gravitas to this film, which made it more enjoyable than it would've been otherwise. The Godzilla reimagining is a classic Kaiju film and quite possibly the first America has actually managed to get right. CNN was correct, it did make me feel like a kid again, and I look forward to the DVD release.
Sunday, April 20, 2014
Happy Anniversary
"Happy Anniversary". Those two words were spoken to me this evening, by the priest at my university parish, and they completely caught me off guard. Longtime readers know what he means though; it was on the Easter Vigil in 2009 that I was received into the Roman Catholic Church. I couldn't help but grin and thank him, because it hadn't crossed my mind that it was sort of an anniversary for me in that!
Why would something like that slip the mind? Well first of all because I was excited...Christ is Risen! The Tomb is empty. "Oh death, where is your sting?"
The second reason is because I was just that caught up in the drama of the Mass and happiness for the two men that were baptised and confirmed tonight. Easter Vigil is the end of Lent and the end of Triduum. It began with a candlelit procession, the long-sung Exsultet, and prayer. Then came seven readings from the Old Testament, seven responsorial Psalms, and seven prayers. Then WHAM, the Gloria is back from its Lenten slumber and the bared altar is being covered once more. The Gospel arrives to the long dormant Alleluia!
Then after the homily it's time...renouncing sins. Baptism. Confirmation. And an outpouring of love by those who came, for those who are entering. There weren't many of us there, not even half the room was filled, but each and every one of us seemed to be deeply joyful for the two men who were joining us. I have to admit, I teared up for them when they received the Eucharist for the first time.
Then things seemed so much better when the Tabernacle closed with the Eucharist inside of it, rather than staying open and empty as it has since Triduum began. He's back in the Tabernacle and it's great! So yes, there were a few things on my mind...but thank you Father S., I appreciate those two words more than you know. It's been five years...and the Church has kept me close to Christ, has served as my rock amidst Qualifier failure and a bad breakup with someone I intended to marry and start a family with. I would be lost without this Church, in an emotional sense and in a very spiritual one.
Our Lord, tonight reminds us, did not stay in the tomb, but instead He rose from the grave, having conquered death after dying for our sins. A happy Easter to all of you! And I leave you with my favorite Easter song:
Why would something like that slip the mind? Well first of all because I was excited...Christ is Risen! The Tomb is empty. "Oh death, where is your sting?"
The second reason is because I was just that caught up in the drama of the Mass and happiness for the two men that were baptised and confirmed tonight. Easter Vigil is the end of Lent and the end of Triduum. It began with a candlelit procession, the long-sung Exsultet, and prayer. Then came seven readings from the Old Testament, seven responsorial Psalms, and seven prayers. Then WHAM, the Gloria is back from its Lenten slumber and the bared altar is being covered once more. The Gospel arrives to the long dormant Alleluia!
Then after the homily it's time...renouncing sins. Baptism. Confirmation. And an outpouring of love by those who came, for those who are entering. There weren't many of us there, not even half the room was filled, but each and every one of us seemed to be deeply joyful for the two men who were joining us. I have to admit, I teared up for them when they received the Eucharist for the first time.
Then things seemed so much better when the Tabernacle closed with the Eucharist inside of it, rather than staying open and empty as it has since Triduum began. He's back in the Tabernacle and it's great! So yes, there were a few things on my mind...but thank you Father S., I appreciate those two words more than you know. It's been five years...and the Church has kept me close to Christ, has served as my rock amidst Qualifier failure and a bad breakup with someone I intended to marry and start a family with. I would be lost without this Church, in an emotional sense and in a very spiritual one.
Our Lord, tonight reminds us, did not stay in the tomb, but instead He rose from the grave, having conquered death after dying for our sins. A happy Easter to all of you! And I leave you with my favorite Easter song:
Thursday, April 17, 2014
Here's Holy Thursday
Holy Thursday, Maundy Thursday, Covenant Thursday, or the Thursday of Mysteries. Today has a great many names, all of which point to the momentous events that happened on it almost two thousand years ago in a land far from my own. Part of the tradition of the Jewish Passover is for the youngest of a family to ask the traditional question, "Why is this night different from any other?" The answers relate to the mercy of God upon the Jewish people during the events described in Exodus. However, for us, the answer is now different.
Why is this night different from any other? Because the Son of God gave us His Body and Blood for the forgiveness of our sins. He gave us the Eucharist in the Last Supper with His Disciples. He told them that His time was ending and that His betrayal at one of their hands was coming. Amazing gifts...gifts we'll never be worthy of, but still given freely to those who would believe in Him and know His love.
Why is this night different from any other? Because it was this night that the Son of God would leave with His Disciples into a garden to pray. And in that garden, we see Him in all of his nature, human and divine; He knows what is to come, He knows what must be done, He knows what He will do. Yet still, He cries. He asks His Father to spare Him if it is possible. His death is coming and He's scared. It's a very human moment and touching beyond words. I can't even begin to express how it makes me feel. God became flesh, and even He was afraid, even He experienced fear. He knew what waits in Heaven, but still, He asked that the cup pass from Him if it was the Father's will. Yet despite that fear, He continued on...and He would do as His Father commanded Him. Just pause to think...the Messiah was frightened. The Savior was scared.
Why is this night different from any other? Courage. It is often said that true courage is to do what is right, despite one's fears. Jesus wept. Jesus was scared. Jesus asked His Father if the cup could pass from Him. Yet when He realized that it was His Father's will for Him to die upon the cross, He accepted. They came for him, a crowd of temple guards and others, swords and spears drawn, torches held high, an angry mob...one of them stepped forward and offered him a greeting kiss. He knew this man, this former disciple of His, Judas and remarked that His former friend would betray the Son of Man with a kiss?
Why is this night different from any other? Because it is on this night that Jesus would be beaten. He would be brought before the Chief Priests, the Scribes, and the Sanhedrin. He would be placed upon trial, spat upon, and the crowds would call for His death. Tomorrow is "Good Friday", the day when He is ordered by Pilate to be crucified. Tomorrow we will remember the fulfillment of Messianic prophecy; today, however, we thank Him for the Eucharist, and we remember the God who felt fear, but did what had to be done for our salvation anyhow.
Why is this night different from any other? Because the Son of God gave us His Body and Blood for the forgiveness of our sins. He gave us the Eucharist in the Last Supper with His Disciples. He told them that His time was ending and that His betrayal at one of their hands was coming. Amazing gifts...gifts we'll never be worthy of, but still given freely to those who would believe in Him and know His love.
Why is this night different from any other? Because it was this night that the Son of God would leave with His Disciples into a garden to pray. And in that garden, we see Him in all of his nature, human and divine; He knows what is to come, He knows what must be done, He knows what He will do. Yet still, He cries. He asks His Father to spare Him if it is possible. His death is coming and He's scared. It's a very human moment and touching beyond words. I can't even begin to express how it makes me feel. God became flesh, and even He was afraid, even He experienced fear. He knew what waits in Heaven, but still, He asked that the cup pass from Him if it was the Father's will. Yet despite that fear, He continued on...and He would do as His Father commanded Him. Just pause to think...the Messiah was frightened. The Savior was scared.
Why is this night different from any other? Courage. It is often said that true courage is to do what is right, despite one's fears. Jesus wept. Jesus was scared. Jesus asked His Father if the cup could pass from Him. Yet when He realized that it was His Father's will for Him to die upon the cross, He accepted. They came for him, a crowd of temple guards and others, swords and spears drawn, torches held high, an angry mob...one of them stepped forward and offered him a greeting kiss. He knew this man, this former disciple of His, Judas and remarked that His former friend would betray the Son of Man with a kiss?
Why is this night different from any other? Because it is on this night that Jesus would be beaten. He would be brought before the Chief Priests, the Scribes, and the Sanhedrin. He would be placed upon trial, spat upon, and the crowds would call for His death. Tomorrow is "Good Friday", the day when He is ordered by Pilate to be crucified. Tomorrow we will remember the fulfillment of Messianic prophecy; today, however, we thank Him for the Eucharist, and we remember the God who felt fear, but did what had to be done for our salvation anyhow.
Thursday, March 06, 2014
Church PTSD
Today I've been learning that there's a lot of talk lately about "Church PTSD" and "Post Traumatic Church Syndrome" as some are calling it. As I read the posts and the comments, I find myself nodding along, because I know these feelings well. I've had them myself.
Leaving my Baptist church is a topic that comes up on here from time to time, but years afterward...almost a third of my life after I stopped attending it, the pain is still there, raw and fresh and bubbling to the surface. It's not a secret to those who know me; I have an almost instinctual hatred of Evangelicalism at this point, and it's not because I find myself in a liturgical church. Rather, reading through those posts and their comments today, I realize that it's because I'm still suffering a bit of Post Traumatic Church Syndrome myself.
The first thing to make me realize this was to read the Thirty by Thirty post on the issue, and then nod along in agreement, and then wince, at the following statement:
1.) Everyone (except us!) is going to Hell. And if you don’t share the gospel with them, their blood is on your hands. Do you want to get to heaven only to see all those you could have saved from eternal damnation?
There we have it, the first gauntlet is thrown. Even growing up, I always held an issue with this. There are more than 40,000 Christian denominations in the world, some of which my own denomination did not recognize as being valid followers of the Christ. I could not fathom that we were the only ones who eventually "got it right" as it were...and the shaming and guilt tripping was incredible for not having a missionary zeal 100% of the time. I've quite literally heard before that "their blood is on your hands".
This sort of shaming was also couched in number three from that post:
3.) It is better to be hot or cold in your faith, lest God SPIT YOU OUT OF HIS MOUTH!!! (Referencing Rev. 3:16)
God will punish you for not being zealous enough. If you're not on fire for God all the time, then you have issues in your life that need confronted. If you're not on fire for God and praising His name at the drop of a hat, you're in trouble with God. If you're not always 100% super Christian, every waking moment, you will be spit out from His mouth...or so I was assured. I went forward for baptism at the age of 16; having believed for years, but having been too ashamed to go forward. I felt as though I would be judged, and to be honest, I still feel like I was judged for waiting too long. People congratulated me, people more often than not, did it in forms of "it took you long enough" or "I always knew you weren't a Believer", because unlike my peers, I didn't go forward by the time I was seven or eight at the very latest.
The truth I've discovered in my own searching and wrestling with this Church PTSD as it were, is that the songwriter Audrey Assad is completely right. Sometimes faith isn't a fire, sometimes it's a soft glow. There are times I am truly passionate for Christ, where I will be able to preach up a firestorm when invited to guest speak before Catholic student groups...and then there are times where I go, "I know You're there Lord, and thanks for all You do for me, but I just don't feel it". That's not being lukewarm, it's being honest with myself and with God; fortunately our God is a god of Love.
Meanwhile, over on Jesus Creed, a former pastor's wife ruminates on just how toxic Church People can be. The commenters, by and large agree with her, as do I. One commenter remarks that he's found far more "Christian" people in behavior among his atheist peers in the business world than he finds in a church pew...sadly I have to agree again. That old song is "They shall know we are Christians by our love", but working almost every Sunday between age eighteen and age twenty-two, do you know how I grew to recognize my brothers and sisters in Christ? By asking myself, "Who are the angriest, rudest, and most demeaning customers we have?" On the Lord's Day, to be blunt, there are a ton of holier than thou "Christian" assholes who turn people off to the message of Christianity and to the saving Grace of Jesus the Christ.
Church People often are the worst; smiling to your face, while slipping a dagger in your back. Professing a belief in Christ, while acting the opposite of how He told us to behave. For an example; my mother used to volunteer in the church prayer chapel back when I was a Baptist and had two rather unfortunate run-ins with the "Worship Band" from the contemporary service we went to at the time. Once, she went to do her shift in the prayer chapel and couldn't, because it was filled with their equipment, as they were too lazy to take their stuff back downstairs. Another time, she was there praying for the intentions in the book left inside the Chapel, when a few people affiliated with the Worship Band came in to set up finger foods for after the service and told her to "just leave. Some of us have actual important things to do." Prayer was unimportant to these Church People, but snacks were.
I watched a 94 year old retiree be fired from his volunteer librarian job and the library turned into new office space for someone's relative, because "nobody reads any more". I watched countless people be driven out, persecuted for not liking the right candidate for the new Senior Pastor. I watched my mother be the token dissenting voice (a fact she soon recognized) on a search committee for a person that was already picked out, they just had to make a show of looking at more qualified candidates. I watched as a man was accused, and that's the only word that fits in the way it happened, of being gay, because he wasn't married at the age of 30. I was personally called heretic, anti-Christ, and Satanist for daring to ask questions about our beliefs, because I wanted to understand why we believed!
And when I did leave the church, or at least stopped attending, nobody said a word. No one voiced a concern or a care. One less troublemaker seeking to understand our faith, one less honest man to have to contend with in all the politicking and power plays and nepotism. They only cared when I came back to request a letter saying I had been baptized, because I was joining the Catholic Church...then they cared, enough to de-friend me en-masse on Facebook and to tell me I was going to Hell.
So yes, I grew up in the late 1980s and the 1990s Christian subcultural bubble. And my experiences in it have indeed left me with a bit of Post Traumatic Church Syndrome. A while ago, The Atlantic posted a piece about atheists, in particular Atheist Millennials, and why they leave the churches. What I saw was a reflection of the road my Evangelical scarring had almost taken me down. Here are the high points of what was discovered:
Almost all off them had gone to church.
Most of the young atheists had not started from a neutral position ideologically, but had left Christianity. Therefore, it was almost reactionary in nature. I would be lying if I said the thought had not occurred to me and I didn't question my God's existence due to His followers and their seething hate.
The mission and message of their churches was vague.
Again, I got called a Satanist, a heretic, and the anti-Christ for asking questions about my faith beyond the standard "Jesus died for you" and "Roman Road" lines. The message was feel good vagueness most of the time and an altar call, and you were expected to be at that altar before you hit double digits in age, or you were written off, by and large, as a lost cause.
They felt their churches offered superficial answers to life's difficult questions.
"Sometimes God says no." "God never gives you more than you can handle." "God helps those who help themselves." "When God closes a door, He opens a window." These are all platitudes I quickly grew tired of in tough times. Plus then you had the anti-evolution seminars and such which relied on pseudoscience, then there were no satisfactory answers for things like why Jesus was the only way? What happened to those who died before He came to die for us? All of these and more, and there were no real answers given. I would have accepted an "I don't know", because that would be intellectually honest, or for why bad things happen to good people, "God let His own Son die on a cross for our sins, why should We be treated better"?
They expressed their respect for those ministers who took the Bible seriously.
We had a few pastors I respected when I was little, and you know what, they all took the Bible seriously. The guy when I left was more worried about his annual vacation to Cancun. This goes for televangelists and radio evangelists as well; I will sit and watch Billy Graham for hours on end, or Fulton J. Sheen, but give me one of the clowns who preaches Prosperity Gospel and I'll turn the channel. Once, working for a school project in the church's meager archives, the workmen renovating the place went to lunch and apologized for having left a preacher on the radio while I was alone there; it wasn't a problem, I told them, I was listening to it the whole time. I respect someone who believes truly and firmly.
Ages 14-17 were decisive.
Age 16 I was baptized. It was also the height of when I began to question my faith due to the vitriol from Christ's followers around me. So yep, another checkmark.
The decision to embrace unbelief was often an emotional one.
Almost anyone who embraces atheism will tell you it's a rational decision, grounded in thought. But often times it's linked to the fact you dealt with jerks, idiots, and bullies. The Atlantic piece shows this pretty well. And yes, when I did contemplate leaving my faith, I was in tears, bawling, because it was my foundation, even if I wasn't always "on fire" for God. For me, knowing God exists, is as simple as knowing I breathe air; but at the same time, it's easy to doubt Him, even though this statement is paradoxical. More often than not, when I look to nature or the stars, I see His handiwork and wonder how anyone can believe He isn't there; but then when I deal with His Christians, in particular, Church People, it becomes so easy to doubt. I went through enough to leave me with Post Traumatic Church Syndrome...the emotion was there, and to an extent, the desire was for a time as well. And while I didn't embrace atheism, I got worse spiritually, before I got better.
The internet factored heavily into their conversion to atheism.
Many of the respondents in the study that The Atlantic talks about, said that it wasn't the superstar New Atheists who converted them, but rather, it was the people who actually stopped to listen and talk to them about their fears and growing lack of belief. I was blessed in this stage of things, because I had a number of Neo Pagan friends...and only one of them tried to convert me to her "side" as it were. The others fought for Christianity and my staying a Christian than 99% of the Christians I knew, including the ones who knew I was struggling.
People who worshiped Morrigan, Brigid, Bacchus, Odin, and Thor and so many others were there telling me not to give up on Christ, just because of His followers. They were recommending books to me: C.S. Lewis, G.K. Chesteron, Archbishop Sheen, Billy Graham, and so many others. They would spend hours on end listening to me rant and replying kindly. Then if I had an issue with a doctrine or belief, where my former church had reacted with anger to stamp things down, the Pagans helped me research why that was believed that way. Some of the greatest defenses of Christianity I've heard in my life, came from someone who worships at the foot of a goddess.
And you know what? God used them to help me stay, along with their free will and their friendship towards me. I paid that forward too, to a young atheist who lost her entire social support network when she stopped believing in God. I gave her boyfriend tips on how to coax her out of her shell, get her back on her feet, help build up a new system of social supports, because what she needed wasn't a firm foundation in her new belief, but the knowledge that people still care. Sorting out faith could come later. Her boyfriend asked why I did what I did, when he knew I was probably (and was) praying for her return to Christ, and the answer was simple enough. "Some people did the same thing for me and they didn't share my faith, and now I'm in the position to do the same." Yes, it's what God would want, yes it was the moral thing to do, but it was done from compassion as a person who experienced the same compassion.
I guess this is where I wrap things up. I'm scarred emotionally and spiritually, but I'm happy where I am now. I'm Catholic. I'm encouraged to question and find answers. I've got the Sacraments. I've got the liturgy. I've got a social support structure. And most importantly...I've got Jesus.
Leaving my Baptist church is a topic that comes up on here from time to time, but years afterward...almost a third of my life after I stopped attending it, the pain is still there, raw and fresh and bubbling to the surface. It's not a secret to those who know me; I have an almost instinctual hatred of Evangelicalism at this point, and it's not because I find myself in a liturgical church. Rather, reading through those posts and their comments today, I realize that it's because I'm still suffering a bit of Post Traumatic Church Syndrome myself.
The first thing to make me realize this was to read the Thirty by Thirty post on the issue, and then nod along in agreement, and then wince, at the following statement:
1.) Everyone (except us!) is going to Hell. And if you don’t share the gospel with them, their blood is on your hands. Do you want to get to heaven only to see all those you could have saved from eternal damnation?
There we have it, the first gauntlet is thrown. Even growing up, I always held an issue with this. There are more than 40,000 Christian denominations in the world, some of which my own denomination did not recognize as being valid followers of the Christ. I could not fathom that we were the only ones who eventually "got it right" as it were...and the shaming and guilt tripping was incredible for not having a missionary zeal 100% of the time. I've quite literally heard before that "their blood is on your hands".
This sort of shaming was also couched in number three from that post:
3.) It is better to be hot or cold in your faith, lest God SPIT YOU OUT OF HIS MOUTH!!! (Referencing Rev. 3:16)
God will punish you for not being zealous enough. If you're not on fire for God all the time, then you have issues in your life that need confronted. If you're not on fire for God and praising His name at the drop of a hat, you're in trouble with God. If you're not always 100% super Christian, every waking moment, you will be spit out from His mouth...or so I was assured. I went forward for baptism at the age of 16; having believed for years, but having been too ashamed to go forward. I felt as though I would be judged, and to be honest, I still feel like I was judged for waiting too long. People congratulated me, people more often than not, did it in forms of "it took you long enough" or "I always knew you weren't a Believer", because unlike my peers, I didn't go forward by the time I was seven or eight at the very latest.
The truth I've discovered in my own searching and wrestling with this Church PTSD as it were, is that the songwriter Audrey Assad is completely right. Sometimes faith isn't a fire, sometimes it's a soft glow. There are times I am truly passionate for Christ, where I will be able to preach up a firestorm when invited to guest speak before Catholic student groups...and then there are times where I go, "I know You're there Lord, and thanks for all You do for me, but I just don't feel it". That's not being lukewarm, it's being honest with myself and with God; fortunately our God is a god of Love.
Meanwhile, over on Jesus Creed, a former pastor's wife ruminates on just how toxic Church People can be. The commenters, by and large agree with her, as do I. One commenter remarks that he's found far more "Christian" people in behavior among his atheist peers in the business world than he finds in a church pew...sadly I have to agree again. That old song is "They shall know we are Christians by our love", but working almost every Sunday between age eighteen and age twenty-two, do you know how I grew to recognize my brothers and sisters in Christ? By asking myself, "Who are the angriest, rudest, and most demeaning customers we have?" On the Lord's Day, to be blunt, there are a ton of holier than thou "Christian" assholes who turn people off to the message of Christianity and to the saving Grace of Jesus the Christ.
Church People often are the worst; smiling to your face, while slipping a dagger in your back. Professing a belief in Christ, while acting the opposite of how He told us to behave. For an example; my mother used to volunteer in the church prayer chapel back when I was a Baptist and had two rather unfortunate run-ins with the "Worship Band" from the contemporary service we went to at the time. Once, she went to do her shift in the prayer chapel and couldn't, because it was filled with their equipment, as they were too lazy to take their stuff back downstairs. Another time, she was there praying for the intentions in the book left inside the Chapel, when a few people affiliated with the Worship Band came in to set up finger foods for after the service and told her to "just leave. Some of us have actual important things to do." Prayer was unimportant to these Church People, but snacks were.
I watched a 94 year old retiree be fired from his volunteer librarian job and the library turned into new office space for someone's relative, because "nobody reads any more". I watched countless people be driven out, persecuted for not liking the right candidate for the new Senior Pastor. I watched my mother be the token dissenting voice (a fact she soon recognized) on a search committee for a person that was already picked out, they just had to make a show of looking at more qualified candidates. I watched as a man was accused, and that's the only word that fits in the way it happened, of being gay, because he wasn't married at the age of 30. I was personally called heretic, anti-Christ, and Satanist for daring to ask questions about our beliefs, because I wanted to understand why we believed!
And when I did leave the church, or at least stopped attending, nobody said a word. No one voiced a concern or a care. One less troublemaker seeking to understand our faith, one less honest man to have to contend with in all the politicking and power plays and nepotism. They only cared when I came back to request a letter saying I had been baptized, because I was joining the Catholic Church...then they cared, enough to de-friend me en-masse on Facebook and to tell me I was going to Hell.
So yes, I grew up in the late 1980s and the 1990s Christian subcultural bubble. And my experiences in it have indeed left me with a bit of Post Traumatic Church Syndrome. A while ago, The Atlantic posted a piece about atheists, in particular Atheist Millennials, and why they leave the churches. What I saw was a reflection of the road my Evangelical scarring had almost taken me down. Here are the high points of what was discovered:
Almost all off them had gone to church.
Most of the young atheists had not started from a neutral position ideologically, but had left Christianity. Therefore, it was almost reactionary in nature. I would be lying if I said the thought had not occurred to me and I didn't question my God's existence due to His followers and their seething hate.
The mission and message of their churches was vague.
Again, I got called a Satanist, a heretic, and the anti-Christ for asking questions about my faith beyond the standard "Jesus died for you" and "Roman Road" lines. The message was feel good vagueness most of the time and an altar call, and you were expected to be at that altar before you hit double digits in age, or you were written off, by and large, as a lost cause.
They felt their churches offered superficial answers to life's difficult questions.
"Sometimes God says no." "God never gives you more than you can handle." "God helps those who help themselves." "When God closes a door, He opens a window." These are all platitudes I quickly grew tired of in tough times. Plus then you had the anti-evolution seminars and such which relied on pseudoscience, then there were no satisfactory answers for things like why Jesus was the only way? What happened to those who died before He came to die for us? All of these and more, and there were no real answers given. I would have accepted an "I don't know", because that would be intellectually honest, or for why bad things happen to good people, "God let His own Son die on a cross for our sins, why should We be treated better"?
They expressed their respect for those ministers who took the Bible seriously.
We had a few pastors I respected when I was little, and you know what, they all took the Bible seriously. The guy when I left was more worried about his annual vacation to Cancun. This goes for televangelists and radio evangelists as well; I will sit and watch Billy Graham for hours on end, or Fulton J. Sheen, but give me one of the clowns who preaches Prosperity Gospel and I'll turn the channel. Once, working for a school project in the church's meager archives, the workmen renovating the place went to lunch and apologized for having left a preacher on the radio while I was alone there; it wasn't a problem, I told them, I was listening to it the whole time. I respect someone who believes truly and firmly.
Ages 14-17 were decisive.
Age 16 I was baptized. It was also the height of when I began to question my faith due to the vitriol from Christ's followers around me. So yep, another checkmark.
The decision to embrace unbelief was often an emotional one.
Almost anyone who embraces atheism will tell you it's a rational decision, grounded in thought. But often times it's linked to the fact you dealt with jerks, idiots, and bullies. The Atlantic piece shows this pretty well. And yes, when I did contemplate leaving my faith, I was in tears, bawling, because it was my foundation, even if I wasn't always "on fire" for God. For me, knowing God exists, is as simple as knowing I breathe air; but at the same time, it's easy to doubt Him, even though this statement is paradoxical. More often than not, when I look to nature or the stars, I see His handiwork and wonder how anyone can believe He isn't there; but then when I deal with His Christians, in particular, Church People, it becomes so easy to doubt. I went through enough to leave me with Post Traumatic Church Syndrome...the emotion was there, and to an extent, the desire was for a time as well. And while I didn't embrace atheism, I got worse spiritually, before I got better.
The internet factored heavily into their conversion to atheism.
Many of the respondents in the study that The Atlantic talks about, said that it wasn't the superstar New Atheists who converted them, but rather, it was the people who actually stopped to listen and talk to them about their fears and growing lack of belief. I was blessed in this stage of things, because I had a number of Neo Pagan friends...and only one of them tried to convert me to her "side" as it were. The others fought for Christianity and my staying a Christian than 99% of the Christians I knew, including the ones who knew I was struggling.
People who worshiped Morrigan, Brigid, Bacchus, Odin, and Thor and so many others were there telling me not to give up on Christ, just because of His followers. They were recommending books to me: C.S. Lewis, G.K. Chesteron, Archbishop Sheen, Billy Graham, and so many others. They would spend hours on end listening to me rant and replying kindly. Then if I had an issue with a doctrine or belief, where my former church had reacted with anger to stamp things down, the Pagans helped me research why that was believed that way. Some of the greatest defenses of Christianity I've heard in my life, came from someone who worships at the foot of a goddess.
And you know what? God used them to help me stay, along with their free will and their friendship towards me. I paid that forward too, to a young atheist who lost her entire social support network when she stopped believing in God. I gave her boyfriend tips on how to coax her out of her shell, get her back on her feet, help build up a new system of social supports, because what she needed wasn't a firm foundation in her new belief, but the knowledge that people still care. Sorting out faith could come later. Her boyfriend asked why I did what I did, when he knew I was probably (and was) praying for her return to Christ, and the answer was simple enough. "Some people did the same thing for me and they didn't share my faith, and now I'm in the position to do the same." Yes, it's what God would want, yes it was the moral thing to do, but it was done from compassion as a person who experienced the same compassion.
I guess this is where I wrap things up. I'm scarred emotionally and spiritually, but I'm happy where I am now. I'm Catholic. I'm encouraged to question and find answers. I've got the Sacraments. I've got the liturgy. I've got a social support structure. And most importantly...I've got Jesus.
Sunday, January 05, 2014
Epiphany
Looking about the Mass this morning, I could not help but notice all the dour faces. Though it was with good cause; only about half the regulars had made it to the 7am Mass at my parish at home, due in no small part to the cold. The first thing that hit me was the saying attributed to Saint Teresa of Avila, "God save me from sour-faced saints!". The second was, "Good grief Phil, try smiling yourself why don't you?" Mass is always good to me in one secular regard, and that is in reminding me of what a hypocrite I can be! Whether it's while praying a penitential prayer, or even just a recognition that I'm frowning too. That, my friends, is known as an epiphany, and fitting that it happens on Epiphany.
Epiphany is the day when we celebrate the coming of the three wise men to worship at the feet of the Christ child. Their gifts are highly symbolic even. The gold representing Jesus's kingship. The frankincense a gift fitting of God's own High Priest, and then the last gift...myrrh, a burial ointment, a sign of how this was all going to end in thirty-three years. More than just bearing symbolic gifts, the magi themselves also represent something greater. Us.
It is my guess that few, if any, who read this post will be of Jewish descent, yet we all worship Jesus Christ as the Lord. The children of Abraham, in faith, are primarily gentiles. The Epiphany shows us the first occurrence where gentiles come before the Christ and pay Him homage as a King. They are the first, but they are not the last. Paul and Peter will fight over issues related to gentile believers in the early Church and even by the end of the first century, a number of gentile followers could be found throughout the Roman Empire. Eventually Christianity would become the Empire's state religion, with the gentile followers vastly outnumbering those of the people that the Christ was born into. Missionaries would go forth across the world over the next centuries, sometimes at the point of the sword, other times with but their words to gird them. Two millenia later, we enter the scene...two billion followers of the Christ, almost all of us gentiles who follow in the footsteps of those magi at the Epiphany. It's been a long road from three men who came to pay homage, but we continue it, and those after us will do the same.
Epiphany is the day when we celebrate the coming of the three wise men to worship at the feet of the Christ child. Their gifts are highly symbolic even. The gold representing Jesus's kingship. The frankincense a gift fitting of God's own High Priest, and then the last gift...myrrh, a burial ointment, a sign of how this was all going to end in thirty-three years. More than just bearing symbolic gifts, the magi themselves also represent something greater. Us.
It is my guess that few, if any, who read this post will be of Jewish descent, yet we all worship Jesus Christ as the Lord. The children of Abraham, in faith, are primarily gentiles. The Epiphany shows us the first occurrence where gentiles come before the Christ and pay Him homage as a King. They are the first, but they are not the last. Paul and Peter will fight over issues related to gentile believers in the early Church and even by the end of the first century, a number of gentile followers could be found throughout the Roman Empire. Eventually Christianity would become the Empire's state religion, with the gentile followers vastly outnumbering those of the people that the Christ was born into. Missionaries would go forth across the world over the next centuries, sometimes at the point of the sword, other times with but their words to gird them. Two millenia later, we enter the scene...two billion followers of the Christ, almost all of us gentiles who follow in the footsteps of those magi at the Epiphany. It's been a long road from three men who came to pay homage, but we continue it, and those after us will do the same.
Friday, December 06, 2013
Rest in Peace Nelson Mandela (1918-2013)
There's a quote outside my office door, hanging under my office hours, that I chose to represent this semester as I dove into teaching Juvenile Justice and Law for the first time. It's from Nelson Mandela, and simply states a profound truth, "There can be no keener revelation of a society's soul than the way in which it treats its children." The quote has always struck me as being one of those core truths that seems to be undeniable, and I have tried to keep it in mind as the semester has gone on. It's something that those who have taken my Juveniles class have heard me say time and again.
Yesterday, however, the voice that spoke those words went silent forever. Nelson Mandela, known to some as Madiba, died in his home at the age of 95. In this age of Facebook, Twitter, message boards, texting, and so much else, I found out about his passing through an old fashioned method; there was a brief interruption of a commercial break with breaking news and promising more information after the show. The reaction from around the world has been swift. Mandela's home of South Africa has entered into ten days of mourning, and even last night, the U.S. Capitol's flag was lowered to half mast...for those who don't keep up with the way the U.S. does this sort of thing, it's a rather big deal. We almost exclusively lower the flag for Americans and usually the highly influential ones at that, those which are often hailed as national heroes.
So why does Mandela rate this sort of treatment? Because he was a hero, not just to South Africa, but to the world. Nelson Mandela is a man whose adult life is a lesson in humility. Sentenced to prison for twenty-seven years for fighting against Apartheid and when he was finally released, he did not seek vengeance, he did not rail against those who had deprived him of his liberty, instead he spoke of the need for reconciliation between the races in South Africa. When he became the nation's first elected black President, he did not use the position to turn around and seek vengeance on those who had wronged him, but instead he used it to draft a new Constitution, to form of a government which included members of the former regime in a show of unity, and formed the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, a court which operated on the principles of restorative justice instead of punitive retribution. He spent his time introducing land reforms, combating the rampant poverty in his nation, and trying to help people get health care.
Then he did the unthinkable to many. He could have run for President again, he would have won in a landslide, but after a single term in office, Madiba would step down. Rather than clinging to ultimate power like so many others have done, especially those who were once imprisoned by their government, he announced with a smile that he'd not run again and that instead, he would be focusing on charity work. As his life drew to a close, he had received more than 250 honors from around the world, ranging from the 1993 Nobel Peace Prize which he shared with South Africa's then white President for helping to dismantle Apartheid to being quite possibly the only person to receive both the Soviet Order of Lenin and U.S. Presidential Medal of Freedom.
In his lifetime, he did embrace violence reluctantly, saying it was needed for self defense against the violence of Apartheid, but all of his greatest work was done through his iconic forms of nonviolent resistance. Faith, hope, charity, and the ability to forgive are the hallmarks of the Mandela legacy. Most men who advocate such things die at a relatively young age: Jesus Christ, Martin Luther King Jr., Gandhi, and many others. However, this man, sometimes called "Tata", or "father" of his nation, lived to an old age of 95. This adds to his legacy as well, for so few peacemakers can live to nearly see the century mark. Last night, the world lost a good man, one whom I am proud to say, I have held as one of my personal heroes for many years.
In the end, I think Secretary General Ban Ki Moon of the United Nations put it best, last night, when he said, "Nelson Mandela was a singular figure on the global stage -- a man of quiet dignity and towering achievement, a giant for justice and a down-to-earth human inspiration." A man who used his power for reconciliation, not revenge. A man who sought justice, not vengeance. A man who had power and surrendered it after one term, so that he might help the poor. A man, who in the end, won't be remembered by history alongside so many others for their conquests by the sword, but rather as a man whose legacy is assured by the fact that he would not put those to death, who may otherwise have deserved it for their atrocities. A man who held on to a simple underlying truth that we so often forget, that all life is sacred.
Yesterday, however, the voice that spoke those words went silent forever. Nelson Mandela, known to some as Madiba, died in his home at the age of 95. In this age of Facebook, Twitter, message boards, texting, and so much else, I found out about his passing through an old fashioned method; there was a brief interruption of a commercial break with breaking news and promising more information after the show. The reaction from around the world has been swift. Mandela's home of South Africa has entered into ten days of mourning, and even last night, the U.S. Capitol's flag was lowered to half mast...for those who don't keep up with the way the U.S. does this sort of thing, it's a rather big deal. We almost exclusively lower the flag for Americans and usually the highly influential ones at that, those which are often hailed as national heroes.
So why does Mandela rate this sort of treatment? Because he was a hero, not just to South Africa, but to the world. Nelson Mandela is a man whose adult life is a lesson in humility. Sentenced to prison for twenty-seven years for fighting against Apartheid and when he was finally released, he did not seek vengeance, he did not rail against those who had deprived him of his liberty, instead he spoke of the need for reconciliation between the races in South Africa. When he became the nation's first elected black President, he did not use the position to turn around and seek vengeance on those who had wronged him, but instead he used it to draft a new Constitution, to form of a government which included members of the former regime in a show of unity, and formed the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, a court which operated on the principles of restorative justice instead of punitive retribution. He spent his time introducing land reforms, combating the rampant poverty in his nation, and trying to help people get health care.
Then he did the unthinkable to many. He could have run for President again, he would have won in a landslide, but after a single term in office, Madiba would step down. Rather than clinging to ultimate power like so many others have done, especially those who were once imprisoned by their government, he announced with a smile that he'd not run again and that instead, he would be focusing on charity work. As his life drew to a close, he had received more than 250 honors from around the world, ranging from the 1993 Nobel Peace Prize which he shared with South Africa's then white President for helping to dismantle Apartheid to being quite possibly the only person to receive both the Soviet Order of Lenin and U.S. Presidential Medal of Freedom.
In his lifetime, he did embrace violence reluctantly, saying it was needed for self defense against the violence of Apartheid, but all of his greatest work was done through his iconic forms of nonviolent resistance. Faith, hope, charity, and the ability to forgive are the hallmarks of the Mandela legacy. Most men who advocate such things die at a relatively young age: Jesus Christ, Martin Luther King Jr., Gandhi, and many others. However, this man, sometimes called "Tata", or "father" of his nation, lived to an old age of 95. This adds to his legacy as well, for so few peacemakers can live to nearly see the century mark. Last night, the world lost a good man, one whom I am proud to say, I have held as one of my personal heroes for many years.
In the end, I think Secretary General Ban Ki Moon of the United Nations put it best, last night, when he said, "Nelson Mandela was a singular figure on the global stage -- a man of quiet dignity and towering achievement, a giant for justice and a down-to-earth human inspiration." A man who used his power for reconciliation, not revenge. A man who sought justice, not vengeance. A man who had power and surrendered it after one term, so that he might help the poor. A man, who in the end, won't be remembered by history alongside so many others for their conquests by the sword, but rather as a man whose legacy is assured by the fact that he would not put those to death, who may otherwise have deserved it for their atrocities. A man who held on to a simple underlying truth that we so often forget, that all life is sacred.
Friday, November 08, 2013
...And the Wall Came Tumbling Down
Tomorrow is the anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall. I was three years old and have no personal memory of the fall of the Wall, but its historical significance is not something to be missed. For decades, during the Cold War, the Wall kept East and West Berlin divided. During those dark years, between 136 and 200 Germans would lose their lives in an effort to escape from the Stalinist Soviet controlled East Germany and into the West German section of the city.
On November 9th, 1989, a series of communication errors lead to the people storming across the Wall to embrace one another. Where once, men and women faced machine guns for climbing over, instead, people danced joyously together. Sledgehammers and other tools pecked away at the symbol of oppression that had divided a people, and even families, for generations. It is often seen as one of the death knells of the Soviet Union.
Today the Berlin Wall's segments can be found around the world, from Germany itself to the Vatican's gardens to the Newseum in Washington D.C. It was in the latter that I was able to see a piece of the Wall firsthand...and I must admit, for one of two times while at that museum celebrating the history of journalism, I had the impression of standing on hallowed ground (the other being the communication mast of the World Trade Center's North Tower). Staring at the piece of the Berlin Wall made so many history lessons seem that much more real, and the sorrow of a people divided, just as clear. I was about to move on from the Wall when a volunteer asked if I wanted a photo, so I said yes, after all, it would be good to remember a time I saw such an important part of history and to remember that unlike those who died trying to escape over it, I only saw it as a museum piece of an era best left behind, but unforgotten.
On November 9th, 1989, a series of communication errors lead to the people storming across the Wall to embrace one another. Where once, men and women faced machine guns for climbing over, instead, people danced joyously together. Sledgehammers and other tools pecked away at the symbol of oppression that had divided a people, and even families, for generations. It is often seen as one of the death knells of the Soviet Union.
Today the Berlin Wall's segments can be found around the world, from Germany itself to the Vatican's gardens to the Newseum in Washington D.C. It was in the latter that I was able to see a piece of the Wall firsthand...and I must admit, for one of two times while at that museum celebrating the history of journalism, I had the impression of standing on hallowed ground (the other being the communication mast of the World Trade Center's North Tower). Staring at the piece of the Berlin Wall made so many history lessons seem that much more real, and the sorrow of a people divided, just as clear. I was about to move on from the Wall when a volunteer asked if I wanted a photo, so I said yes, after all, it would be good to remember a time I saw such an important part of history and to remember that unlike those who died trying to escape over it, I only saw it as a museum piece of an era best left behind, but unforgotten.
Tuesday, October 08, 2013
Abiding
I went to Adoration earlier. Something that has never changed in my habit of going to Adoration, since my ex found the only Perpetual Adoration chapel in my home state, is how I arrive. Perfectly fine the entire way there, but once I start to approach the doors of a church where Adoration is going on inside, I begin to acquire a feeling of the utmost anticipation and a small dose of fear. Fear that I'm not worthy to sit before Him, fear that I'm not going to know what to say. It's quite a bit of what Saint Paul says, "work out your salvation with fear and trembling".
At first I worried and prayed, but then, as I continued, the calm that always settles upon me while sitting with Him in Adoration fell. I prayed my Divine Mercy Chaplet for friends, the website Phatmass and its posters, and for all who are struggling. When that was done I got up from my knees and simply stared at Him, getting lost in thought and then just settling into a period where I abided. My worries melted away. Theology, Trads vs. NOers, the government shutdown, my loans, dissertation, it all just melted away. I was at Peace, for I sat before the Creator of all things, and He loves me.
It's an experience so hard to convey in words. I even whispered to Him that it often felt like everyone was on fire but me, and then a thought came to head, a lyric from Audrey Assad in her excellent song Slow,
At first I worried and prayed, but then, as I continued, the calm that always settles upon me while sitting with Him in Adoration fell. I prayed my Divine Mercy Chaplet for friends, the website Phatmass and its posters, and for all who are struggling. When that was done I got up from my knees and simply stared at Him, getting lost in thought and then just settling into a period where I abided. My worries melted away. Theology, Trads vs. NOers, the government shutdown, my loans, dissertation, it all just melted away. I was at Peace, for I sat before the Creator of all things, and He loves me.
It's an experience so hard to convey in words. I even whispered to Him that it often felt like everyone was on fire but me, and then a thought came to head, a lyric from Audrey Assad in her excellent song Slow,
"Faith is not a fire
As much as it's a glow
A quiet lovely burning
Underneath the snow
And it's not too much
It's just enough to give me hope
Cause love moves slow
Love moves slow"
As much as it's a glow
A quiet lovely burning
Underneath the snow
And it's not too much
It's just enough to give me hope
Cause love moves slow
Love moves slow"
Friday, October 04, 2013
Why I'll Never Donate to K-Love
On my way to and from work, I listen to K-Love, a Christian radio station. However, twice a year, they have the "annual pledge drive", which is a festering sore upon the face of anotherwise nice outreach. The reason I say it is such, is due to the weedling, guilt tripping, and otherwise plain old un-truths that it refers to. These are the reasons I will never donate to K-Love, not because the Devil has hardened my heart to them, but because I refuse to donate to something using Word of Faith Prosperity Gospel tactics, I refuse to donate to something that is trying to cash in on the suffering of children, and I refuse to donate to people who fly off the handle and make pronouncements like some of the ones below.
K-LOVE Christian Radio is the King of Guilt (along with sister station Air1 they both fall under Electronic Media Foundation). My mother donates to them and still turns it off during the few weeks a year they do Pledge Drive, because if she didn't, she would stop donating to them. . Some of the gems from the last few pledge drives (paraphrasing and then in parentheses I'll put how I interpret it):
1. "IF YOU HAVE A JOB, ANY JOB AT ALL, YOU HAVE NO EXCUSE! NO EXCUSE AT ALL NOT TO DONATE TO OUR MINISTRY! NO EXCUSE!" (Caps intentional because the DJ screamed that...one of his cohosts told him to go get a freaking coffee or something. Anyhow, my take on that is, "We want your money and you need to give us money. Prosperity Gospel for real; God wants you to give money to us and you'll be rewarded for it.")
2. Do you know how many suicides K-LOVE prevented last year when people called us? Well we do [insert number]; that many people are alive today because you donated to your K-LOVE station. (I take that as, "If you don't give us money, people will kill themselves! Their blood is on your hands if you don't donate now!")
3. If you don't donate to us right now, more women will have abortions. Just listen to [person]'s story, one of many, about how your donations provide counseling for pregnant women who call us for help. (My take, "If you don't donate to us now, women will have abortions, and if you're a real Christian, you're participating in the genocide of the unborn. How's that on your conscience huh? How's that?")
4. Last year [number here] people gave their lives to Jesus Christ through the ministry of K-LOVE and that's possible through your continued support of your local K-LOVE station. (My take, "If you don't support K-LOVE, you're sending people straight to Hell.)
5. Endless quick radio bites by people who say K-LOVE saved their life. (Each is individual and a "true story" from a listener.)
6. "I have a hard time believing that there aren’t more listeners who can’t afford $20 a month, not even the full $40." (My take: Give us money, give us money, you have the money.)
7. “One of our listeners just called to become part of our family. She did not think that she actually had enough money to do so, but, for a long time, she has felt that God has been telling her to call in and give to K-Love anyways. So she did.” (Direct quote from A Social Spirituality's blog post on KLOVE's fundraising. My take, "We don't care that you don't have the money, just give it to us anyhow and trust God won't let you down because you gave money to a ministry.")
8. "You can even sign up to donate on the Easy Gift Plan. Right out of your checking account, it saves us money and you money by eliminating paper and postage!" (My take: Give us even more money. Now. We'll take it directly from your checking account.)
9. If you don't meet 100% funding for your local K-Love station, it will probably go off the air. If we don't meet 100% funding for pledge drive, we're going to have to make cuts and it won't be pretty... (I saved this for last, because every point before now that involves money leads up to this...umm yeah, about that...how about your $34,678,623 profit according to Charity Navigator, the almost half a million you pay your President, etc.? Did I mention they sponsor a NASCAR team?)
10. We're working with Angel Tree this year. Did you know children who have parents in prison are more likely to go to prison? What if you could help stop that cycle, by donating $40 a month to K-Love this pledge drive, Angel Tree will send those children a gift, something from their dad, and the Saving Gospel of Jesus Christ. (My take: Angel Tree is a wonderful ministry, and yes, they are correct about the correlation between parental incarceration and later delinquency. However, using children's suffering to sell your radio station is wrong. You're not making me feel guilty, you're making me see an angry red.)
11. Direct quote from this morning (around 7:15am on 10/4/2013 EST), "Don't let the Devil stop you from donating to a ministry that saves lives". (My take: You're implying that the Prince of Hell wants me to not give money to you. It doesn't get more Christian guilt trip than that, "DO THIS OR THE DEVIL WINS" is no way to raise money.)
Sunday, September 29, 2013
FeLiNa (Breaking Bad Spoilers)
This post has been written in commercial breaks as a stream of
consciousness. Nice beginning there, with the whole shout out to the
song Felina, that many of we fans had seized upon.
Our friends from Gray Matter were played perfectly there and so was Walt’s decision on how to handle them. Nearly ten million in an irrevocable trust for his son, for college and taking care of the family from “wealthy benefactors who once knew his father quite well” who were sorry the family suffered. The laser pointers from the meth addicts being the “hitmen” was brilliant as well, just the sort of ploy we’ve all come to expect from Heisenberg.
Walt’s birthday, 52 apparently. Only two years has passed in show? The final showdown comes on the anniversary of when it all began. Flashback to the pilot as Walt reflects on how it all began in the ruins of his former home, fallen into disuse and vandalism.
Lydia meats Todd at her favorite place to eat. He makes awkward small talk as Walter White sits down next to the two of them. He tries to convince them he needs money and has a new method of making meth. Lydia dismisses him and tells Todd, essentially, to mercy kill him. Then the camera zooms in as she puts her sweetener in her tea; Walt remarked he knew to find her there because they always met there, at that table…is the ricin in the sweetener packet?
Walt shows up to talk to Skylar one last time, right after Marie calls about him being back in town according to an old neighbor. He tells her how Hank and Gomez died and hands her a lotto ticket, the one with the coordinates, and tells her they’re buried there and to call the DEA when he leaves and trade it for a deal with the prosecutor. He starts to say he has one last thing to tell her about why he did it and she interrupts, telling him she’s tired of his saying it was for the family. He cuts her off, the month’s introspection helping him apparently, “I did it for me…I was, I was good at it. I felt alive.” He plaintively asks to see his daughter one last time and wipes a wisp of her hair from her sleeping face and leaves. Flynn gets off the bus, and Walt watches, unable to speak to his son who now hates him, closure seemingly denied.
Walt’s machine gun key fob rig was a bit contrived in all honesty, but the way it killed almost all the Nazis wasn’t. I was happy to see Walt tackle Jesse to save his life and even happier to see Jesse get to garrote Todd. Walter’s true moment where we saw his growth as a person had to come as he held the gun on the wounded Jack, and Jack tells him that he can tell Walt where the rest of the money is. Walter kills him. It’s not about the money for Walt now, it’s about tying up loose ends. It’s about leaving a better world for his family. He asks Jesse to kill him, because he’s been mortally wounded by the machine gun. Jesse refuses and drives away, yelling happily.
Jesse Pinkman ends this series as the redeemed man. He began as an addict, he abetted White’s fall into evil, he became a partner in great evil. However, after his imprisonment by the Nazis, he no longer seems addicted (months of forced hard rehab). He has the chance to kill White, something he wanted months ago, and he spares him, a bit to see him suffer, but also to free himself from servitude to White’s whims, just as Walt saved him from servitude to the Nazis. He apparently goes to the police too, because we see them pulling in, in the middle of nowhere, as Walt holds a gas mask and leaves a bloody handprint as he falls dead next to a tank in a meth lab. We begin to pull away and show the police storming the place…any doubt that Walt is dead is dispelled when they treat him as a dead body.
As for Lydia, the corporate face of the blue meth empire. She won’t be distributing any stored up product the Nazis might have given her. She calls Todd’s phone shortly before Walt dies and is answered by Heisenberg, who informs her that she’s suffering flu like symptoms because the ricin was indeed in her sweetener. He hangs up and tosses the phone away, having pronounced her death sentence.
Walter White destroyed everything he had built. His empire built upon the death, suffering, and addiction of others is toppled. In the end, even he finds a measure of redemption, his fatal wound being the result of having saved Jesse’s life.
At the end of the night, redemption is the word of the hour. In the words of J.K. Rowling, “All was well.”
Our friends from Gray Matter were played perfectly there and so was Walt’s decision on how to handle them. Nearly ten million in an irrevocable trust for his son, for college and taking care of the family from “wealthy benefactors who once knew his father quite well” who were sorry the family suffered. The laser pointers from the meth addicts being the “hitmen” was brilliant as well, just the sort of ploy we’ve all come to expect from Heisenberg.
Walt’s birthday, 52 apparently. Only two years has passed in show? The final showdown comes on the anniversary of when it all began. Flashback to the pilot as Walt reflects on how it all began in the ruins of his former home, fallen into disuse and vandalism.
Lydia meats Todd at her favorite place to eat. He makes awkward small talk as Walter White sits down next to the two of them. He tries to convince them he needs money and has a new method of making meth. Lydia dismisses him and tells Todd, essentially, to mercy kill him. Then the camera zooms in as she puts her sweetener in her tea; Walt remarked he knew to find her there because they always met there, at that table…is the ricin in the sweetener packet?
Walt shows up to talk to Skylar one last time, right after Marie calls about him being back in town according to an old neighbor. He tells her how Hank and Gomez died and hands her a lotto ticket, the one with the coordinates, and tells her they’re buried there and to call the DEA when he leaves and trade it for a deal with the prosecutor. He starts to say he has one last thing to tell her about why he did it and she interrupts, telling him she’s tired of his saying it was for the family. He cuts her off, the month’s introspection helping him apparently, “I did it for me…I was, I was good at it. I felt alive.” He plaintively asks to see his daughter one last time and wipes a wisp of her hair from her sleeping face and leaves. Flynn gets off the bus, and Walt watches, unable to speak to his son who now hates him, closure seemingly denied.
Walt’s machine gun key fob rig was a bit contrived in all honesty, but the way it killed almost all the Nazis wasn’t. I was happy to see Walt tackle Jesse to save his life and even happier to see Jesse get to garrote Todd. Walter’s true moment where we saw his growth as a person had to come as he held the gun on the wounded Jack, and Jack tells him that he can tell Walt where the rest of the money is. Walter kills him. It’s not about the money for Walt now, it’s about tying up loose ends. It’s about leaving a better world for his family. He asks Jesse to kill him, because he’s been mortally wounded by the machine gun. Jesse refuses and drives away, yelling happily.
Jesse Pinkman ends this series as the redeemed man. He began as an addict, he abetted White’s fall into evil, he became a partner in great evil. However, after his imprisonment by the Nazis, he no longer seems addicted (months of forced hard rehab). He has the chance to kill White, something he wanted months ago, and he spares him, a bit to see him suffer, but also to free himself from servitude to White’s whims, just as Walt saved him from servitude to the Nazis. He apparently goes to the police too, because we see them pulling in, in the middle of nowhere, as Walt holds a gas mask and leaves a bloody handprint as he falls dead next to a tank in a meth lab. We begin to pull away and show the police storming the place…any doubt that Walt is dead is dispelled when they treat him as a dead body.
As for Lydia, the corporate face of the blue meth empire. She won’t be distributing any stored up product the Nazis might have given her. She calls Todd’s phone shortly before Walt dies and is answered by Heisenberg, who informs her that she’s suffering flu like symptoms because the ricin was indeed in her sweetener. He hangs up and tosses the phone away, having pronounced her death sentence.
Walter White destroyed everything he had built. His empire built upon the death, suffering, and addiction of others is toppled. In the end, even he finds a measure of redemption, his fatal wound being the result of having saved Jesse’s life.
At the end of the night, redemption is the word of the hour. In the words of J.K. Rowling, “All was well.”
Monday, September 16, 2013
Ozymandias
When this season of Breaking Bad was being advertised, they had Walter White reading the famous poem "Ozymandias", by Percy Shelley. In some ways, after last night's episode, I first thought that Yeats's "The Second Coming" would have been appropriate with such lines as:
The story about Breaking Bad is primarily broken into three types. The first is that of crime; Walt as Heisenberg, is a meth drug lord and all that implies. The second is the story of Walter White's transformation from mild mannered family man, to ruthless kingpin Heisenberg. The third is Walter's relationship with his family, trying to hold on to it, despite the evil things he has done. Last night hit upon all three of these elements and tore them apart.
The episode began with a flashback to a simpler time, where Walt had to prepare himself to lie to his wife about cooking meth. We see him as the man he once was, the man who wanted to help his family with the drug money and the loving father who was incapable of easily betraying the trust of the love of his life. Yet that did not continue for long, as fans know. Cut forward in time and Walt is laying in the back of a bullet riddled car. Agent Gomez is dead. Hank, Walt's DEA brother in law is bleeding on the ground. As the white supremacists move in to kill Hank, Walt struggles from the car and begins to beg for Hank's life, "He's family!" In the past, this is where Walt would have managed one more deal and boy did Walt try, informing them about his $80 million and offering them the money if they would just spare his brother in law...this time however, Hank gives the most chilling line of the entire show, "You're one of the smartest men I know. Can't you tell he made up his mind ten minutes ago?" Then he turns his face to the white supremacists and utters one last line, dying with some dignity as he's killed mid sentence.
Walt tumbles to the ground and lies there, as if upon the sands of Hell, or perhaps Purgatory, just trying to process how things had come to this. There were only a few lines that Walt had held as being uncrossable, and one was to kill his brother in law. The thugs give him one of his barrels back, $11 million, and ask if there will be any problems, with an implication they'll happily kill Walt too. At this moment, Walt stands in silence before finally shaking hands with them, and in that instant...Walter White has ceased to be any semblance of a good person. His fall from grace has finally cost him his soul, just like the Gospels ask in Matthew 16, ""For what will it profit a man if he gains the whole world and forfeits his soul?" Within moments, Jesse is captured, and before it seems he'll be killed (he isn't), Walt turns and tells him that he was there when Jane overdosed and did nothing to help her. Another of Walt's unbreakable lines is no more, as Jesse was like a second son to him, and he leaves him to be tortured and possibly killed, but only after rubbing salt in the wound as it were.
Walt's empire has been destroyed, just like that lost kingdom of Ozymandias. There is almost nothing left, but the remnants of a once proud operation. The sands stretch around Walter and he begins his trek back to civilization, through the ruins of what he has spent the last five seasons building. However, things have not fully fallen apart yet. His son, off-camera, his son who is so adoring and worshipful of him has learned the truth and is also falling apart. When Skyler and Flynn return home, they know he should be with Hank, but he screams at them like a madman to pack only what they need...finally Skyler snaps and pulls a butcher knife, ordering him out of the house. She ends up slashing his hand open and he wrestles with her on the ground, until he gets the upper hand and his beloved son dives between them and calls the police, telling them that Walter is the one who pulled the knife. In that moment, Bryan Cranston's face is truly heartbroken, and this scene alone is deserving of an Emmy nomination. He flees his home, with his money, and grabs his daughter Holly as well.
When the police come and Walter calls again, he leaves Holly at a fire station with her address, after realizing at "mama" that he can never have family again and any attempt to force Holly to love him is doomed to fail. He knows the police will be tapping the call, so Walter does the only thing that may possibly save him from damnation when the cancer finally kills him...he rips into his wife. He calls her stupid, a bitch, and told her this sort of thing is what happens when you cross him. That he built everything up himself. To the police, it seems like he's being an abuser, but from the gorgeous acting with the body language between the two, on opposite ends of the phone, its apparent they both know this for what it is. For one last time, even though he's lost his family, Walter White is saving them from destruction. His ranting "confession", saves Skyler and his son from any of the consequences of the meth business, at least legally. He also confirms for her, even though he didn't do it as he implies, that Hank is dead and off to the side, Skyler's sister Marie, who was married to Hank, bursts into tears.
As the episode ends, Walter is being picked up by the van from his lawyer's guy who starts people with a new life. He looks down the vast barren stretch of desert road. Walter White, King of Kings of the meth business has been reduced to a wreck, alongside that of his empire which has faded away with the sands. He goes to take one last look at the surrounding area before he gets into the van, evoking the last lines of the famous poem, " boundless and bare, The lone and level sands stretch far away."
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;Such lines do describe last night's episode well, but it does not tie in to the desert technique of the show as well as Ozymandias does. When I saw the episode title, even before it began, I thought back to the advertisements with Walter reading it, "Look upon my works, ye Mighty and despair". It was not a portent of a good episode, at least for the touchy feely side of the show. What it was, however, was something that deserves a slew of Emmy awards. Spoilers ahead my friends, spoilers ahead.
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The story about Breaking Bad is primarily broken into three types. The first is that of crime; Walt as Heisenberg, is a meth drug lord and all that implies. The second is the story of Walter White's transformation from mild mannered family man, to ruthless kingpin Heisenberg. The third is Walter's relationship with his family, trying to hold on to it, despite the evil things he has done. Last night hit upon all three of these elements and tore them apart.
The episode began with a flashback to a simpler time, where Walt had to prepare himself to lie to his wife about cooking meth. We see him as the man he once was, the man who wanted to help his family with the drug money and the loving father who was incapable of easily betraying the trust of the love of his life. Yet that did not continue for long, as fans know. Cut forward in time and Walt is laying in the back of a bullet riddled car. Agent Gomez is dead. Hank, Walt's DEA brother in law is bleeding on the ground. As the white supremacists move in to kill Hank, Walt struggles from the car and begins to beg for Hank's life, "He's family!" In the past, this is where Walt would have managed one more deal and boy did Walt try, informing them about his $80 million and offering them the money if they would just spare his brother in law...this time however, Hank gives the most chilling line of the entire show, "You're one of the smartest men I know. Can't you tell he made up his mind ten minutes ago?" Then he turns his face to the white supremacists and utters one last line, dying with some dignity as he's killed mid sentence.
Walt tumbles to the ground and lies there, as if upon the sands of Hell, or perhaps Purgatory, just trying to process how things had come to this. There were only a few lines that Walt had held as being uncrossable, and one was to kill his brother in law. The thugs give him one of his barrels back, $11 million, and ask if there will be any problems, with an implication they'll happily kill Walt too. At this moment, Walt stands in silence before finally shaking hands with them, and in that instant...Walter White has ceased to be any semblance of a good person. His fall from grace has finally cost him his soul, just like the Gospels ask in Matthew 16, ""For what will it profit a man if he gains the whole world and forfeits his soul?" Within moments, Jesse is captured, and before it seems he'll be killed (he isn't), Walt turns and tells him that he was there when Jane overdosed and did nothing to help her. Another of Walt's unbreakable lines is no more, as Jesse was like a second son to him, and he leaves him to be tortured and possibly killed, but only after rubbing salt in the wound as it were.
Walt's empire has been destroyed, just like that lost kingdom of Ozymandias. There is almost nothing left, but the remnants of a once proud operation. The sands stretch around Walter and he begins his trek back to civilization, through the ruins of what he has spent the last five seasons building. However, things have not fully fallen apart yet. His son, off-camera, his son who is so adoring and worshipful of him has learned the truth and is also falling apart. When Skyler and Flynn return home, they know he should be with Hank, but he screams at them like a madman to pack only what they need...finally Skyler snaps and pulls a butcher knife, ordering him out of the house. She ends up slashing his hand open and he wrestles with her on the ground, until he gets the upper hand and his beloved son dives between them and calls the police, telling them that Walter is the one who pulled the knife. In that moment, Bryan Cranston's face is truly heartbroken, and this scene alone is deserving of an Emmy nomination. He flees his home, with his money, and grabs his daughter Holly as well.
When the police come and Walter calls again, he leaves Holly at a fire station with her address, after realizing at "mama" that he can never have family again and any attempt to force Holly to love him is doomed to fail. He knows the police will be tapping the call, so Walter does the only thing that may possibly save him from damnation when the cancer finally kills him...he rips into his wife. He calls her stupid, a bitch, and told her this sort of thing is what happens when you cross him. That he built everything up himself. To the police, it seems like he's being an abuser, but from the gorgeous acting with the body language between the two, on opposite ends of the phone, its apparent they both know this for what it is. For one last time, even though he's lost his family, Walter White is saving them from destruction. His ranting "confession", saves Skyler and his son from any of the consequences of the meth business, at least legally. He also confirms for her, even though he didn't do it as he implies, that Hank is dead and off to the side, Skyler's sister Marie, who was married to Hank, bursts into tears.
As the episode ends, Walter is being picked up by the van from his lawyer's guy who starts people with a new life. He looks down the vast barren stretch of desert road. Walter White, King of Kings of the meth business has been reduced to a wreck, alongside that of his empire which has faded away with the sands. He goes to take one last look at the surrounding area before he gets into the van, evoking the last lines of the famous poem, " boundless and bare, The lone and level sands stretch far away."
12 Years Later
"We are not the same people we were 12 years and 1 day ago". One of the speakers at the 9/11 memorial service in Shanksville, PA said that earlier today. I cannot help but pause to reflect upon those words, and how much it can mean. The world has changed in so many ways. A generation has known only war. A generation has never known an airport where you didn't have the TSA screening every passenger in order to "protect" them. A generation has never known a world without 9/11 and to them it has become as the Kennedy assassination has become to my generation and as Pearl Harbor became to my parents' generation.
Thursday, July 18, 2013
Catching Up
Facebook is one of the many social media sites that make it interesting to catch up with people you once knew. This evening, I got a friend request from a friend we'll call V. V. and I both went forward for baptism after our experiences at an American Baptist summer camp, I on one week and he on another. But we lost touch after the baptism they made us wait until the next fiscal quarter for, which was why it was exciting to have a friend request from him!
He's doing pretty well it seems, a stable job, friends, and all that. Being nosy, I looked under his About tab to see if he had a girlfriend and noticed his religious views "none". It was a bit of a blow, because I could remember how on fire he had been, far more so than I, outwardly at least. But hey, our former church didn't mind alienating a few people here and there and as a Baptist you believe in Once Saved, Always Saved...so it's not like you have any souls on your hands after you dunk'em.
Our most pivotal years in whether one remains a believer in Christ or not are between 14-17, the next most important range is the early 20s. V. like so many I know, apparently said "screw it". I don't know why and wish I did. But it made me cringe and want to cry, because I knew that my old church had managed to probably drive off another person.
He's doing pretty well it seems, a stable job, friends, and all that. Being nosy, I looked under his About tab to see if he had a girlfriend and noticed his religious views "none". It was a bit of a blow, because I could remember how on fire he had been, far more so than I, outwardly at least. But hey, our former church didn't mind alienating a few people here and there and as a Baptist you believe in Once Saved, Always Saved...so it's not like you have any souls on your hands after you dunk'em.
Our most pivotal years in whether one remains a believer in Christ or not are between 14-17, the next most important range is the early 20s. V. like so many I know, apparently said "screw it". I don't know why and wish I did. But it made me cringe and want to cry, because I knew that my old church had managed to probably drive off another person.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


